Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Carmel

Filters:
    • 9.2

      1. Blaze Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      12697 N Pennsylvania St,, Carmel
      Save
      • Bob S.

        Bob S. • May 1, 2015Fantastic. Napolese in Indy might be the closest to pizza you find in Tuscany, but Blaze is a nice second.

    • 8.9

      2. Bazbeaux Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      111 W Main St (at 2nd Av W), Carmel
      Save
      • Gina H.

        Gina H. • March 18, 2011By far the best pizza in town. We always order the house salad with creamy basil dressing. Our kids love the cheesy bread. Plenty of outdoor seating. One of the few restaurants that are worth the wait

    • 8.5

      3. Mellow Mushroom

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      2340 E 116th St (Keystone Avenue), Carmel
      Save
      • Natasha S.

        Natasha S. • April 16, 2016Thai dye is to die for. All of the specialty pizzas we have tried have been hits. Also mushroom soup and pizza dough pretzels - yum!

    • 9.0

      4. Greek Tony's

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      1732 E 116th St (116th & Rangeline Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Natasha S.

        Natasha S. • April 16, 2016Pizza like you'd find on every street corner in Chicago. We always ask for extra sauce!

    • 8.0

      5. Pies & Pints

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      14550 Clay Terrace Blvd, Suite 100, Carmel
      Save
      • Romily B.

        Romily B. • October 22, 2023Post picking up Keri and picking up a car.

    • 7.9

      6. Jets Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      2764 E 146th St, Carmel
      Save
      • Laurie R.

        Laurie R. • August 31, 2010Breadsticks are to die for here!

    • 7.9

      7. Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy (at Hazel Dell, behind Starbucks), Carmel
      Save
      • Kayla J.

        Kayla J. • April 20, 2015To start, get the ricotta dish or breadsticks

    • 7.7

      8. Roselli's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4335 W 106th St, Carmel
      Save
      • J C.

        J C. • September 29, 2021Thin crust sausage classic is very good.

    • 7.6

      9. Puccini's Pizza Pasta

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      13674 N Meridian St, Carmel
      Save
      • Matt I.

        Matt I. • April 8, 2013Campfire pizza is delicious. All pizzas are great.

    • 7.6

      10. Bella Pizzeria

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1450 Clay Terrace Blvd., Carmel
      Save
      • Richard K.

        Richard K. • May 21, 2013The ONLY true east coast pizza! I agree that it is "The best pizza west of the Hudson!" Makes me homesick it is so good!

    • 7.6

      11. Some Guys Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      12552 N Gray Rd, Carmel
      Save
      • Abbey

        Abbey • April 19, 2013Delicious, crispy crust and yummy toppings. Great place to grab a beer and hang out. Excellent service too!!

    • 7.5

      12. Lou Malnati’s

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      11435 Springmill Rd, Carmel
      Save
      • rKS

        rKS • October 22, 2020Be ready to play bumper cars... place is going to crazy for a minute.

    • 7.4

      13. Luca Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      890 E 116th St #100 (at Guilford Road), Carmel
      Save
      • Brooke K.

        Brooke K. • July 13, 2012Pick 2 $5.99 - pick a slice, chef salad, spaghetti, half sub, breadstix, soup, meatballs, penne alfredo, or pasta salad!

    • 7.4

      14. BoomBozz

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      2430 E 146th St, Carmel
      Save
      • John T.

        John T. • March 19, 2013Get the Chicken peppadew pizza and one of their local beers! Matt made a few beer suggestions.. Excellent choices!

    • 7.4

      15. Papa Murphy's

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1950 E Greyhound Pass, Carmel
      Save
      • Aaron S.

        Aaron S. • August 27, 2011Love their pizza. Try the Chicken Mediterranean sometime.

    • 7.4

      16. Donatos Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1311 S Rangeline Rd (in Carmel Walk strip mall), Carmel
      Save
      • Chris T.

        Chris T. • May 4, 2013Love the thin crust. Robin is awesome-great customer service!

    • 7.5

      17. Fazoli's

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      465 E Carmel Dr (at AAA Way), Carmel
      Save
      • Mary W.

        Mary W. • June 29, 2011The employees at this Fazoli's are the friendliest in town. I will drive out of my way to eat here.

    • 7.4

      18. Laser Flash

      Pizza • View Prices •
      617 3rd Ave SW (City Center Drive), Carmel
      Save
      • Eva L.

        Eva L. • May 7, 20103 for the price of 2 sessions after 8pm

    • 6.9

      19. Papa John's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      2001 E Greyhound Pass Ste 7, Carmel
      Save
      • Tara M.

        Tara M. • January 25, 2012Any large pizza $11.. love it!

    • 6.7

      20. Papa John's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      10598 N College Ave (106th), Carmel
      Save
      • Craig G.

        Craig G. • September 24, 2010Mention this and receive a free lg pizza

    • 6.6

      21. HotBox Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      1 E Carmel Dr Ste 170 (at Range Line Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Zeb G.

        Zeb G. • December 13, 2014Lunch box is a pretty good deal, pick 2: 1 slice, salad or breadsticks

    • 6.6

      22. Domino's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1441 S Guilford Rd Ste 110, Carmel
      Save
      • Paul L.

        Paul L. • December 12, 2010Get extra sauce on your pie--it's free, plus I think the sauce (as opposed to cheese) is what really makes a pizza a pizza.

    • 6.3

      23. HotBox Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      4400 Weston Pointe Dr (Suite 160), Zionsville
      Save
      • Allison J.

        Allison J. • June 30, 2012HotBox is the best pizza chain in Indianapolis. Get their thin crust Four Cheese pizza and you MUST get their bread stix.

    • 6.2

      24. Donatos Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      4100 W 106th St (at N Michigan Rd), Carmel
      Save
      • Drew D.

        Drew D. • September 18, 2014Friendly staff. Free wifi. Great pizza!

    • 6.1

      25. Greek's Pizzeria

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      120 E Main St, Carmel
      Save
      • Jeremiah C.

        Jeremiah C. • December 11, 2017The “Last Call” pizza deal is where it’s at!

    • 5.8

      26. Pizza Hut

      Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
      705 S. Rangeline Road (Rangeline Rd & City Center Dr), Carmel
      Save
      • Chris M.

        Chris M. • August 24, 2018Do you need plates? Ask for plates at no additional fee.

    • Category icon
      ?

      27. Noble Roman's

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      1224 S Guilford Rd, Carmel
      Save
    • ?

      28. Pi Carmel

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      351 Monon Blvd, Carmel
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      29. Ono's Pizza

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      14931 Greyhound Ct, Carmel
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?

      30. King Dough

      Pizza • $$$$ •
      Carmel
      Save

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.