- pizza
- nutella chocolate cake
- fashioned square
- good for groups
- good for dates
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Jonathan DavilaMay 10, 2014The round pies are delicious. As close to authentic Italian pizza as you're probably going to get.
- DevontaDecember 30, 2013Try the Old Fashion Pizza with Chicken, Spinach and Broccoli. Expensive but pretty good and light. The Sangria was decent.
- No Leftovers Jackie GebelJanuary 11, 2017Best pizza in FiDi! Right off Stone street- get a sheet pie and salad!
- Some of my favorite pizza in all of New York. Love sitting outside on Stone St
- Gary TorielloAugust 11, 2014Fantastic artisinal pizza. No slices. Sit down and manga at the outdoor cafe seating.
- Kmart FashionDecember 2, 2011If you’re looking for the best pizza south of Canal Street, this is it. Our tip: Try the $17 old fashioned. The lasagna is also spectacular.
- Vito GialloAugust 31, 2014Excellent pizza. The Italian waiter is super helpful and nice. Pretty cool spot outside
- Craig MiddletonAugust 27, 2014Quaint little pizza spot with big flavors. Definitely stop in for lunch.
- Subin LimAugust 7, 2014Only pizza place I know in the area with arugula as one of the topping choices. We order it every time.
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic - One of the best pies in NY
- Wei VaynMay 2, 2015Try the Sausage Pizza - #farewell lunch thank you guys!!!!!!! I will miss you all (via @Foodspotting)
- ChrystieJune 4, 2013Old Fashioned Square is where it's at. Sausage + Extra Onions = One Classy Friday Night in tastebud heaven.
- Henri BoudreauJanuary 25, 2018The old fashioned square pizza is tasty for sure (I had it with pepperoni, sausage and basil). However, it's overrated for the price. It will put you back $40. I found it too salty for my taste.
- Romain D.August 19, 2017The Aztec Sol cocktail (don julio tequila, mezcal, lime, tabasco) is quite strong! Food is good but service is rude and clumsy. To be expected in touristic areas!
- Can't go wrong with the old-fashioned style pizza. Don't forget the arugula!
- Mike BianchiJune 22, 2018No individual / round pies at lunch. Only after 5. Old fashioned pie is more than enough for 2, even 3 people, FYI. Not a great place for lunch.
- Jessica de OliveiraJune 18, 2016Perfect for those Sunday hangovers. I always get the white cheese pie.
- Sri VNovember 19, 2015They do NOT go light with the toppings here. Fantastic pizza... excellent service
- Kristin DaltonMarch 5, 2015Romantic, grab a seat at the bar, order some wine and split a pizza with your love!
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic (via @Foodspotting)
- Ed PodojilSeptember 21, 2014Best pizza in FiDi though usually crowded. Order online and eat somewhere else
- Sara JohnsonJune 4, 2012Great place to grab lunch after Ellis island. The food is great, the location is amazing!
- The onions are red and pair remarkably well with the sausage.
- Noah LucasOctober 23, 2011Best pizza EVER:Stone St. Pizza. Old fashioned square with pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, and arugula.
- Arrabbiata pizza Is great! I love the sweet and spicy peppers on it. A must try.
- montserrat hernandezNovember 24, 2014Pizza is made with fresh ingredients and the service is excellent
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Meatballs And Garlic
- bianca buskettaJune 6, 2010Sit outside on the Stone Street benches and order from their new menu - different types of ravioli and the linguine with mussels is awesome!
- Danny PayneJuly 1, 2018Pizza was good, not great. We had the old fashion and it was a little greasy and soft on the bottom. Way overpriced for so many pizza options in the area.
- TenantKing.comAugust 6, 2014People will come here for the Pizza, but leave raving about the nutella chocolate cake.