Barrett T. • December 2, 2012Greek salad is to die for. Great for parties, too!
Jamie O. • July 11, 2013By far the best pizza I've had in Sarasota. Reminded me of my summers at the Jersey shore. Can't wait to go back!
Rory P. • February 5, 2022Start with the Origin salad then some mango habanero wings and then the barbershop pizza
Gregorio B. • July 21, 2020The calzones are excellent. Recommend the Chicago deep dish as well.
Edwin R. • January 17, 2014excellent ravioli. ..and an awesome value for lunch
Tommi O. • December 14, 2016Do yourself a favor try the soup. Authentic. Now get the parm, lasagna or ziti- the best Pizza. Quick service lots of table space and good prices.
Bridget S. • September 27, 2012Love the vibe, the ambieance & the behind-the-bar talent. Awesome joint.
Mrugesh P. • March 2, 2013Best and most respected pizzeria on Main Street. Regular for their lunch special as it's a close walk from the Selby Library, my current study residence.
Ankush K. • February 9, 2019Great pizzas!
Ryan H. • August 30, 2021This is the best pizza in the area... quality toppings and NY Style very crispy tasty crust!
Count Cory B. • March 17, 2012I LOVE Cafe Amalfi. best lasagna and antipasto,everything is great hair also their garlic knott bread.
Susan H. • December 8, 2018Very good toasted ravioli for an appetizer. I love the Greek salad.
Tom G. • July 12, 2014This is my new "go to" place for pizza. It's awesome and you simply have to try it.
Lori M. • January 10, 2015So many options-- fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, even gluten free pizza crust.
Chris B. • August 17, 2014Excellent place for Italian food. The black berry sangria is our favorite.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.