Suggestions for Pizzeria near East Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Paola G. • June 24, 2015Definitely not your neighborhood pizzeria, but play around with the topping options. The speck is outstanding and the cheese is unreal. Definitely order 2 pies!

Dan • June 19, 2021Excellent pizza, best slice in Williamsburg (including Joe’s and Best Pizza)

Eater • August 24, 2017Pizza may be the other breakfast of champions, but the real winner is the egg sandwich tucked away at Roberta's Bakery, a few steps down from the famous pizzeria.

Cole K. • March 2, 2022Way better than Emmy Squared. Enjoyed the pepperoni and buffalo chicken. A “half square” is plenty for one, maybe even two people if you’re not crazy hungry.

Joe K. • September 9, 2015This is one of the better counter slice spots in Brooklyn. Traditional NYC slice. No fancy, over the top toppings. Just a perfect slice of pizza.

Serious Eats • March 21, 2013One of our favorite pizzerias in NY, Best Pizza churns out wonderful slices from their wood-fired brick oven.

Luis S. • December 30, 2014Ótimos pedaços de pizza!

Carol • April 4Incredible sourdough pizza! This was a surprise stop on our pizza tour and we’re so glad. Try the potato slice. It’s like lemon potatoes on a pizza

Amber N. • March 1, 2015My favorite late night spot. Addicted to their mac and cheese and white slice pizzas. Cash only but ATM inside.

LaDawn P. • January 24, 2017This BK pizzeria is amazing! The pizza is doughy and rich and if you like thicker crust, you'll be in heaven. There will definitely be a wait but service is swift and attentive!

Drew C. • May 10, 2019This is such an incredible upgrade—both in the pizza itself and the design of the space. Probably my favorite sicilian slice in town.

Alexander M. • January 4, 2023Delicious. Worth the trek.

Monica C. • August 28, 2016Great pizza pick up when coming home from the Subway! They also finally opened their sports bar which has been a total game changer in the neighborhood! Tons of TVs with great Italian food to order!

Jarel H. • April 11, 2022Pizza was so good!! Pepperoni by far and the garlic knots were fiya

James C. • June 19, 2016Awesome family style is the way to go.

Cha 🎈🏃🏻 • January 27, 2010best pizza in south williamsburg. Pomodoro is awesome.

Giulia • August 1, 2019Focaccia der Muratore and pinsas are a must try. Pasta all’amatriciana is very good too. Went there with 7 Italians and everyone was very happy. Amazing patio and friendly service!

Fr T. • April 13, 2010Great place!! You must try their penne vodka, penne with grilled chicken with brocoli. Their salad rocks too. You must stop there.

Gabriel B. • September 6, 2014A classic, this pizzeria offers some of the best neapolitan pizzas in the city.

Brit R. • October 24, 2020The most authentic Italian pizza in BK, which is no surprise as Giuseppe (owner/chef) started making pizza in Sicily at 13. He is both an exceptional chef + a lovely human being. You will love it!!

Eric R. • October 18, 2023White slice is stuff of legends. Cheese blend plus spritz of lemon make it best white slice I’ve ever had. Definitely add some of the hot honey sauce from the unmarked green squirt bottles.

Mike M. • June 26, 2023Vodka slice

10 W. • October 13, 2015Pepperoni slice

7th.List • December 22, 2011Try: The montanara, a margherita made with a crust shaped and flash-fried before being topped and finished in the wood-burning oven, is a popular choice.

Joe P. • January 19, 2014Pretty much like crocodile lounge in the city. Cheap, free pizza with beers, some games.

Gracia M. • July 6, 2015Pizza, empanadas!!

Deniz E. • June 28, 2012Amazing pasta dishes. Tastes like mom food!

Bravo • November 22, 2010New Yorkers are very opinionated when it comes to their favorite pizzeria. Walk up to the counter at Anna Maria's, shout "next please!" and order a plain slice to go. Freaking delicious. -Jacqueline

Cynthia R. • October 29, 2013Best pizza in Brooklyn!!!!