See all
169 photos

Croton Reservoir Tavern

Bar, American Restaurant, and Music Venue$$$$

Garment District, New York

Save

6.2^/10

227

ratings

"Great donw stairs happy hour."(11 Tips)
"Zero cell service in downstairs bar area."(3 Tips)
"Make sure to win the Arrested Development Trivia in February!!"(3 Tips)
"Lobster roll was delicious, though do bring a sweater."(2 Tips)

47 Tips and reviews

Filter:

happy hour
trivia
good for groups
brunch food
candy
bar
quiet
salads
alcohol
salmon
lunch
dinner
disco
artichoke dip
peppers
events
(11 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Stephanie PierucciniFebruary 15, 2012
Nice bar with booth seating as well. Decent beer selection on tap and a full wall of liquor choices. Plenty of TVs playing the local NY games. Food looked good. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Lauren DJanuary 31, 2017
Their whiskey is good, the decor is cool, & that's even before you discover that they have a brick-room bar downstairs! Also their lobster bisque is quite nice.
Christina ChinDecember 14, 2015
Classic American food. Salmon dish was excellent and healthy, artichoke dip yummy..rarely gone wrong here, no matter what you order
Upvoted 1 week ago
Andrew CApril 18, 2018
Across the street from Bryant Park, so the happy hour crowd was very typical midtown bro-y... nothing special in the standard happy hour (from what I remember)
Michael G.September 21, 2018
Decent spot for after work drinks. They have a casual downstairs room with tables and room to stand by the bar.
AlisonNovember 12, 2017
Great atmosphere and great drinks! Great spot for a happy hour.
Croton Reservoir TavernJuly 23, 2011
Come and join the disco party tonight it will be fun. first 100 people get a free shot. party starts at 8pm don't miss this party it will be one of the best this summer. expecting over 300 people
Jacob FordJune 6, 2017
Happy hour is—apparently—only valid downstairs. But the bar down there is nice and secret.
James KiernanMarch 19, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Decent pub fare and good drinks but just don’t let them sit you in the basement. Free WiFi.
Mimi TakanoAugust 17, 2015
Lobster roll was delicious, though do bring a sweater. It's freezing in here!
Brok HowardJanuary 27, 2014
Steak Burger is awesome! If upstairs is packed, try downstairs.
David BrahlerMarch 29, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Head straight to the back of the bar and downstairs during Happy Hour.
Croton Reservoir TavernApril 1, 2011
Don't miss our Annual Guilty Pleasures Party - Sat 4/2 (8pm-2am)DJ + Cover Band playing all the songs you hate... to admit you love :)FREE shot to 1st 100 people & FREE Candy.. to help ease the guil
Dee PhunkFebruary 25, 2012
Looking for somewhere decent to pre-game before going to an event @ MSG? Look no further. Happy hour M-F, 5-9pm downstairs.
Lindsay FranzoniOctober 23, 2015
Has a decent happy hour but super loud, lots of midtown suits.
Sephaie TsangFebruary 14, 2014
Awesome selection of whiskey! :)
Matthew CaldecuttAugust 22, 2011
If you're there for a lunch meeting, ask to be seated downstairs. It's quieter and there's wi-fi. Read more
Tracy SolorzanoFebruary 20, 2016
Expensive but good for a work lunch or dinner
Croton Reservoir TavernJuly 20, 2012
Brunch every Saturday! Unlimited Mimosas, Bellinies and Bloody Marys! Think no further!
Pete RushingSeptember 10, 2011
Loved it. Came for 9-11 10yr reunion. Service was great. Awesome conversation with GM Chad.
Heidi CAugust 2, 2010
Been here 10+ times
The Mac and cheese is great, has a slight kick to it due to the pepper jack cheese.
Trivia, ADAugust 16, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Curb Your Enthusiasm Trivia on Monday, September 12th starting at 8pm. Make your reservations today; on.fb.me/qIdR9L
Gary TorielloAugust 28, 2014
Polenta Fries with hot pepper ketchup
Leah HammerschlagJuly 16, 2014
The risotto's a good choice!
Diana SukoJanuary 3, 2013
Been here 10+ times
The Buffalo Finger Salad is AMAZING!!!
Lara RoseDecember 13, 2020
The food is delicious
Trivia, ADSeptember 16, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Arrested Development Trivia at Croton Reservoir Tavern on Monday, October 24th at 8pm. Call 212.997.6836 for reservations; on.fb.me/pxoGvX
Kaitlyn PezikOctober 24, 2015
cheap happy hour at the downstairs bar
chad gaudetJanuary 13, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Get ready for croton brunches starting in feburary keep watching and following me for details or like crotonnyc on facebook, twitter,and four square.
chad gaudetJanuary 6, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Come see chad the bartender for cheap drinks it will be busy tonight
Mad MimiJanuary 17, 2012
Make sure to win the Arrested Development Trivia in February!!
eric bornemannJanuary 5, 2018
Been here 10+ times
After work dumpster dive.
Marc LucasNovember 6, 2011
Been here 5+ times
fancier [and more expensive] than your average pubgood for a post work beverage
Jimmy WeeksApril 7, 2012
Try the Shepard's Pie
Tracy SheaNovember 26, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Spinach salad. Healthy.
KDaddyNovember 11, 2010
I'm not sure if @Patrick was right or not. Not the most diverse place for sure, but wouldn't seat him -- that's seems a little extreme.
Jimmy WeeksApril 7, 2012
Try the Guinness Draught
Tayler TrottierJanuary 25, 2013
Zero cell service in downstairs bar area.
Sean MurphJuly 30, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Good happy hour in the brick bar downstairs
Tayler TrottierJanuary 25, 2013
Zero cell service in the downstairs bar.
Mike BeckerMay 21, 2010
Great donw stairs happy hour. 80's baby.
Kal ElJune 22, 2011
Great Happy Hour
David SpringJanuary 4, 2010
Good bar and very good food
Tara DîanaMarch 31, 2015
Not bad, but a little overpriced
Patrick DJune 14, 2010
Interesting seating policy. If you're a person of color, I bet they won't seat you on the elevated platform. Food wasn't worth the $ at all. I won't be back.
Michael BlatterMay 4, 2011
Service sucked
Leonid EliseevMarch 7, 2015
Хорошее место для встречи старых друзей

169 Photos

Croton Reservoir Tavern

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Croton Reservoir Tavern

Appears on 73 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.