Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Blue Heaven
Breakfast Spot and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$
Key West
"Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!!"(33 Tips)
"Best key lime pie I've had and Banana Heaven is absolute perfection."(78 Tips)
"Lobster grilled cheese sandwich was divine. 2 words - Banana Heaven."(10 Tips)
"BLT Benedict was amazing as was the lobster omlete."(9 Tips)
404 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- key lime pie
- breakfast food
- brunch food
- pancakes
- blt benedict
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Best breakfast on the Island! Be prepared to wait at least an hour but well worth it. Use the time to browse next door at Besame Mucho or hang at the bar & catch some live music.
Jeff EscalanteJuly 8, 2013Without a doubt one of the best restaurants I've been to ever. Beautiful atmosphere and food. Banana bread is incredible, definitely go for the key lime pie as well. Photo is "after" on the pie : )
Food NetworkOctober 2, 2014Blue Heaven Restaurant inspired Jimmy Buffett to write the song “Blue Heaven Rendezvous.” Whether you’re here for musical inspiration or not, the Caribbean cuisine is worth staying for. Read more
Timothy BrewerApril 9, 2013Great FOOD & SERVICE. Loved the Key Lime pie. Awesome Benedicts. Blueberry with pecan Pancakes are excellent. And for Key West the prices are reasonable. Plus they often have live entertainment.
Don KernerApril 11, 2017Sunday brunch incredible! Worth the wait. Lobster Benedict and shrimp and grits excellent. Bar tenders really knkw how to take care of you. Want unique spot to eat and drink his is the place.
Alex RainertApril 22, 2013Great spot. Solid Bloody Mary and excellent Key Lime Pie (it's like 6 inches tall!) Finally, they do a solid Lobster Benedict and if they happen to have their BLT Benedict (L = lobstah!), get it!
Julia GMay 6, 2015The atmosphere is relaxing. The food is pricey but worth every penny. The yellowtail snapper is delicious. The cocktails are refreshing as well. Try the Mango Fantango
Jessica EJanuary 2, 2018I went at noon on a week day. The wait for 2 people was an hour. I loved the ambiance here. The outdoor area is so cute/shady, and they had live music. Bloody mary's and breakfast were good.
Jordan GrosecloseNovember 20, 2014Best breakfast in Key West! Whatever you order (breakfast..heck, lunch also) you should ask for a side of the famous Key Lime Hollandaise. Spectacular. They are known for their various egg benedicts.- Laura AldridgeJanuary 14, 2017Relaxed outdoor seating, friendly staff and gorgeous food! Can see why it is rated highly! Lobster grilled cheese sandwich was divine. 2 words - Banana Heaven. You MUST have this for dessert!
Mercedes SayagoApril 15, 2016One of my favorite spots in Key West! The food is delicious and the ambiance is great! I recommend it to everyone who has the opportunity to go!
Reagan BarbosaMarch 28, 2018Lobster Benedict with lime hollandaise sauce was amazing!! Banana Heaven was delish, and better than the key lime pie. I think there are other places here in Key West with better Key Lime Pie.
Dolores GutierrezOctober 28, 2016Blue Heaven has it all, Ambient, Service and the FOOD, ohh the food! We will be coming back to try their brunch!!! Bon Appetite!!
Oriana SequeraAugust 29, 2014I got the egg Benedict's with Lobster and Avocado and were delicious!!! Great for breakfast. They also have live music. Nice and relaxed ambiance.
Marcel P.November 23, 2014amazing place. lobster benedict is delicious, blueberry pancakes taste like heaven, omelettes are awesome and the staff is fun and super friendly
KCJune 12, 2017Had the eggs Benedict with the sirloin. The lime hollandaise sauce is delicious! Pancakes are fluffy and homemade. The rooster makes good company.
Nina SundarNovember 5, 2014Very great food and service! Friendly atmosphere! My fav breakfast spot in key west! I ordered lobster blt on the homemade white bread. Tried the homemade banana bread so soft & sweet!!!
Izabela MJanuary 22, 2016Great atmosphere with decent live music. Super long dining wait times. If all you're after is key lime pie and/or drinks, grab a seat at the bar.
Debbie HilliardOctober 19, 2019Awesome restaurant! Fish with Beurre blanc sauce is amazing!! Great little gift shop with local artist creations! Highly recommend! ❤️❤️
Leo OliveiraApril 30, 2013Amazing place to chill, get brunch and play ping-pong! Order Lobster-Shrimp Benedict and their ridiculous Key-Lime Pie
HeatherJuly 31, 2012lobster omlette was the best thing i have ever eatten! in my opinion the best restaurant in key west.......Home made bread, relaxing enviroment and friendly wait staff!
Maddie LippincottMarch 15, 2019This is THE breakfast place in Key West. Get their banana bread, eggs benedict with key lime hollendaise sauce, and fresh fruit. Very busy, though, so go as early as possible.
Sharon BrittonMay 1, 2016Loved the Breakfast Tostadas and Lobster BLT. Hour and a half wait on a Sunday morning but with Mimosas Bloody Mary's great music and people it flew right by.
- Thomas GuibasJanuary 19, 2017Very good food with cool vibe and location has had a varied history from boxing arena to cockfights. Service was excellent.
Had the local lobster special. Made the same as their yellow tail snapper, it was amazing. The cappalenni was great. Their Key Lime pie is good though its meringue, I prefer whipped cream.- Kathy RedpathMay 25, 2015If you want a casual (and shady) outdoor cafe, this is the place to go! Get there early and be sure to try the mahi mahi ! Caprese salad was yummy but overpriced, good selection of wines.
Rachel SwendsrudMarch 27, 2014The best food i had the whole week on vacation. All the deserts melted in your mouth. The key lime pie actually was the best we tried. And the Yellowtail dinner was incredible.
Steve HannemanDecember 14, 2012This should be a required stop when visiting Key West. Ate here a couple of times this week. Lobster benedict, yellowtail snapper, key lime pie, mimosas, mojitos and banana heaven were all fantastic.!
Mohamed EisaJanuary 11, 2018One of the best breakfast places in the island, the lobster Benedict is a MUST-TRY. You won't be disappointed.
My very favorite place on the entire planet! Try the eggs Benedict with lime hollandaise sauce, Key West pink shrimp, and grilled asparagus. This place is (Blue) Heaven on Earth!
Behrad EatsNovember 15, 2013By far the best Key Lime Pie you will find! Topped with Meringue on a graham cracker crust with freshly squeezed lime juice.
- Maddie LippincottMarch 8, 2019INCREDIBLE banana bread--whatever you get, make sure you get this is a side. Best place for brunch on the island but be there early. They get busy VERY quickly.
Meric Akcay DunnJuly 6, 2018Amazing food and atmosphere. Tried BBQ shrimp and loved it! Yellow tail snapper was also sublime! 🤩👍🏻
- Hande AksoySeptember 4, 2016Start with Lobster Benedict finish with key lime pie!! You won't regret!! Super lovely place, nice garden..
courtney choateFebruary 21, 2016Very busy on a Saturday morning. Banana bread was delicious, though my omelette and the dropped eggs appeared rushed in the kitchen. Service was great and fun atmosphere.
Daniel JonesMarch 25, 2016The white cheddar shrimp and grits was incredible! We had a 2 hour wait, but it was well worth it. We just sat at the bar having some mimosas :)
JillAugust 23, 2013Brunch with the roosters!! Lobster Benedict ~ dont ask the $ just get it!!! ;) key lime pie ~ no matter how full you are just get it ~ you can always share! MUST experience while in Key West!!
Richard RevillaJanuary 4, 2017Make sure you sit outside for the experience otherwise the food is average. Bloody Mary's do hit the spot.
Charlie BuscemiOctober 20, 2012the most amazing breakfast. The Lobster Benedict is to die for. The blueberry pancakes are foodgasmic, careful though...the blueberries are so juicy they'll squirt and make you squirt.
Ellen BraApril 7, 2019Live music with nice «Key West vibe» garden tables. The food is EXCELLENT. We had the fish if the day, Jamaican shrimps and the key lime pie.
carla borsoiJuly 9, 2022A classic spot with vegan and veggie options. I have been coming since 1995. Be prepared to dine with the chickens and roosters.
McKinzie TurnerNovember 24, 2018The key lime pie is to die for!!!! Best scallops I’ve ever had as well!!! PSA: the black and white cat is allergic to seafood and will only eat steak!
Erik Traveling-MystroMay 31, 2019The BLT eggs benny with avocado and a side of breakfast potatoes. Complete with a hibiscus mimosa💆🏼♂️🙌🏼👌🏻
Joseph LJune 30, 2016The vibe is super cool and fun. The food was mediocre. I had to send back my lobster benedict, the lobster was inedible rubber. The blueberry pancakes were delicious though.
Elizabeth O'LearyJanuary 4, 2017Usually a long wait for brunch. Leave your name, get a Bloody Mary and go for a walk. The lobster bacon omelette is amazing
David GilesJanuary 22, 2012Wait is usually long, but definitely worth it! Everyone congregates on one side of the bar - go to the back side for shorter service lines and open seating in a garden setting. Great Bloody Mary's!
KathrynAugust 6, 2012Great place for breakfast! Outdoors under the trees. Chickens running around make it fun. Lobster Benedict and the shrimp and grits...yum! Must go when in Key West!- Brian UnverzagtJanuary 30, 20152nd best key lime pie I've had food is wonderful cool music but be ready to wait...limited reservations
Charlotte CMarch 31, 2023The Banana Heaven is where it’s at, far superior than their key lime pie. The pie may have a gigantic sail enticing in photos but taste cannot back up the photo.
1,779 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Blue Heaven is a real Key West favorite serving breakfast, lunch, and fine dining in the evenings, known for Caribbean flavors, live music, and funky setting.
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–10:30 PM
(305) 296-8666
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 770 lists
Created by Travel Channel
200 items • 9,609 followers
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 221 followers
America's 50 Best Eggs Benedict Dishes
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 161 followers