Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Filters:
    • 8.5
      Pizza$$$$
      2201 Avenue X, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Jarel H.

        Jarel H. • June 8, 2022Everything is top tier here but the grandma slices were some of the best I’ve had.

    • 8.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2928 Avenue R, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Joyce

        Joyce • February 9, 2017GREAT PIZZA! I was surprised by this local branch of the bigger chain pizzeria. the margarita and regular slices are great!

    • 8.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1723 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Allen S.

        Allen S. • September 15, 2009The pizza here is some of the best regular-oven pizza I've ever tasted. Their grandma slice to fresh mozzarella to veggie slice, and even calzone, everything tastes great.

    • 8.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1668 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Michael W.

        Michael W. • September 1, 2018Great pizza and specialty slices. One of our favs is be Alfredo slice.

    • 8.2
      Pizza$$$$
      1688 E 16th St (Btw Kings Highway & Quentin Rd), Brooklyn
      Save
      • ᴡ L.

        ᴡ L. • August 10, 2014Love their margherita slice! Sooo good

    • 7.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2823 Avenue U, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ian L.

        Ian L. • July 15, 2017The Sicilian with breadcrumbs and cheese is superb. So is the Grandma slice.

    • 7.1
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2911 Avenue U, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Nicholas S.

        Nicholas S. • July 1, 2011Great Food . Perfect Service. TRY THE VEAL & MUSHROOM HERO w/SAUCE

    • 7.0
      Pizza$$$$
      1907 Avenue U (btw E. 19th St. & Ocean Ave.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Lefkes

        Lefkes • July 9, 2013I've eaten at a lot of pizza shops this is a great slice of regular pizza thin and cooked just right.

    • 6.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1101 Avenue U (Avenue U), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Christopher H.

        Christopher H. • February 23, 2010great supreme pizzas and sausage rolls. they have this orange cream soda which is amazing

    • 6.5
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      3528 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • PinkyLoca

        PinkyLoca • November 13, 2011The cheesy bread is tooo delish!!

    • 6.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1800 Kings Hwy (at E. 18th St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Humming B.

        Humming B. • January 22, 2012We have the best crust in all of Brooklyn:-)

    • 6.1
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1916 Kings Hwy (Btw Ocean Ave. & 19th St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Luis L.

        Luis L. • December 29, 2014Great italian food place, I had the grilled chicken with baked ziti and it was on point with man size servings.

    • 6.1
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1615 Avenue U (btwn E 16th & E 17th St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Joyce C.

        Joyce C. • April 8, 2017Love their all white pizza. Also make a very good shrimp parmigiano.

    • 6.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      3514 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
    • 6.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1626 E 16th St (P & Kings Hwy), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Steef

        Steef • January 15, 2012The food is really fresh, try everything

    • 7.8
      Italian$$$$View Menu
      2110 Avenue X (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • May 1, 2011Straightforward, home-style Italian food, with the BEST garlic knots. Get the house salad, followed by fried zucchini and something from their specials menu.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1652 Sheepshead Bay Rd (btw Jerome Ave & Voorhies Ave), Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      3033 Avenue V (Coyle St.), Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Coyle St (Avenue U), Brooklyn
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1907 Avenue U, Brooklyn
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2650 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1619 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2224 Avenue U (East 23 Street), Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2113 Avenue Z, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Liz G.

        Liz G. • October 5, 2013It's been a few years villa bay closed down. I loved the food!

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1323 Avenue U (at 14th St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Bill M.

        Bill M. • November 15, 201099c slices Mondays & Tuesdays says the sign

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2800 Ave U, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ethan K.

        Ethan K. • June 23, 2013Some of the best pizza and falafel in Brooklyn at 2724 Avenue U

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      709 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ethan K.

        Ethan K. • April 21Last pizza before Pesach/Passover

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2224 Avenue U (East 23rd St), Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      902 Kings Hwy (East 9th Street), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ethan K.

        Ethan K. • May 14, 2019Very good there in every way!

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1115 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Anatoliy B.

        Anatoliy B. • July 15, 2010Beef paty with cheese. Best in town.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.