Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near University Heights, Indianapolis

Filters:

8.3
1. Bob's Tu Your Door Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
3653 Carson Ave (at National Ave), Indianapolis
Save
- Patti F. • March 13, 2013Best in Indy and great workers
8.2
2. Enzo Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
3940 Madison Ave (at Hanna Ave.), Indianapolis
Save
- Gabrielle S. • October 19, 2015The pizza is great and the service is amazing! My family and I have been coming for years.
6.8
3. Papa John's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
3915 Madison Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Penny I. • May 20, 2017Love the pizza, the brownies, and the fact they include the peppers
6.2
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
2509 Albany St, Beech Grove
Save
- Christopher B. • December 1, 2011Whatever time they quote you, tack on 15 more mins @ least!
8.7
5. Indy All Night
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
1324 S East St, Indianapolis
Save
- niko t. • April 29, 2024What a treat to spend family event ordering from Indy all night... The food, service was amazing. Certainly know how to prepare, as well as present a meal
7.5
6. Fazoli's
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
4742 Emerson Avenue (at E Elenor St), Indianapolis
Save
- Joe P. • August 29, 2013Best breadsticks ever eaten
6.7
7. McQ's Pub & Eatery
Pizza • $$$$ •
3149 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis
Save
- Derek B. • April 11, 2010Great non-smoking family friendly pub to watch the game at!
7.4
8. Papa Murphy's
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
5347 E Thompson Rd (at bt S Emerson Av & Encore Dr), Indianapolis
Save
- candie s. • August 20, 2013great pizza and great specials, made they way you like
6.5
9. Domino's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
3220 S East St, Indianapolis
Save
- Brent I. • July 5, 2012Nice clean environment and fast delivers, never had any problem and i eat here a lot. :)
7.0
10. Papa John's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
4907 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Jessica K. • April 8, 2012I always get original crust with bacon & canadian bacon. so yummy. but I hate how they changed their drinks to Pepsi.
8.5
11. Bazbeaux Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
329 Massachusetts Ave (at E New York St), Indianapolis
Save
- Ricardo D. • February 14, 2016La pizza es exquisita. Una de las mejores que he probado.
6.3
12. Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
3400 S East St, Indianapolis
Save
6.7
13. Donatos Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
5835 Madison Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Jeremiah C. • September 23, 2010Dining room closes at 10 pm, pickup window and delivery open till Midnight Sun-Thu, 1:30 am Friday and Saturday
6.5
14. Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
2245 Shelby St (shelby and raymond), Indianapolis
Save
- Andrew E. • March 1, 2012Try the pizza!
?
15. Big Kahuna's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
3643 S Keystone Ave (at I-65), Indianapolis
Save
- Matt C. • April 1, 2016Everything we've tried has been delicious. Great late night delivery option. Cool name too.
?
16. Pasquale's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
1135 E Troy Ave (at Carson Av), Indianapolis
Save
- candie s. • August 20, 2013been going there for years
6.9
17. Jet's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
5202 E Thompson Rd, 150 (Emerson Ave), Indianapolis
Save
- Ken Y. • January 28, 2014Well-mannered and courteous staff. And the pizza is delicious too!
6.2
18. Cicis
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
3652 S East St, Indianapolis
Save
- Heather R. • May 4, 2013The mac n cheese, buffalo chicken, and cheeseburger pizza are all good!
6.9
19. Maria's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
1106 Prospect St, Indianapolis
Save
- James B. • August 15, 2010Really great pizza. Unique sauce. Well made. If you are in the area it's worth stopping in. Very affordable too. Less expensive than ordering from the big guys. Lol
6.4
20. Domino's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
4030 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis
Save
6.9
21. Hungry Howie's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
6005 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis
Save
- Sheri M. • October 14, 2010Best pizza on southeast side!
7.2
22. Mauricio's Pizzeria
Pizza • $$$$ •
222 E Market St, Indianapolis
Save
- Sarai J. • July 24, 2013I had the lasagna. It was perfect. The breadstick was also perfect. Just perfect.
6.3
23. Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
4922 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Kyle R. • October 9, 2011Try zesty jalapeño cheese bread! So good!!!
6.1
24. Pizza Hut
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
4533 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Michael • January 31, 2015The pizza rollers are my favorite. They always seem to be understaffed.
6.6
25. Papa John's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
1630 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis
Save
6.7
26. Donatos Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ •
435 Virginia Ave Unit 1700 (at S East St), Indianapolis
Save
- A • December 1, 2023Good pizza 👍🏻
6.7
27. Domino's Pizza
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
2522 E Washington St (Temple Ave.), Indianapolis
Save
- Andrew H. • November 13, 2013The staff here tonight is on point. Good guys
6.1
28. Pizza Hut
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
1801 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis
Save
- Elizabeth H. • August 21, 2010I love their choco-dunkers!
?
29. Ball Park Pizza & Eatery II
Pizza • $$$$ •
510 Main St, Beech Grove
Save
?
30. Noble Roman's Take-n-Bake P'ZA
Pizza • $$$$ •
404 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis
Save
- Stephanie W. • May 3, 2013Stick to papa Murphy
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.