Angelica Y. • November 20, 2014A good date spot and easily one of the best (if not the best) pizza places in Astoria. Had the superfly snuka (pineapple and speck make a great combo) and pomodoro (really enjoyed the no cheese)
Keri H. • March 5, 2019Everything I have had has been good, but the Margarita is insanely delicious. Sicilian slices are unique and varied.
Ava L. • May 1, 2011the rice ball is fantastic, service is great, definitely a must and recommended.
Rosanne C. • September 20, 2012Another excellent pizzeria where I've had lunch on occasion :). The difference between Rosa's pizza and 'Carlo's Pizzeria' is that the pizza is cooked in a regular oven, as is their Italian food.
Serious Eats • January 27, 2014A very fine new york slice made in a blazing hot oven that delivers puffy, charred lips and airy interiors to the slices.
Bryant B. • October 8, 2015Very good specialty pizzas with friendly staff. The Buffalo pizza is something else. Don't toss out that sesame seed crust!
Rosanne C. • September 20, 2012Located near the Metro Diner, their pizza and Italian food is excellent authentic Italian. Their unique 'brick-oven' allows the food to melt in your mouth!
Edward D. • August 11, 2018Mediocre at best. Only if you're starving and can't make it to a better pizzeria.
Brooke R. • February 22, 2012The pizza is truly amazing - all the way from the simple cheese to the outrageous chicken supreme! An awesome staff and really relaxing environment. The entrees are definitely surpass expectations!
Jacob L. • August 3, 2012The best pizzeria in this neighborhood in NYC I think :)
Erik C. • August 19, 2012This 2nd generation owned pizzeria which fully caters and has all the usuals and a full Italian menu. They just got a liquor license awesome, everything I have eaten has been great and fair priced.
Mallory • May 25, 2010Order a falafel (they really are the best in Queens) and the potato pizza knish. What an amazing meal.
Rory P. • March 26, 2014Excellent sauce to cheese ratio with a well baked crust. Other standouts include the meatball parm, chicken roll and broccoli pinwheel
Paolo B. • April 16, 2022Amazing pizza, to me it's the best NYC style one in Astoria
Christopher E. • July 16, 2013Want a quick bite to eat, and love pizza? Well Gaby's is best pizzeria in Queens (Better than Margaritas) #DontJudgeMe
Adam K. • February 17, 2013Trivia: the "Pistachianco" pie here is a tribute to Chris Bianco's "Rosa" pizza at Phoenix's legendary Pizzeria Bianco.
Dushyant B. • October 17, 2019Well made wood fired pizzas and a great collection of wines to complement the lighting👍🏽
Toni B. • September 16, 2012My dad used to come here when he was a kid in the '50s & '60s. I love the chicken roll, lemon chicken & pasta, lasagne, and vodka chicken pizza. May try one of the salads soon.
Hugh W. • October 1, 2013Wow. The Crumbled Buffalo Chicken Pizza is extraordinarily good. One of the best pizzas I've tasted.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.