Casa Nonna
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria$$$$
Garment District, New York
74 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The service, the fresh pastas and sauces, the monthly city-themed prix fixe -- all amazing. Add to that the great atmosphere of deep cushioned booths and high ceilings.
Mike FriedlichJanuary 31, 2017The free bread may be the best I've ever had. The calamari is also good but they dont give u much. Pollo Panini, which has Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Prosciutto, and basil aioli is amazing.
Andrea De La CruzFebruary 2, 2013Kuddos to the staff and Executive Chef Julio as well as the Sous Chef Atilio everything was Delicious!!!!! Must try Pollo Scarpariello and the Octopus Salad!! To die for!!!
IrmaZandl ZandlSlantSeptember 24, 2019Food is excellent. Not my typical neighborhood but if in this far western part of midtown I would definitely come back. Restaurant is huge but great place to have a conversation. Good service.
Elizabeth BursteinMarch 24, 2018The squash wheat pasta is phenomenal, the bread and burrata are so good, the mulchepulcino wine is incred. Love this place.
Zoë E.November 14, 2016Can't say enough good things. Stick with the classics - Spaghetti Pomodoro and a side of eggplant parm - but don't sleep on the spaghetti squash side. It's truffly & might even be better than pasta.
Sam SNovember 7, 2015The best service I've had in NYC, hands down. Friendly, polite, courteous. And the food is delicious too. Can't go wrong.
Halstead PropertyOctober 18, 2012A Midtown West gem. Get cozy with a buffalo mozzarella pizza made with homemade white truffle oil and authentic Northern Italian burgundy truffles and a hearty glass of white wine.
CompassApril 25, 2014Hit the restaurant for a game day or lunchtime pizza, or make a bigger night of it with foodie-appoved dishes from truffled pasta to salads topped with honey balsamic vinagraitte.
Akshata KaliaApril 3, 2016Came here on a Saturday evening. The service was decent - could be better if the waiter didn't ask us multiple times if we were done. The pasta was just amazing. Get the cheesecake for dessert!
eric bornemannApril 2, 2021Big and decent red sauce joint close to the theater district. Good happy hour for getting in and out fast.
Sarah GosnellJuly 18, 2013Great happy hour! $6 glass of wine and a choice of a complimentary small appetizer. I tried the meatball slider with smoked mozzarella, delish!
Vivian VoMarch 6, 2015Plenty of space - they even have a private room. Not sure if available to rent for birthdays?
Shannon LindellJuly 15, 2018The signature cocktails are delicious as well as the seasonal offerings.
Everything, esp the apps. meatballs are to die for. Foccacia bread is so addicting.
Todd BouldinSeptember 18, 2013The complimentary bread, the chicken parm, the meatball and anything with their spectacular marina sauce is great.
Vonatron LFebruary 20, 2016Wonderful happy hour on wine, pizza, and cocktails, despite being being Port Authority
Order the Italian soda. It's passion fruit. Also homemade focaccia is amazing.
Anthony SpicciatiAugust 7, 2014Pasta dishes are great here, pretty creative. Can be slow at lunch, so plan for extra time.
Michael BaumrindNovember 30, 2013Food is great. Service is pretty good. Location is somewhat out of the way. Makes it easier to get a table
Our Man On The GroundSeptember 9, 2011Recommend trying the tasty pizzas from their wood-fired pizza oven or the great value Happy Hour in the bar at the front. Read more
Steve DuboisJanuary 17, 2014Was great! Service and food were top shelf. Great place to bring a date.
Alfred M.February 7, 2015great place for large groups. had plenty of open tables at 8pm on a Friday.
Like a college sports bar with food. Has a chain-restaurant vibe. Patrons are first year corporate pawns and mid-town prisoners.
- Will ArnoneMarch 3, 2013Fennel sausage and veal meatballs - order both and you will not regret it - delicious !
#1 place to get a quick drink and do a quick meeting in #midtown. love you #casa!
Jessica J. TJanuary 9, 20141. Meatballs 2. Polenta 3. Buccatini 4. Cappuccino. Four steps to heaven.
Jean-Baptiste KaloyaAugust 18, 2016The food was very good (pizza) but the service was absolutely terrible. The waiter was hardly pleasant and made it obvious we were not interesting customers (thinking primary for his tip).
Raj S.August 23, 2011Great place to bring a client or business contact. They also have a decent sized bar.
Come for happy hour for free bites of appetizers and $5 drinks.
231 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Casa Nonna, which means “Grandmother’s House” in Italian, is as open and inviting as you would expect from our name. Located just south of the theater district, Casa Nonna is our tribute to authentic flavors and quality ingredients that are the hallmark of true Italian cuisine...
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Sat
- 4:30 PM–9:30 PM
(212) 736-3000
View menu on https://www.winendine.com/casa-nonna-2/menu-official
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"Great pizza, cozy athmosphere, very crowded for dinner, always a wait at the door"
Duygu İnceöz - 9.0
"Octopus appetizer was great! Special gnocchi was awesome. Wine was overpriced/mediocre."
Aashna S - 9.0
"You'd never know about this place unless you were walking by. Quaint and romantic spot for date night. The waiters are super friendly and have great recommendations. Try the carbonara!"
Nicolette Romero
Places people like to go after Casa Nonna
- 8.9
"My favorite venue to see live music! Always fun and easy to get to."
Naquel Stevens - 8.4
"Always my favourite place to be when I am in NY. Love the dynamic."
Atika Al-Bimani - 7.0
"Huge beautiful theater with amazing sound and great seating. Tons of concessions, but if you want more for your bucks go to Chipotle, Quiznos, DD and other nearby locations."
✨#IamRomdelacrème✨
Appears on 167 lists
NYC Restaurant Week 2014 – Uptown
Created by American Express
199 items • 63 followers
NYC Summer Restaurant Week 2014 - Uptown
Created by American Express
191 items • 15 followers
