Suggestions for Pizzeria near Wooster Square - Mill River, New Haven

Eric D. • January 6, 2017Like any respectable pizzeria, Frank Pepe doesn’t take reservations. The focus here was on the pizza. We ordered 4 pies: clams, pepperoni, 4 cheeses and spinach. The best!

Gustavo N. • November 24, 2017La pizza es excelente. El lugar es calido . Lo recomiendo.

Timur H. • April 27, 2017Best pizza in Elm City when compared to classic Italian pizzerias. Shame they stopped selling pie with soppresata though :/

Rachel F. • February 4, 2010Pizza, soda and beer. Be prepared to wait, but so worth it. Also cash only.

Fred S. • August 1, 2020Pizza very good

Dave M. • October 26, 2013Great pizza spot. The bacon chicken ranch and buffalo chicken pizza were both awesome. Super reasonable price too!

Alexandr K c. • January 3, 2015Great and huge pizza. Awesome local beer.

David D. • August 10, 2016Loaded baked potato pizza! Tomato pizza really good too

Jeff A. • December 2, 2018My favorite pizza is the Hannibal, a meat lover's dream pie. And the fried cheese curds are beyond incredible!!!

Colton S. • December 23, 2020Hot take: Brick Oven is New Haven’s most underrated pizza place. My go to is the sausage, pepper, and onion 👌

Julian S. • January 22, 2013They have slices...Buffalo Chicken is my favorite.

Carlos S. • April 14, 2017Muy rica pizza! Rico wrap! Buena atención y descuentos universitarios

Denis F. • July 3, 2017You must ask for the Wenzel (grinder sandwich of chicken and hot sauce). It is not awesome but a tradition at Yale

J.T. F. • February 13, 2023Really nice people behind the counter. Good veggie options

Kevin D. • November 10, 2013Calzones! Original introduction of Calzones to New Haven by this family. What a pleasant surprise. Truly an authentic experience!

Ralph M. • August 25, 2018Great pizza! Classic New Haven landmark. Friendly staff.

Amaya • December 24, 2016Hands down my favorite pizza. Greek style, crispy crust. My tummy is always happy when I leave :)

Kathleen F. • September 20, 2015I hold reviews for my students here- love getting a bottomless cup of responsibly sourced coffee with organic half & half! There's a nice breakfast for a buck,great salmon & vegetarian offerings too

Robert K. • June 15, 2019Pizza is as good as any of the legends in NHV. And better beer list and less of a wait.

Julia M. • January 2, 2015Chicken parm is my fav!

Sujay S. • February 25, 2012Get the Garlic Parmesan breadsticks.. best thing ever!

Edgar J. • July 13, 2010The grilled chicken salad is the best in town

Drew • July 3, 2013I would probably pick their plain slice over any other in the country. Superb.

Joseph D. • September 16, 2013Awesome Soup and Salad deal!