Jennifer Y. • August 5, 2022Similar-ish menu to its sibling restaurant and the OG, Emily. Can't go wrong with any of the pizzas, and of course, get the burger.
Amanda G. • June 10, 2018Good, solid pizza. We liked original with pepperoni and tri color the best.
Eater • March 16, 2016Matthew Kenney's vegan pizzeria serves pies topped with things like farro-fennel sausage, almond ricotta, cashew mozzarella, and smoked oyster mushrooms.
Fabian M. • July 27, 2022The best. And I mean best 99ct pizza in New York. It’s got everything it’s quick it’s delicious and it’s still 99ct unlike many of the Inflation-adjusted 1.50$ ones. PUT HOT SAUCE ON IT! Trust me
Alerrandro C. • May 15, 2015A pizza é boa, bem no estilo italiano. Uma dá para 2 se não comer muito. O destaque são as cervejas. A Sixpoint Sweet Action é muito boa.
Justine W. • May 29, 2013CASH ONLY. Great pizza with thin crust. Try the large with 3 different pizza selections on one pie. Delicious!
Graham S. • April 9, 20115$ for 2 slices and a soda will be ready quick, will fill you up, and their plain slices are great. Great NY-minute meal.
ºDamian W. • October 20, 2012You can't beat the decor here, they put in the extra effort to make your experience just right here. Good stuff! Go when the back patio is open!
Marc • March 8, 2013Tasting Table says: This famed Carmine Street pizzeria has opened a Union Square location. This is the first expansion in 37 years.
Syl L. • December 12, 2011Order online in no time. No phone call. All the work is the best! Love it!
Carol • May 3, 2023Went for their soft launch and wasn’t disappointed! The 10” pizzas are $22. Def get (bulgogi) pizza and waffle fries. The sauce is bomb! Service is impeccable & friendly. Menu is expanding. Must visit
Ebrahim B. • December 27, 2018The lamb shank $35 was amazing, hunk of meat and bone enough for two Planted on a bed of yellow polenta with a few roast carrots on the side, the cut had been braised in wine tasty bit.ly/2ERVQqR
Clay F. • December 16, 2020A truly great slice shop. I'd rather these than Joe's tbh. I know that's low key slander but I stand by it. Great pizza by a genuinely nice shop owner.
Ari S. • August 26, 2012Legit NY slice, the thick slices are great too. Buffalo chicken is hard to beat, love me some solo!
Jordan M. • April 28, 2012Best margarita pizza I've ever tasted. Tried many other slices. It beats them all.
NearSay NYC • July 25, 2011N-Sider favorite: We have been eating here since they first opened up and it's great to have a place like this that you can go to late at night. Did we mention that it's only $1 a slice!!!
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.