Reloading results...

Suggestions for Desserts near Key West

Filters:

8.8
1. Better Than Sex
Desserts • $$$$ • View Menu •
926 Simonton St (at Truman Ave), Key West
Save
- Brian S. • January 2, 2013Peanut Butter Perversion is so delicious!!
8.7
2. Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Desserts • $$$$ • View Menu •
200 Elizabeth St (Greene St.), Key West
Save
- People here talk about the key lime pie, free samples, and chocolate dip
8.2
3. Mattheessen's
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
419 Duval St (btwn Eaton & Fleming St), Key West
Save
- Chris F. • July 8, 2013They also ship their delicious cookies at a reasonable price
8.5
4. Glazed Donuts
Donuts • $$$$ • View Menu •
420 Eaton St (Duval St), Key West
Save
- Bacon donuts, bourbon, candy and a whole lot more
8.7
5. Duetto Pizza & Gelato
Pizza • $$$$ • View Menu •
540 Greene St (Ann st), Key West
Save
- Rachel A. • May 29, 2015Delicious pizza and the nicest ladies that work there!
8.8
6. Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
1105 Duval St, Key West
Save
- Shannon M. • February 14, 2012Try the Orange And Lemon Sorbet Waffle Cone
7.9
7. Key West Key Lime Pie Company
Desserts • $$$$ •
511 Greene St (at Ann), Key West
Save
- Over 30 tips talk about the key lime pie, gluten-free food, and good service
8.2
8. Key Lime Republic
Pie Shop • $$$$ •
412 Greene St (Telegraph Lane), Key West
Save
- Key West has great key lime pie, and this pie shop has some of the best
8.0
9. Mattheessen's
Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
106 Duval St (btwn Front & Greene St), Key West
Save
- Tammy S. • September 5, 2013Beat chocolate covered key lime pie!
7.2
10. Kermit's Key Lime Pie
Desserts • $$$$ • View Menu •
802 Duval St, Key West
Save
- One of the top 5 pie shops in Key West
8.4
11. Dairy Queen
Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
1207 United St, Key West
Save
- Caren C. • January 22, 2012I love my peanut buster parfait!!!!!
8.4
12. Kilwins Chocolate Fudge & Ice Cream
Desserts • $$$$ •
505 Duval St, Key West
Save
- Latha S. • June 5, 2015Try the Toasted coconut fudge and the key lime fudge!
8.9
13. La Crêperie French Café
French • $$$$ • View Menu •
300 Petronia St (at Thomas St), Key West
Save
- Over 15 tips talk about the fruit crepes, red velvet desserts, and coffee
9.1
14. Moondog Cafe & Bakery
Café • $$$$ •
823 Whitehead St, Key West
Save
- Cyndie C. • March 15Delish pastries & Cafe Con Leche! 🥂🍮🥧🍪🥤
7.7
15. Haagen-Dazs
Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
625 Duval St, Key West
Save
- Erianna R. • February 3, 2012Key lime pie shake is so good!
8.6
16. Old Town Bakery
Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
930 Eaton St (at Grinnell St), Key West
Save
- One of the top 5 places for pastries in Key West
7.7
17. Croissants de France
Bakery • $$$$ •
816 Duval St, Key West
Save
- One of the top 5 places for pastries in Key West
8.2
18. The Courthouse Deli & Whit's Frozen Custard
Coffee Shop • $$$$ •
600 Whitehead St, Key West
Save
- Carla F. • June 6, 2018Best frozen custard in the world! Cakes, cones, cups, or milkshakes. You can’t go wrong.
7.5
19. 2 Scoops I Scream
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
2814 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Save
- Ryan D. • July 6, 2013Get the carrot cake cupcakes in the waffle cone cup.
6.9
20. Le Macaron
Desserts • $$$$ •
423 Duval St, Key West
Save
- Maureen • March 6, 2016Also, the tiramisu gelato is to die for.
6.8
21. Key West Polar Bear Ice Cream Parlor
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
247 Front St, Key West
Save
- Shn J. • October 6, 2013Their key lime pie is really popular here!
8.7
22. Coles Peace
Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
1111 Eaton St (White St), Key West
Save
- Travis L. • December 23, 2016Get the Ciabatta-Lotta or the Brisket Sandwich!
8.0
23. River Street Sweets • Savannah's Candy Kitchen
Candy Store •
400-B Duval Street, Key West
Save
- Gleb J. • August 8, 2017Come in for free praline samples
6.8
24. Carpe Diem Ice Cream
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
300 Whitehead St, Key West
Save
- Allison G. • December 27, 2017We always get ice cream here when we come to Key West. Every flavor we’ve ever tried has been really good and their shakes just as tasty.
6.6
25. Baskin-Robbins
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
3124 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Save
- Ricky L. • February 16, 2020Real ice cream milkshake are good,
6.3
26. All You Need Is Yummy
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
514 Duval St, Key West
Save
- Hollie S. • April 18, 2015Get the giant cookie. It's delicious
5.8
27. Dunkin'
Donuts • $$$$ • View Menu •
3124 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
Save
- Davis S. • March 29, 2013Hashbrowns here are crucial as tits!
6.2
28. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Desserts • $$$$ •
431 Front St, Key West
Save
6.2
29. Haagen-Dazs
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
425 Front St, Key West
Save
- David M. • December 28, 2014$7.50 for a kiddie cone. 😭
?
30. Key West Polar Bear Ice Cream
Ice Cream • $$$$ •
500 Truman Ave Ste 7, Key West
Save
- Steve H. • August 31, 2011Try the waffle cone delish
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.