David Z. • December 29, 2012So underrated. Just as good as grimaldis without the wait. They are the best "order by the slice" pizzeria in nyc.
Jackie C. • July 16, 2011Incredible. Small calzone w garlic and artichoke hearts. Life alteringly delicious
Trevor R. • August 20, 2018Great pizza and great service. One of the best spots in the neighborhood. 👌
Rachel O. • November 9, 2021We tried the Margarita DOP and Tartufata. Both were excellent! We anticipate adding Crosta to our regular rotation of dinner options.
Jameson F. • February 27, 2020Best tomato slice in the city and the cheese isn’t far behind. Amazing crust.
Mary M M. • August 18, 2015beats the other options for pizza by the slice in the general area. can vary in freshness (like any place that sells by the slice).
Kevin C. • February 21, 2016Heroes, linguini and clam sauce, all the different slices are good. Try the stromboli slice
Pratheeksha K. • August 9, 2018Neapolitan style pizzeria with a sassy menu! Loved my popeye pizza with ricotta
Julie K. • January 1, 2016Caprese Pizza is wonderful and the antipasto oh melts in your mouth! Definitely a winner!!!
Alexis A. • March 28, 2010The white slice is so good. Their plain slice is thin, crispy, foldable and has great sauce.
Jenn A. • October 1, 2015Cozy authentic pizzeria. Fresh pizza and slices. Tasty. Absolutely delish and not too pricey either. Their fruit punch is good too.
Marshal G. • February 8, 2015Restaurant in Back was great. Stuffed Shells and Chicken Francese were outstanding. Rolls were hot and Fresh, service was great.
Aaron D. • February 17, 2012Luigi Pizzeria got a health rating of A with 10 points. Download the nyc health ratings android app to view and share restaurants on FourSquare http://nychealthratings.com/r/23145
Gajtana S. • May 27, 2016Excellent sicilian slice. 9/10 rating Cozy neighborhood feel with friendly staff. Neighborhood fixture kind of NYC place. If you love good pizza, worth a visit.
Autumn R. • March 14, 2015Pizza is descent for the price and has been in the neighborhood for years. Sometimes good to have a slice of old school new york pizza
Orlando M. • April 18, 2011Excellent pizza. Sauce is delicious, crust thin and perfectly crisp! Stop in for quick and friendly service...manja manja!
Lorena N. • September 9, 2014Great traditional pizzeria. Good for groups and and for hunger people. Super valuable price. Enjoy!
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.