Suggestions for American Restaurant near Key West

Rosie M. • September 7, 2012Top notch in Key West. Menu changes daily. Great atmosphere. 1 block off of Duval but it feels like 10miles. Like a place in the West Village of Manhattan.

Jenna Rose R. • May 6, 2018Much better than I’d expected. Best service is at the bar. Great breakfast!

Kalikina V. • July 7, 2011The pancakes are delicious and so is the corn beef hash. Staff is very friendly!!

Val D. • April 12, 2010Get the fantastic Shrimp Salad, great service.

Lauren A. • September 2, 2012Blackened chicken pasta is spicy but good! Dolphin sandwich is also tasty.

Mags • January 1, 2013Good shrimp and really good yellow tail snapper.. Also prices are not that bad

Bruno C. • September 1, 2015Great burgers and fries with a fair trade culture. Much love!

K M. • September 6, 2021Always my 1st stop when I arrive. Amazing Mahi & Red Snapper sandwiches. (Get the key lime Mayo)

Sys E. • January 22, 2012Have the crab/shrimp cake as an appetiser! Delicious. Mahi mahi was flavorless and disappointing

Ghaida✨ • May 17, 2023Strawberry fried pancake was awesome!

Alexander S. • June 2, 2014The seared scallops on a bed of arugula w black olives, almonds and cantaloupe was to die for! Wish it was on the regular menu!

Mike L. • February 12, 2012Fish tacos are phenom. Dog friendly with some great characters. I feel like the local boozers really love this place. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu)

Cecile G. • August 7, 2013They close fairly early at night, so get there in time to watch the sunset and have a leisurely meal. A bit pricey, but the view makes up for it.

Kaydee M. • April 14, 2014I loveeee this bar. We sat at the very front entrance bar and the bartender was wonderful. First time in the Keys and he made it a blast. :)

M Gavin D. • April 27, 2016Awesome food, exceedingly affordable, and speedy quick service!

Lindsay S. • July 8, 2012The ribs were amazing!!!! Guava BBQ sauce was yummy!

Robert A. • August 14, 2014Best parking rate in town at $10 for the whole day. AND you get a free piece of Key Lime Pie (with a purchase at the restaurant)!

Erica S. • October 5, 2012This is a must whether you're in kw for an hour or week. Hands down best pasta I've ever had and they make all the noodles from scratch! So many options and huge wine list! Off the beaten path too :)

Jennifer R. • June 8, 2015The oyster combo plate is great - you can try key lime, buffalo and spinach baked oysters. :-)

Jim E. • August 25, 2012Best Frozen drinks. Good food too. I had the turkey club. Tasty and I could substitute salad for fries.

Tim M. • March 7, 2011The wait staff was amazing. always on top of the drinks. try the california burger... its a bit messy but so good. loved the Nachos.

VP M. • November 30, 2013Must get the roast pork panini sandwich!

Nick M. • December 24, 2013My favorite out of the four or five pizza places I tried.

Scot S. • June 8, 20214 people in group, every menu choice was the best. Entertainment was very good. Staff was fun and professional

Samuel F. • July 6, 2017The restaurant is perfect. There are a waiter very good. CJay. Thank you for your care.

Chasidy B. • June 16, 2014Lobster bisque was amazing... Had the surf and turf special @$75 was great but way too much food. Service was top notch...will def be back next trip

Monica G. • July 1, 2015Omg! Grilled oysters are amazing. Best thing I've had in Key West so far.

courtney c. • February 17, 2016The Tipsy Turtle signature drink was very yummy! Great setting, service, and happy hour deals!

Brittanie Q. • August 17, 2011Friendly staff! Great menu! The best part is they serve breakfast until 4pm!

Elena F. • March 24, 2019Omg - adult milkshakes. All of them. So good.