Reloading results...

Suggestions for Pizzeria near Coney Island, Brooklyn

Filters:
    • 8.4
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1524 Neptune Ave (W 15th & W 16th St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Mary M M.

        Mary M M. • May 28, 2015this is my #2 pizza in the world! it's definitely worth the train ride to Coney Island to stop in for a pie 🍕 - come hungry!

    • 7.3
      Pizza$$$$
      2809 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Brenda R.

        Brenda R. • July 20, 2013Great Italian place!

    • 6.5
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1408 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
    • 6.4
      Pizza$$$$
      2932 Stillwell Ave (Surf Avenue), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Maxwanette P.

        Maxwanette P. • November 10, 2017Best Pizza Place left in Brooklyn!

    • 6.4
      Pizza$$$$
      837 Surf Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Marc

        Marc • February 19, 2018It's a delicioso regular slice.

    • 6.4
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1208 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Stella P.

        Stella P. • September 3, 2013I usually order. Figured it be quickert to pick it up. What a mistake. The girl screwed up my order. I waited 40min. I can see in the widow: they kept moving the boxes back & forth thats it. Horrible

    • 8.3
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1668 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • May 1, 2011This old-school pizzeria has been around forever due to their pizzas with golden and lightly crispy crusts, tangy sauce and their famous white pizza.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2875 W 8th St, Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Brooklyn
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      West 17th Street, Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      3033 Neptune Avenue (Coney Island Avenue), Brooklyn
      Save
    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      532 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Brooklyn
      Save
      • Tiph_Tiph

        Tiph_Tiph • March 24, 2013$4 for a pepperoni slice?!

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1025 Boardwalk W, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Hannah M.

        Hannah M. • August 11, 2013Don't cross the white line with your beer or you'll get a nice ticket.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2728 Mermaid Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Eddie F.

        Eddie F. • March 23, 2012Prices went up. Plain still $2 but everything else $2.50 and up

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      1627 Mermaid Ave (W 17 st), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Daddy's Sunshine!!

        Daddy's Sunshine!! • March 19, 2011The best time to get a slice?? Around 1pm or so.. I have no clue why but.. woo that pie is always their best!

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      522 Neptune Ave (at W 5th St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Anna M.

        Anna M. • March 22, 2012Try their grandma slice - perfect stripes of Basil/pesto and marinara on a thin crusty square

    • ?
      Pizza$$$$
      1904 Surf Ave (at MCU Park), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Sarah T.

        Sarah T. • July 24, 2012The deep-dish slice was huge and delicious.. and there was service with a smile. Well done.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      2811 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
    • 7.7
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      6514 18th Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Orlando M.

        Orlando M. • April 18, 2011Excellent pizza. Sauce is delicious, crust thin and perfectly crisp! Stop in for quick and friendly service...manja manja!

    • 7.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      6316 18th Ave (63rd St.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Michael V.

        Michael V. • February 17, 2012There pizza has not been as good rather the pizzeria on Fort Hamilton Pkwy and 68th

    • 7.2
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      6808 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Mike G.

        Mike G. • October 4, 2013Best Italian dishes in the hood. Fresh Ingredients and Huge Portions. Always end up taking home another meal!

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      Coney Island Boardwalk, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Daniel S.

        Daniel S. • September 5, 2010Staff really helpful when I was handling an order, two kids, an armful of beach gear and a table hunt simultaneously!

    • 7.0
      Pizza$$$$
      1907 Avenue U (btw E. 19th St. & Ocean Ave.), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Tom D.

        Tom D. • December 26, 2012Great pizza place that's been around for decades. Just stay away from the Djon chicken slice. It's a wet napkin.

    • 8.8
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      7305 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Visit L.

        Visit L. • February 9, 2014Love this restaurant. Food is excellent. Waiters are the best.

    • 8.6
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      147 McClean Ave, Staten Island
      Save
      • Angela L.

        Angela L. • June 28, 2015$3 bottled beer and a crispy grandma's slice! Heaven!

    • 6.9
      Pizza$$$$
      3845 Nostrand Ave (Avenue Y and Z), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Brianna C.

        Brianna C. • October 18, 2012White slices are amazing!!!!!!

    • 7.0
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      2823 Avenue U, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ian L.

        Ian L. • July 15, 2017The Sicilian with breadcrumbs and cheese is superb. So is the Grandma slice.

    • 7.8
      Pizza$$$$View Menu
      5408 Avenue N, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ted L.

        Ted L. • December 18, 2016The old fashioned pizza (square) is better than L&B in Bensonhurst. The Grandma is the Best I've tasted.

    • Category icon
      ?
      Pizza$$$$
      3335 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn
      Save
    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.