Suggestions for Seafood Restaurant near Montauk

Sam P. • October 3, 2013The meal was nothing to write home about, but it's a nice little local spot tucked away off the main roads with an amazing view and decent seafood. Great place for a sunset cocktail.

Matt H. • August 24, 2014Everything, particularly the sushi, chowder and fried whole fish app.

Dmitry • August 29, 2012Great place for lunch or dinner. Above getaway from the glitz of the hamptons. Fish is fresh and great. Great restaurant on the water.

Nikki W. • October 1, 2020Great food. Lobster fried rice, steak are all great.

Jesse G. • June 4, 2021Highly recommend the tuna tostada, the fish and chips (light and delicious), of course the oysters, and the cocktails. The Como la Flour was delightful.

Mike P. • August 9, 2019Grilled tuna on a bed of greens was super fresh and tasty.

Mike t. • September 9, 2017Nice place by the marina. Solid menu. Lobster is a must as well as the breaded scallops. Go for dinner and enjoy the sunset.

Christopher S. • August 24, 2014The Shagwong may also be a famous fishing spot just off the shores of Montauk, but you won't forget their steaks that are seared to perfection. Scallops and/or fried calamari are also worth the wait.

Nicolas S. • May 23, 2019I had the opportunity to try their Mtk Exclusive Burger with Lobster and Fish Tacos. Burger could be really good if they would do something with seasoning for meat. Fish tacos were really good.

Andrea B. • July 10, 2011Mussels and frites were amazing. Best dish vs ceviche and tuna tartar. By far.

Char • December 27, 2019Lobster 🦞 🍔 burger was EXCELLENT!!! The chef was very friendly, totally sold me on the lobster burger, and it was fantastic, 10/10!

Jenny R. • May 31, 2015You can't go wrong with scallops. Sushi, fried. Anything scallop. And the blackened swordfish.

Elyse E. • July 12, 2017The scallop ceviche is everything! So flavorful and fresh. Wonderful, quiet atmosphere. One of my new MTK faves that hasn't gotten too crowded yet.

Ian Y. • July 26, 2011Excellent produce, fish - and meat!

Jon C. • June 2, 2019Chill, but active, great place to see some boats

David 🎉 L. • June 29, 2022Outstanding local little necks and oysters on the half shell. Fish, lobster, and bbq beef tacos are large with a tasty salad and aioli inside a flour soft shell.

PureWow • June 14, 2016Expect a buzzy, casual vibe and lots of fresh fish at the new Montauk outpost. One lobster roll, please--and don’t skimp on the claw meat.

Nabil B. • August 24, 2019Simple place on the water. Yummy seafood, king crab legs, chowder soup. Bon fire, marshmallows over fire

Udi R. • November 16, 2014Calamari salad spectacular, big portions, great wine, fantastic ambient, good meat as well.

Carli D. • July 23, 2016Lunch menu is excellent. Scallops and beet salad in particular were well prepared and perfect for a summer day.

Ellie R. • June 13, 2013Great open air bar area that also includes a large covered area as well. Loved the fried asparagus and seared sea scallops.

K G. • August 12, 2011Try the Shrimp Wreck bloody Mary.