Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Butler - Tarkington, Indianapolis

Filters:
    • 7.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      5615 N Illinois St, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      114 E 49th St (Pennsylvania), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Andy @.

        Andy @. • October 12, 2012Buffalo Margherita Pizza is terrific! We always order a side of sauce to go with it, too.

    • 9.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      811 E Westfield Blvd (bt Central Canal Tr & Guilford Av), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Lainna C.

        Lainna C. • November 13, 2011Wheat thin crust is amazing!

    • Category icon
      6.4
      Pizza$$$$
      704 W Hampton Dr, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Katherine

        Katherine • October 9, 2011Very thick & cheesy slices of pizza.

    • 7.2
      Pizza
      4901 N College Ave, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Muuka M.

        Muuka M. • April 28, 2019Great bar upstairs that is adult friendly!

    • 8.0
      Pizza$$$$
      6320 Ferguson St, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 8.4
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      921 Broad Ripple Ave (at Winthrop Av), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Monica V.

        Monica V. • October 22, 2010As someone who loves French Onion Soup I can say they have a great one here!

    • 6.9
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      705 E 54th St (at College Ave), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Amy S.

        Amy S. • April 14, 2012Super fresh house salad with an out of this world dressing. Also love the traditional pizza. Yum!

    • 6.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      501 E 38th St, Indianapolis
      Save
      • T Neverdinner J.

        T Neverdinner J. • January 13, 2014Switch red peppers for green on the Philly steak pizza

    • 7.1
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      715 Broad Ripple Ave (btw College Ave & Carrollton Ave), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Chris S.

        Chris S. • May 11, 2010I always order online. The crew is friendly, and the pizza is great. Even great when it's cold in the morning. I get thin crust, ranch in the middle, & 1/2 pepperoni and mushroom on top.

    • 9.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      913 Indiana Ave,, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Devon N.

        Devon N. • July 9, 2014Meat eaters with a little bit of goodness added.....yummy.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      4002 Boulevard Pl, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 6.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      5749 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 6.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2130 E 62nd St (at Keystone Ave), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Jamie R.

        Jamie R. • May 14, 2012Love the Thin and Crispy crust! The thinner the better for me!

    • 6.5
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      6311 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Leah P.

        Leah P. • June 5, 2013Yummy! ! Bbq or buffalo chicken pizza!!

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      5172 N College Ave (52nd & College), Indianapolis
      Save
    • 6.6
      Pizza$$$$
      910 West 10th Street #12 (University blvd), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Jerry M.

        Jerry M. • January 12, 2014This place was great! Try the ToTs pizza!

    • 6.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      907 N Pennsylvania St (at E 9th St), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Mike R.

        Mike R. • January 6, 2011Really good lunch special: personal pizza and a salad for $8.

    • 6.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2236 E 62nd St, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Florence H.

        Florence H. • February 6, 2015Always check for online deals and order things for pick up from their website for the best value.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Save
      • J.T. C.

        J.T. C. • December 13, 2011Everything at hot box is awesome make sure you get some stix w cheese and a cup cup

    • 6.2
      Pizza$$$$
      2181 N Meridian St, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Samantha G.

        Samantha G. • June 7, 2013Wanted cheese bread was given pizza. Check before u leave!!

    • 6.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2357 E 62nd St (N. Keystone Av.), Indianapolis
      Save
      • Dana P.

        Dana P. • August 25, 2014Gluten free options, lots of toppings, and a drive through!

    • 6.3
      Pizza$$$$
      Indianapolis
      Save
      • Mikey L.

        Mikey L. • May 17, 2012Great breadsticks! Very cheap

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      5603 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 6.1
      Pizza$$$$
      2445 E 65th St, Indianapolis
      Save
      • Ti'auna W.

        Ti'auna W. • November 9, 2013The bread sticks were fresh and hot

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      5955 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis
      Save
    • 6.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      845 N Capitol Ave (at Muskingum & W 9th Sts), Indianapolis
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2201 E 46th St, Indianapolis
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2621 Dr Martin Luther King Jr St, Indianapolis
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      914 Broad Ripple Ave (Winthrop), Indianapolis
      Save
    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.