Reloading results...

Suggestions for Desserts near Theater District, New York

Filters:
    • 8.4

      1. Junior's Restaurant & Bakery

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1515 Broadway (at W 45th St), New York
      Save
    • 8.8

      2. Amorino

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      721 8th Ave (btwn W 45th & W 46th St), New York
      Save
      • Ket M.

        Ket M. • April 14, 2016Great place with a lot of gelato flavors and good Italian coffee!

    • 8.8

      3. Shake Shack

      Burgers • $$$$ • View Menu •
      691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York
      Save
      • Star One of the top 5 burger joints in New York
    • 8.5

      4. Bibble & Sip

      Coffee Shop • $$$$ •
      253 W 51st St (btwn Broadway & 8th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star Lavender latte, earl grey tea, matcha latte and a whole lot more
    • 7.8

      5. Paris Baguette

      Bakery • $$$$ •
      567 Fashion Ave (40th Street), New York
      Save
      • Alayna C.

        Alayna C. • April 21, 2014The cronuts and croissants are delicious.

    • 7.7

      6. Petrossian Boutique & Cafe

      French • $$$$ • View Products •
      911 7th Ave (btwn 57th & 58th St.), New York
      Save
      • Places with caviar are popular in Theater District, and this is one of the best
    • 7.6

      7. Ben & Jerry's

      Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
      200 W 44th St, New York
      Save
      • Katie T.

        Katie T. • October 1, 2017Not sure WHY they don’t sell New York Super Fudge Chunk at this location. But, you can walk to Rockefeller and get it there.

    • 7.6

      8. Krispy Kreme Flagship

      Donuts • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1601 Broadway (W. 48th St), New York
      Save
      • Randall

        Randall • September 15, 2020glazed doughnuts being made in front

    • 8.2

      9. Paris Baguette

      Bakery • $$$$ •
      977 8th Ave (btwn 57th & 58th St), New York
      Save
      • Star One of the top 5 places for pastries in the Theater District
    • 8.2

      10. Zibetto Espresso Bar

      Coffee Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1385 Avenue of the Americas (at W 56th St), New York
      Save
      • Star Most people that write tips here are raving about the espresso, coffee bar, and Italian pastries
    • 7.3

      11. Brasserie Cognac

      French • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1740 Broadway (btwn W 55th & W 56th St.), New York
      Save
      • Star Over 25 tips talk about the French pastries, desserts, and seafood
    • 7.6

      12. Buttercup Bake Shop

      Bakery • $$$$ •
      828 7th Ave (7th Ave and 53rd St), New York
      Save
      • Emma B.

        Emma B. • October 8, 2017Excellent salted Carmel cookie dough pudding!!

    • 7.9

      13. Baked By Melissa

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1585 Broadway (on 47th), New York
      Save
      • Alexandra

        Alexandra • October 28, 2012I wish they had normal minis or standard size cupcakes.

    • 7.5

      14. Angelina Bakery

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1675 Broadway (52nd St.), New York
      Save
      • Star Most people that write tips here are raving about the desserts and pastries
    • 7.5

      15. Café Zaiya

      Bakery • $$$$ •
      1073 Avenue of the Americas (btwn W 40th & W 41st St), New York
      Save
      • Anne Z.

        Anne Z. • March 20, 2012green tea red bean roll is so good, and their puddings are good too

    • 7.8

      16. Venchi

      Chocolate Store •
      1796 Broadway (W 58th Street), New York
      Save
      • Alyssa B.

        Alyssa B. • August 11, 2021There are at least 3 variations of choc-hazelnut gelato flavors.

    • 7.1

      17. Woops!

      Desserts • $$$$ •
      1000 Ave,S 8th (Columbus Circle), New York
      Save
    • 6.9

      18. Baked By Melissa

      Cupcakes • $$$$ •
      975 8th Ave. (at W 57th St.), New York
      Save
      • Christina N.

        Christina N. • April 27, 2015Peanut butter and jelly cupcake is the winner.

    • 7.7

      19. Magnolia Bakery

      Cupcakes • $$$$ •
      1796 Broadway (58th Street), New York
      Save
    • 7.2

      20. The Bread Factory Cafe

      Bakery • $$$$ • View Menu •
      935 8th Ave (btw 55th & 56th), New York
      Save
      • Bauzen

        Bauzen • March 6, 2013Never had a bad bagel or bad egg-based breakfast here.

    • 6.7

      21. Uncle Tetsu’s Japanese Cheesecake

      Desserts • $$$$ •
      135 W 41st St, New York
      Save
      • Cynthia L.

        Cynthia L. • July 12, 2021Tiny location but same quality cheesecakes.

    • 7.4

      22. Dunkin'

      Donuts • $$$$ • View Menu •
      750 8th Ave (W 46th St), New York
      Save
    • Category icon
      7.4

      23. Momofuku Milk Bar

      Desserts • $$$$ •
      225 W 57th St, New York
      Save
    • 7.3

      24. The Milk Bar

      Desserts • $$$$ •
      235 W 57th St, New York
      Save
    • 8.0

      25. S’mores

      Chocolate Store •
      Hershey’s Chocolate World, New York
      Save
    • 7.3

      26. Lady Wong

      Desserts • $$$$ •
      135 W 50th St, New York
      Save
      • Cynthia L.

        Cynthia L. • January 31, 2023Flavor combinations of each of the cakes are amazing

    • 6.7

      27. Baskin-Robbins

      Ice Cream • $$$$ • View Menu •
      240 W 40th St, New York
      Save
      • Ta S.

        Ta S. • July 8, 2013Soft serve cones are currently 99cents.

    • 6.5

      28. Au Bon Pain

      Sandwich Spot • $$$$ •
      1251 Avenue of the Americas (at W 50th St), New York
      Save
      • Star Most people that write tips here are raving about the bagels and pastries
    • 7.5

      29. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

      Ice Cream • $$$$ •
      712 7th Ave, New York
      Save
    • 6.7

      30. Mia's Bakery

      Bakery • $$$$ •
      716 7th Ave (btwn W 47th & W 48th St), New York
      Save
      • George W.

        George W. • October 19, 2021Wife enjoyed the Red Velvet cake which was not too sweet ❤️.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.