12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC
Milk Bar is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

1. Milk Bar

7.8
251 E 13th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · East Village · 711 tips and reviews

noskosnoskos: Just two words, CRACK PIE!

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

2. Four & Twenty Blackbirds

9.1
439 3rd Ave (at 8th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pie Shop · Gowanus · 224 tips and reviews

Kika G.Kika G: Never settle for a single slice. One should be Salty Honey, the other a seasonal fruit.

Little Pie Company is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

3. Little Pie Company

8.6
424 W 43rd St (btwn 9th & 10th Ave), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Hell's Kitchen · 101 tips and reviews

Karissa✨Karissa✨: Mississippi mud pie is awesome. So very chocolatey.

Pies 'n' Thighs is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

4. Pies 'n' Thighs

8.8
166 S 4th St (at Driggs Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · Williamsburg · 553 tips and reviews

Dan T.Dan Torres: Obviously the fried chicken, but don't leave without trying any of the pies.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

5. Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

8.9
185 Van Dyke St (at Ferris St), Brooklyn, NY
Pie Shop · Red Hook · 114 tips and reviews

Liz C.Liz Courtney: The Swingle - a key lime pie tart on a stick, dipped in dark chocolate, and frozen - is the greatest dessert ever invented.

Bubby's is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

6. Bubby's

8.8
120 Hudson St (btwn Franklin & Moore St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Tribeca · 527 tips and reviews

Tom H.Tom Halleran: Great brunch spot with innovative and delicious comfort food. The pies are a must! It goes without saying that you should be prepared to wait for a table.

Hill Country Chicken is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

7. Hill Country Chicken

1123 Broadway (at W 25th St), New York, NY
Fried Chicken Joint · NoMad · 326 tips and reviews

TomTom: Southern fried chicken done right! I prefer their original with skin. It's nice and crispy yet juicy. Biscuits are must. Their pies are just as good as their chicken if not better.

The Blue Stove is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

8. The Blue Stove

415 Graham Ave (btwn Withers and Frost St), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Williamsburg · 128 tips and reviews

Michael C.Michael Cadenas: The blackberry rhubarb pie will haunt you like a demon's whisper (in the best possible way)

Petee's Pie Company is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

9. Petee's Pie Company

9.0
61 Delancey St (btwn Allen & Eldridge St), New York, NY
Pie Shop · Lower East Side · 112 tips and reviews

Nick A.Nick Andlinger: I've eaten my fair share of pie, but this pie is spectacular. Especially the coconut custard 🔥🔥🔥

The Dutch is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

10. The Dutch

8.5
131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · SoHo · 457 tips and reviews

Trae F.Trae F: The banana cream pie with chocolate peanut butter ice cream was the perfect ending to a great meal.

Pie Corps is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

11. Pie Corps

7.8
77 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pie Shop · Greenpoint · 26 tips and reviews
Two Little Red Hens is one of 12 Perfect Places for Pie in NYC.

12. Two Little Red Hens

1652 2nd Ave (btwn E 85th & E 86th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Yorkville · 362 tips and reviews

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Excellent American-style bakery for pie, birthday cake, and moist, flavorful cupcakes.