Antica Pesa
Italian Restaurant$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
"fireplace on a Chesterfield sofa"(6 Tips)
"Amatriciana and Cacio&Pepe"(4 Tips)
"Crudo e Buffala Croccante to start."(2 Tips)
"Crudo e Bufala Croccante & the Tannarelli cacio e pepe."(2 Tips)
81 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for dates
- fireplaces
- trendy
- croccante
- amatriciana
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Absolutely fantastic authentic Roman food. If you're up for a great Italian dinner and meeting a few celebrities (such as Madonna & Leo Di Caprio, to just name a few; then Antica Pesa is the place 4U.
Joseph MarchettiJanuary 23, 2016One of the best Italian meals I have ever had. I felt like I was in Italy Roberto the Manager ordered for us. The Cace' e Pepe and guancale pasta was superb . Highly recommended. Excellent service
Liz TanJanuary 27, 2018There are tons of really good Italian restaurants in the area, this one is not the best of the bunch. It’s so-so. You will feel like you’re in Manhattan - all the character, none of the charm.
Meghan KathleenNovember 13, 2012Everything tastes really fresh and the environment is really cozy (despite the really tall ceilings). If you get there early, sit by the fireplace with a glass of wine.
Andrea BarrezuetaOctober 9, 2014Delicious wines or cocktails by the fire while you wait for your table. Then a very simple but incredibly delicious spaguetti Cacio e Pepe. Def get why some celebrities love this place.
Lucy AppertJanuary 12, 2014Such an amazing treat for the senses! You'll feel like you're in Rome. The lamb chops and salt and pepper and and cheese pasta are transformative, as is the tiramisu and prosecco in chilled glasses.
BillyNovember 30, 2014Good for infante dates for those who loveeee Italian. They have one restaurant in Rome and one in Brooklyn, so you know it's authentic!
Wesley KevinMarch 17, 2013The uovo is excellent! We had a great time dinning here and the owner is very friendly! He greeted us at the table towards the end of the meal. I definitely recommend this place for second dates.
Mindy RomeroOctober 26, 2014Great place. Tried to walk in for dinner on a Saturday night. Tia the hostess tried to seat us and couldn't but gave us each a glass of champagne to make up for it! Great service!
Christina NawabiSeptember 16, 2016Pasta is really good. And so is the delicious bread they bring before your meal. Very cute atmosphere. Kinda pricy though.
I have eaten here more than most, I have sent 50+ people here and we all agree its the best Italian food period. Also we are undefeated when eating here before fights so the place is lucky!!- Claire LeeNovember 24, 2012Stumbling upon this 1.5 month old restaurant/bar was like a dream. Sipping on a delicious custom cocktail (with chai tea in it) by the fireplace on a Chesterfield sofa is the best. thing. ever.
amNewYorkOctober 29, 2013Halloween drink alert! The Buon Spirito here may summon the dead: Courvoisier Cognac, JDK & Sons Orange Liqueur, mole spicy chocolate bitters and muddled blackberries may make for a spooky night. $15.
Sam PezzulloAugust 22, 2013I was blown away by this place. The food, atmosphere, and service were all stellar. It's definitely a cut above the other Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, and even Manhattan!
Jenna DrapkinJuly 27, 2015great place to bring your parents. don't forget the mozzarella appetizer and the seafood is always delicious.
Carol EganFebruary 8, 2013Impeccable service, the mozzarella with FILO dough app, and lamb chops were divine. Love this restaurant! It's gorgeous, and we forgot we were in Brooklyn :-) it's not the usual williamsburg rude!
Ajay DivakaranJuly 14, 2013Insanely long wait (despite having a reservation) but great food. Definitely worth checking out their lamb chops. Just be prepared to wait 35+ minutes to be seated
Crystal ZhengDecember 17, 2013It's a beautiful place. The fireplace facing the bar is awesome in the winter while waiting for people.
Leland SJune 10, 2013Delicious lasagna with big chunks of chopped, braised lamb. So much more satisfying than the standard ground-meat version. Skip the tiramisu, though.
Dana FlynnNovember 12, 2014Love the cocktails, though my favorite was recently taken of the menu sadly (Dana's passion). Fabulous all'amatriciana
Giulia MSeptember 8, 2019Burrata appetizer, ragù d’anatra. Most waiters are actually from Italy. Great venue too. Will be back!- Justin OrgelDecember 30, 2012Lots of Italian schtick w/ focus on customer service (ie you are Tony Soprano). Crudo e Buffala Croccante to start. Sample Roman pasta staples Cacip e Pepe & Amatriciana. Secondi is average.
Piper GoodeveFebruary 24, 2013Absolutely the best food I've had in ages. Great staff and hip atmosphere. The fireplace was great on a cold winter night.
Kate WagnerDecember 28, 2012Food was good. Not as good as PTs but the service and atmosphere were amazing and having lived in Rome I felt like I could be back in trestavere due to the ambiance of the place.
Keren AtzlanNovember 18, 2021Would like to come back and try other dishes. Rigatoni was the fave of the bunch. Very cute vibe and nice wine!
Everything we ate that night Pasta , chicken. Can’t wait to go back just love the place- The Festive AnthropologistSeptember 9, 2014Impress your date meal selections: Crudo e Bufala Croccante & the Tannarelli cacio e pepe. #youarewelcome
wow!!!! Amazing. Everything from the service to the food to the atmosphere. Definitely a keeper.
LA BoshkinSeptember 15, 2013The best host, the best food! Every dish was the best thing I've ever had and they're SO NICE here!
John ShiApril 14, 2019~8pm 4/13/2019. Slow and disorganized service. Course quality mixed: Pane Porchetta app and Tiramisu dessert excellent. Anchovy pasta was not made with any anchovy
Marideny TavarezJanuary 3, 2016Such a wonderful little find. Always a plus for places that are open on holidays.
Júnia ProcópioMarch 18, 2016Loved this place! Amazing Valentine´s Day dinner, great staff! Looking foward to come back soon:)
Danny NathanSeptember 27, 2016We had a fantastic meal here. The octopus and the pasta were clear stand outs.- Viola MelMelMelDecember 13, 2012Amatriciana and Cacio&Pepe both amazing...the withe chocolate ice creme to die for!!!!
David McGillivrayFebruary 28, 2016Good food but the clientele felt like we were in Murray Hill - lots of bros and guys in bad suits. Super cheesy.
Love love love everything about this place. It's like having a little piece of Rome in Williamsburg.
AmateurConciergeJune 3, 2013Excellent Italian hospitality. Solid food but a tad pricey on some items
Best restaurant of the year - hands down. Ask for Gabrielle and Andrea's tables... Unless I'm there, then leave us alone:)
Sterling ProfferOctober 16, 2012Two brothers run the show. One in front, one in the kitchen. And yes, they make their own olive oil.
169 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 6:00 PM (Show more)
- Tue–Thu, Sun
- 6:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 6:00 PM–11:00 PM
(347) 763-2635
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Antica Pesa
Appears on 475 lists
Created by Rana Rouhana
166 items • 518 followers
Created by Erica Choi
205 items • 27 followersJason's Top 50 Restaurants To Try In 2013
Created by Jason Feirman
48 items • 30 followers
