Suggestions for Ice Cream Parlor near Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Lori L. • July 24, 2016An old school ice cream parlor, complete with sundaes, shakes, milkshakes, floats, and more. Get one of their signature sundaes to share, or make your own version if you're feeling creative,

Selina A. • February 27, 2021Buy the pints to take home for a special treat. Flavors are rich and unique!

Burt H. • May 20, 2022Salted caramel is the best flavor

estheribrown ✌🏻 • March 29, 2011The New Mexican mocha is great: spicy, a little sweet, a little smoky, not too rich.

Brandon F. • June 4, 2017I was born in a barn and had ever had rolled ice cream before. Madre de Dios this stuff is good. Friendly staff too. I recommend the Key Lime Pie.

Cody M. • April 25, 2014Vegan-friendly! Sorbets, cake, and creamy almond milk-based gelato. Yum!

Dywuan B. • May 16, 2015Best shakes in the world. Burgers are great too. My favorite spot when I'm in NYC.

Nikki L. • July 2, 2014Cash only!

Globetrottergirls D. • December 24, 2019Great coffee drinks (they use beans from Partners Coffee) and delicious sandwiches. Lovely neighborhood cafe.

Valentin G. • August 30, 2016Great ice creams and so cheap, try them!

eric b. • December 28, 2023A staple of Brooklyn now no matter the price. Good interesting flavors keep you coming back.

Nate F. • June 28, 2014stracciatella gelato brownie a la mode sundae

Kim B. • April 15, 2019The non dairy coconut chocolate frozen yogurt is amazing!!!

Jeremy F. • May 26, 2021Haven’t had Oddfellows in years, and was shocked at how good it is these days

Hannah N. • June 20, 2019So excited they opened a new location closer to me! Still my favorite green curry years after they opened their first location (forewarning - much more spicy than others)

Tyniece W. • April 7, 2014love this place!.. Not a bad wait. Strawberry delight is the best!!

Jared B. • November 2, 2012As an ice cream purist, their Vanilla is like no other.

Alice Q. • November 20, 2019Don’t sleep on the berry flavors. I’m usually a chocolate fan but the berry flavors are exceptionally good.

diana🐇 • July 2, 2024German chocolate cake ice cream was splendid. i'd like to try their soft serve !

Keilaina B. • August 17, 2012Get the twist cone with cookie crunch!