Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Bath Beach, Brooklyn

Filters:
  • Haven't Been
  • Following
  • Price
  • Open Now
  • Saved
  • Liked
  • It's late! Show places that are Open Now?
  • 7.5
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    2178 86th St (Bay Parkway), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Andrew B.

      Andrew B. • December 18, 2011Best eggplant pizza ever!

  • 6.1
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    1654 86th St, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Laddy U.

      Laddy U. • December 12, 2015The pizza is delicious. 🍕🍕

  • 7.6
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    6514 18th Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Lucy W.

      Lucy W. • October 15, 2013Renovations are beautiful. Pizza still tastes the same. Best pizza in NYC, hands down.

  • 7.7
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    6316 18th Ave (63rd St.), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Michael V.

      Michael V. • February 17, 2012There pizza has not been as good rather the pizzeria on Fort Hamilton Pkwy and 68th

  • 8.1
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    7818 5th Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Jack T.

      Jack T. • June 3, 2015Great coffee and everyone is always congenial. Interesting mix of customers.

  • 7.1
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    6808 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Mike G.

      Mike G. • October 4, 2013Best Italian dishes in the hood. Fresh Ingredients and Huge Portions. Always end up taking home another meal!

  • Just show me:

    Fast Food
    Italian
    Cafés
  • 8.0
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    1524 Neptune Ave (W 15th & W 16th St.), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Village Voice

      Village Voice • August 15, 2014Totonno's sports the best fresh mozzarella of any pizzeria in town. That this cheese is a little soupy, making the pie damp, is fine with us. Just grab a fork!

  • 7.3
    Pizza$$$$
    2809 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Andrei B.

      Andrei B. • August 1, 2013Awesome pizza, White pizza is my favorite. Btw, they accepting online orders www.dinnerout.com #dinnerout (Tip: get 20% off, coupon FOUR20)

  • 8.5
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    7305 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
    • lotfi B.

      lotfi B. • August 3, 2017The pizza is the best, but do not leave without trying the "Chicken Parmesan Hero" sandwich.

  • 7.0
    Pizza$$$$
    9052 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Melis H.

      Melis H. • May 15, 2012Pizza is just ok. The herod and pizza are great.

  • ?
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    1702 86th St (17th Ave), Brooklyn
    Save
  • ?
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    1750 Bath Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Christine R.

      Christine R. • November 1, 2013Best pizza in bensonhurst! Very friendly atmosphere :)

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    1656 Bath Ave (Bay 14), Brooklyn
    Save
    • JSV Laundry I.

      JSV Laundry I. • February 16, 2011Have been getting lunch (& sometimes dinner) here since they opened. Fernando is very welcoming.

  • ?
    Pizza$$$$
    1702 86th St, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Serious Eats

      Serious Eats • March 22, 2013This hole-in-the-wall pizza joint offers a stellar Grandma slice with a crisp, cracker-like crunch and fresh, tangy sauce.

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    1738 Bath Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    8509 20th Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    1649 Bath Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
  • 7.6
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    6922 5th Ave (Bay Ridge Ave), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Emily S.

      Emily S. • January 24, 2020Hands down best chicken roll I've had

  • 8.4
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    1668 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn
    Save
    • The Corcoran Group

      The Corcoran Group • May 1, 2011This old-school pizzeria has been around forever due to their pizzas with golden and lightly crispy crusts, tangy sauce and their famous white pizza.

  • 7.4
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    5023 10th Ave (50th St.), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Paulo B.

      Paulo B. • October 7, 2013Calamari Fridays. One of the best tasting pizza's in Brooklyn.

  • 7.4
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    6918 3rd Ave (Ovington Ave), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Dana L.

      Dana L. • February 22, 2010Grandma slices (natch) and eggplant slices are to die for.

  • 7.9
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    147 McClean Ave, Staten Island
    Save
    • Angela L.

      Angela L. • June 28, 2015$3 bottled beer and a crispy grandma's slice! Heaven!

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    2151 Bath Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
  • ?
    Pizza$$$$View Menu
    8774B Bay Pkwy (Bath Ave), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Andrei B.

      Andrei B. • July 1, 2013Order online www.dinnerout.com 20%off coupon :FOUR20

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    8778 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn
    Save
  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    8774 Bay Pkwy (at Bath Ave), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Alex

      Alex • January 25, 2010Most underrated pizza in Brooklyn. Great Stromboli and wraps, too.

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    8774 Bay Pkwy Ste B (Bath Avenue), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Jay N.

      Jay N. • September 4, 2023Best round pizza in Bensonhurst. Hands down. Thin crust fresh ingredients, great sauce.

  • 7.2
    Pizza$$$$
    4412 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn
    Save
    • Kevin C.

      Kevin C. • February 21, 2016Heroes, linguini and clam sauce, all the different slices are good. Try the stromboli slice

  • ?
    Pizza$$$$
    1406 86th St (14th ave), Brooklyn
    Save
    • Joanne B.

      Joanne B. • September 21, 2013Thumbs up👍

  • Category icon
    ?
    Pizza$$$$
    7924 16th Ave, Brooklyn
    Save
  • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.