See all
1,771 photos

Carnegie Deli

(Now Closed)

Deli, Sandwich Spot, and American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Carnegie Deli

261 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Tonia Loran-GalbanFebruary 21, 2013
Huge sandwiches!! Get one and share
Nichole FavreauJuly 2, 2013
Waiter said we get free piece of cheesecake and recommended strawberry.when sandwich was done he brought said cake.we were charged, and cashier said he must have been joking.not going back.
Nathan LMarch 17, 2012
Best share your sandwich!! They are massive
Ben ButlerOctober 25, 2012
Save room for the cheescake!
Dorian LJuly 9, 2011
The portions are huge, so bring your hunger on!!! Cash only
Peter GregsonDecember 3, 2009
don't eat the day before, have the open face rueben then cheesecake. you won't be able to move, but it's all good.
Max PerryDecember 30, 2016
Farewell...
Gustavo LadeiraDecember 23, 2011
The tuna panini sandwich is delicious!
Jane NoerJanuary 2, 2011
Delicious - strawberrycheesecake and pastrami sandwich a must try ;)
Jonathan RyanMarch 27, 2013
Just eat pastrami is incredible
H AJune 6, 2011
Overpriced, overrated. But because it's so famous it may be with going to once in your life just to see what it's like and be stunned by the MOUNTAIN of food they pile on your plate.
Greg PalominoMarch 18, 2012
Love the pickles! Try 'em!
James SmithDecember 12, 2013
Do yourself a favor and don't order delivery to a hotel. We finally got our food ninety minutes and ten phone calls later and, big surprise, it was cold. Totally inept at delivering to a hotel.
FoodSherpas.comSeptember 24, 2013
Try the Chicken Ceaser Salad
James SimsAugust 16, 2011
Rude waiters add to the authentic NYC vibe. Don't be afraid of the sandwich sizes... just dig in.
David A. Hawkins, CPAApril 21, 2012
Chocolate babka to-die-for.
Katie RyanMay 29, 2012
One time deal- huge portion sandwich with only meat, kind of a let down. Too big to eat on your own and it's an expensive split fee.
Stephanie RosadoSeptember 19, 2013
The WORST cheesecake I have ever had in my life. Super dry. Not enough strawberry sauce...12 bucks...huge slice but NOT worth it. Trust me. Go to Eileen's special cheesecake or to Junior's.
Brad KavinDecember 29, 2015
Pastrami sandwich
Glen GilmoreMarch 23, 2013
Been here 5+ times
At least once!
🚡 Chris MarraDecember 24, 2009
The hot pastrami sandwich is delicious. Split it unless you have an ambitious stomach, but its a must-try.
Nana NamiMarch 27, 2016
Woody Allen + Cheesecake
Erhan ImamogluJuly 23, 2016
Fries and Cole slaw. However not worth waiting in line for an hour.
Travis HolcombJanuary 26, 2015
Chocolate egg cream
Arnoud AalbersbergNovember 24, 2011
Be civil, share a plate :-) what a cool deli this is!
Katie AllenJanuary 18, 2014
Good food, but way over priced. It is NYC and it is tourist trap --- but $40 for an open faced sandwich and a glass of iced tea?!?!
AubreyJune 26, 2012
Cash only! But there is a ATM in the back.
Nikos FotouJanuary 31, 2016
Deli. Pastrami
Fluying ✅November 9, 2010
For sure, best cheesecake in NY. Un must!!!
Cristina AlonsoSeptember 19, 2012
best pastrami on the world!
Anthony TApril 10, 2012
I think it was rude of the server to basically tell my friend to leave because he didn't want to eat, just because it's in ny. I think it's pretty dumb never again would I come back such a shame
FoodSherpas.comJanuary 25, 2013
Try the Hot Pastrami
Wes KovalMarch 2, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Pickles Pickles Pickles
icNovember 5, 2011
one must try the Woody Allen sandwich!!!
Ariel SchpolianskyMarch 27, 2015
Nice fast food
John BuntingApril 29, 2018
This placed closed down on 12/31/2016, 😔
David ElrodMay 20, 2014
Woody Allen. Get it.
Carlos Jimenez MayaOctober 12, 2011
They don't take credit card! Cash only!! What the f....! Huge orders!!
Casandra SOctober 18, 2012
Combos are HUGE!!!!!
Jason SchenckJune 6, 2012
Best Cheesecake in NYC.
EduardoSeptember 8, 2014
Woody Allen, definitely
Pierre LaromiguiereDecember 2, 2011
The beast! NYC cheese cake... for 12... at least :)
Emily RosenDecember 28, 2012
Matzo ball soup & roast beef= HEAVEN
Marcelo AlbagllOctober 9, 2011
Try the Corned Beef - Pra terminar a dieta.
FoodSherpas.comFebruary 20, 2012
Try the Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Andrea BlundaMay 25, 2012
Best cheesecake in Manhattan
Gene ChuangOctober 7, 2012
Adam Sandler sang about this place in his Hanukkah Song!
Larissa VazOctober 23, 2012
The world's best cheesecake!!!!!
SimonMay 8, 2014
Went there based on the reviews here. My faith in 4square reviews has been shaken. Chicken salad sandwich was dry and tasteless, burger likewise. Crazy overpriced.
Miguel GalarzaAugust 22, 2014
Corn beef:-)

1 2 3 4 5 6

1,771 Photos

Carnegie Deli

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Carnegie Deli

Appears on 724 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.