- pizza
- nutella chocolate cake
- fashioned square
- good for groups
- good for dates
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Subin LimAugust 7, 2014Only pizza place I know in the area with arugula as one of the topping choices. We order it every time.
- Wei VaynMay 2, 2015Try the Old Fashioned Pizza W/Pepperoni - #farewell lunch thank you guys!!!!!!! I will miss you all (via @Foodspotting)
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic - One of the best pies in NY
- Vito GialloAugust 31, 2014Excellent pizza. The Italian waiter is super helpful and nice. Pretty cool spot outside
- ChrystieJune 4, 2013Old Fashioned Square is where it's at. Sausage + Extra Onions = One Classy Friday Night in tastebud heaven.
- Sri VNovember 19, 2015They do NOT go light with the toppings here. Fantastic pizza... excellent service
- Romain D.August 19, 2017The Aztec Sol cocktail (don julio tequila, mezcal, lime, tabasco) is quite strong! Food is good but service is rude and clumsy. To be expected in touristic areas!
- Jessica de OliveiraJune 18, 2016Perfect for those Sunday hangovers. I always get the white cheese pie.
- Can't go wrong with the old-fashioned style pizza. Don't forget the arugula!
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Sausage And Garlic (via @Foodspotting)
- Sharon ManApril 2, 2018Great, hearty pizza and chicken parmesan. Nutellatini is delicious and potent.
- Craig MiddletonAugust 27, 2014Quaint little pizza spot with big flavors. Definitely stop in for lunch.
- Harish HoonJanuary 29, 2015The pizza here with pepperoni and onions might be the best I've ever had. Period.
- Wei VaynMay 2, 2015Try the Sausage Pizza - #farewell lunch thank you guys!!!!!!! I will miss you all (via @Foodspotting)
- Arrabbiata pizza Is great! I love the sweet and spicy peppers on it. A must try.
- Sara JohnsonJune 4, 2012Great place to grab lunch after Ellis island. The food is great, the location is amazing!
- I've never had a bite here that wasn't fantastic. Lasagna was a terrific lunch option if you're looking to try something other than pizza.
- Michael Fox-RabinovitzJune 28, 2016Pretty solid pizza, although portions tend to run on the large side
- Adam KubanAugust 16, 2011The old-fashioned pizza, basically a grandma (or "nonna") pie, is insanely great here. It's THE pizza to get, plain or topped. A riot of crust textures, crisp, chewy, springy-fried. Read more
- montserrat hernandezNovember 24, 2014Pizza is made with fresh ingredients and the service is excellent
- bianca buskettaJune 6, 2010Sit outside on the Stone Street benches and order from their new menu - different types of ravioli and the linguine with mussels is awesome!
- Miroki TongMay 3, 2015Pizza's delicious, but service was rude, and seemed eager to be rid of us. I get we came late, but then say that you're closing, instead of seating us, then treating us like we're wasting time
- Joshua KehnOctober 23, 2011Order the Stone St. Pizza. Old fashioned square with pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, and arugula.
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Pepperoni, Meatballs And Garlic
- Gary TorielloAugust 11, 2014Fantastic artisinal pizza. No slices. Sit down and manga at the outdoor cafe seating.
- TenantKing.comAugust 6, 2014People will come here for the Pizza, but leave raving about the nutella chocolate cake.
- The onions are red and pair remarkably well with the sausage.
- Ed PodojilSeptember 21, 2014Best pizza in FiDi though usually crowded. Order online and eat somewhere else
- Try the Old Fashioned Pizza With Sausage, Peppers And Onions