Reloading results...

Suggestions for Dining and Drinking near Montauk

Filters:
    • 8.8
      Ice Cream$$$$View Menu
      478 West Lake Drive Extension, Montauk
      Save
      • Chris P.

        Chris P. • August 22, 2013Great selection of pints in the back room. 32+ flavors!

    • 8.5
      Seafood$$$$
      88 Firestone Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Idan S.

        Idan S. • October 13, 2017Great spot for grabbing a beer and watch the sunset

    • 8.4
      Mediterranean$$$$View Menu
      11 S Emery St (S Euclid Ave), Montauk
      Save
      • CM S.

        CM S. • May 19, 2014Family style dishes (read: very large!) Order to share. Delicious!

    • 8.3
      Café$$$$View Menu
      779 Montauk Hwy (btwn The Plaze & S Edison St), Montauk
      Save
      • Nathalie G.

        Nathalie G. • August 20, 2011The food is amazing - try the organic blueberry pancakes for breakfast and the yellow fin tuna salad for lunch. Yum!

    • 8.3
      Beach Bar
      The Crow's Nest, Montauk
      Save
      • Jasmine

        Jasmine • August 4, 2020Sea bass ceviche is the best I’ve had in NY.

    • 8.2
      Coffee Shop$$$$
      83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Jorge U.

        Jorge U. • August 23, 2015Best coffee in Montauk. Their cakes and cookies are great too!

    • 8.2
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Kim M.

        Kim M. • August 18, 2018The lobster salad is amazing, and great to share

    • 8.2
      Bagels$$$$
      28 S. Etna Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Amanda

        Amanda • August 26, 2012Best bacon egg and cheese on a roll! Also they charged us for an extra sandwich by mistake... But they let us keep it and gave us 6 dollars back- more than the sandwich.

    • 8.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      32 Star Island Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • SPQR

        SPQR • October 18, 2015Amazing... The Montauk Blue drink is a must have

    • 8.1
      Seafood$$$$
      352 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Matt H.

        Matt H. • August 24, 2014Everything, particularly the sushi, chowder and fried whole fish app.

    • 8.1
      Bakery$$$$
      29 Carl Fisher Plz, Montauk
      Save
      • Kathleen V.

        Kathleen V. • August 8, 2015The fish cookie was adorable and it taste really good and I would really recommend you guys having the blueberry crumb cake. I would come back just for those two things. :)

    • 8.0
      Mexican$$$$View Menu
      364 W Lake Dr (at Diamond Cove Marina), Montauk
      Save
      • DishEnvy

        DishEnvy • September 1, 2011Fish tacos and stuffed jalopenos are amazing.

    • 8.0
      Beach BarView Menu
      290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
      Save
      • Nabil B.

        Nabil B. • August 23, 2019Nice serviced beach. Nice bar/restaurant. Nice dj. Nice crowd

    • 8.0
      Italian$$$$View Menu
      290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • Alex K.

        Alex K. • August 17, 2020The Spaghetti with tomato was amazing - as well as the wagging!

    • 8.0
      RestaurantView Menu
      782 Montauk Highway (The Plaza and S Edison), Montauk
      Save
      • Laura 🍑✨

        Laura 🍑✨ • August 9, 2014Most delicious Moroccan salad, fresh entrees w reasonable prices + great live music =perfect combo!

    • 7.9
      Seafood$$$$
      Gosman's Dock, Montauk
      Save
      • Dmitry

        Dmitry • August 29, 2012Great place for lunch or dinner. Above getaway from the glitz of the hamptons. Fish is fresh and great. Great restaurant on the water.

    • 7.7
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      16 Navy Rd (Shore Road), Montauk
      Save
      • Ben K.

        Ben K. • August 28, 2016Great spot to drink with friends and watch the sunset.

    • 7.7
      Seafood$$$$
      32 Star Island Rd, Montauk
      Save
      • Nikki W.

        Nikki W. • October 1, 2020Great food. Lobster fried rice, steak are all great.

    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$
      240 Fort Pond Rd, Montauk
      Save
    • 7.6
      Deli$$$$View Menu
      778 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • Theresa G.

        Theresa G. • June 12, 2013It's true - no one beats Herb's meat! Steak kebab cut like butter. Can't wait to try the fried chicken next time.

    • 7.6
      Ice Cream$$$$
      677 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • March 14, 2011Burgers, shakes and fries and the best homemade ice cream to boot! Try the John burger and the homemade ice cream. No website, but then who needs one for a popular place like this.

    • 7.6
      Coffee Shop$$$$
      732 Montauk Hwy (Carl Fisher Plaza), Montauk
      Save
      • Alicia M.

        Alicia M. • August 5, 2020Great breakfast sandwiches and strong WiFi on the patio

    • 7.6
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Erika R.

        Erika R. • August 30, 2013Don't leave with out getting the seasonal local pie and ice cream! I had the Peach Raspberry and it was delicious!

    • 7.6
      Seafood$$$$View Menu
      541 E Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • R L.

        R L. • July 5, 2016Fresh Seafood and Sushi!! Lobster Mac and Cheese! ...and Garlic Bread to die for! Really can't go wrong with anything!!

    • 7.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      500 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • Shiri L.

        Shiri L. • July 3, 2016Love this place! Fresh tuna steak in the tuna melt hit the spot. the fried asparagus is perfection! Definitely the most authentic Montauk.

    • 7.6

      26. Joni's

      Sandwich Spot$$$$View Menu
      28 S Etna Ave, Montauk
      Save
      • Shannon V.

        Shannon V. • May 12, 2013Great spot for breakfast with a very west coast vibe and great California cuisine (& plenty health-conscious options). Highly recommend the flax coconut waffle. Great tea selection too.

    • 7.6
      Seafood$$$$
      Montauk
      Save
      • Mike t.

        Mike t. • September 9, 2017Nice place by the marina. Solid menu. Lobster is a must as well as the breaded scallops. Go for dinner and enjoy the sunset.

    • 7.5
      New American$$$$
      63 S Euclid Ave (at S Edgemere St), Montauk
      Save
      • James W.

        James W. • August 5, 2018Great food, live music, patio dining, and good wine list. Family friendly and a classic Montauk experience.

    • 7.4
      Tiki Bar
      426 W Lake Dr, Montauk
      Save
      • NHH

        NHH • August 21, 2013Hands down the best cocktails I have had in the Hamptons

    • 7.4
      Burritos$$$$
      805 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
      Save
      • Joe M.

        Joe M. • July 20, 2014If they've got it, the local fish, grilled and blackened, is excellent.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.