Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Firefly Grill

Firefly Grill

Bar, Seafood Restaurant, and Pizzeria$$$$
Effingham
Save
Share
8.9/10
150
ratings
  • Tips
    Brant M.
    "Great food in the middle of Illinois."(2 Tips)
    Jacob U.
    "Montana mignon was tasty."(2 Tips)
    Michelle C.
    "Chicken and waffles were crazy good!"(2 Tips)
    Marjorie B.
    "steak like butter"(3 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon50 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • illinois
  • montana mignon
  • good for dates
  • trendy
  • Southern food
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Kerbsheart icon on user image
    KerbsMarch 9, 2013
    Food was amazing and I loved the atmosphere. If you are looking for real good food in southern Illinois this place is it. Specials are made fresh, definitely start there!
  • K. M.heart icon on user image
    K. M.January 5, 2018
    My all time favorite restaurant, the food is flavorful, savory, and to die for! It's a bit noisy but if you don't go during a rush hour it's not so bad. Friendly staff who make you feel very welcome.
  • Cassie G.
    Cassie GarveyAugust 24, 2013
    450 miles in the car and a fantastic place to stop and get lunch. the food is fantastic, the employees are very nice, and the atmosphere is great!
  • Brant M.heart icon on user image
    Brant McQuittyApril 18, 2016
    Been here 25+ times
    Great food in the middle of Illinois. Excellent seafood and modern American options. Excellent service.
  • Shannae W.heart icon on user image
    Shannae WeaverMay 11, 2015
    It's all good but my favorite is the ranch dressing! Check out specials and it's cheaper than eating at McDonalds! Love all staff too!
  • Sadie J.
    Sadie JeanSeptember 6, 2011
    It was an absolute treat stopping here. The quesadillas were amazing, the pizza was great- a little salty for me but I dont eat salt much so I could taste it, and the clam chowder was fantastic!
  • dorothy p.
    dorothy petersenSeptember 27, 2014
    Great service. Amazing entrées. Well worth the road trip from STL. Had the seafood tower and tiramisu. WONDERFUL
  • Megan W.heart icon on user image
    Megan WilloughbyJuly 11, 2014
    A must stop in Effingham. Delicious food, a relaxed atmosphere, and friendly staff. Enjoyed dining on the porch.
  • Brandon M.heart icon on user image
    Brandon MorrisSeptember 3, 2020
    Chicken piccata was fantastic and the homemade sauce is great!
  • Jacob U.heart icon on user image
    Jacob UnderwoodDecember 28, 2018
    Montana mignon was tasty. After seeing it, I wish I would have ordered bone-in ribeye. I had order envy.
  • Betsy
    BetsyMay 25, 2013
    Amanda is super good with kids. An excellent server. Been a long time since I could say that about a waitress! Food is beyond amazing.
  • Michelle C.
    Michelle CNovember 30, 2013
    Outstanding food and service. Even offered beverages for the road since we're traveling. Chicken and waffles were crazy good!
  • Marjorie B.
    Marjorie BlackmanApril 12, 2012
    Food is amazing; lobster pot pie was wonderful, steak like butter, excellent scallops. Worth stopping while on the road.
  • Jason C.
    Jason CampbellApril 11, 2012
    What a fantastic place and story. Try anything and everything. As many times I have been here, I've never had a bad anything.
  • Chris H.heart icon on user image
    Chris HankenAugust 1, 2017
    I had the burger. It was pretty tasty but messy with all the toppings. And expensive!
  • Chris N.
    Chris NortonSeptember 3, 2013
    A great dining experience in a small town. Definitely worth the price of admission.
  • Pete V.
    Pete Van BaalenJuly 12, 2014
    Good food, especially for Effingham. Very good beer selection on tap.
  • Sally W.
    Sally WallaceMarch 22, 2014
    A pleasant little surprise in a cool little town. Yum!
  • Ken W.heart icon on user image
    Ken WelshAugust 5, 2016
    One of the best restaurants in the state! $$$ but :)
  • Chris B.heart icon on user image
    Chris BozarthJuly 20, 2017
    Great atmosphere reasonably price food was awesome
  • Darlaheart icon on user image
    DarlaNovember 3, 2016
    Steakburger was delicious!
  • Sean L.heart icon on user image
    Sean LackeySeptember 21, 2014
    Probably the best place to eat between Memphis and Chicago.
  • Joya H.
    Joya HoldenJuly 7, 2013
    Yum!!! If you have to drive from Texas to Michigan...make a point of stopping here.
  • Chris N.heart icon on user image
    Chris NixonJune 17, 2016
    Fish Tacos and Crabcakes
  • Fred S.
    Fred SimpsonApril 22, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    A little pricey, but everything here is good. Treat yourself occasionally.
  • Jason C.
    Jason CampbellApril 11, 2012
    Do yourself a favor and stop and enjoy food. Farm to plate for the most part. I have been here more than a few times & never a bad anything.
  • Shannae W.heart icon on user image
    Shannae WeaverMay 11, 2015
    Love the mushroom pizza!!
  • Susan P.heart icon on user image
    Susan PrichardOctober 26, 2014
    Great food and beautiful outdoor seating.
  • Thea C.heart icon on user image
    Thea ChesleyNovember 19, 2017
    Appetizer pizza was delicious.
  • Kellen R.heart icon on user image
    Kellen ReeceJune 21, 2014
    Food is amazing. A must try.
  • Amy S.
    Amy SpectorJune 28, 2013
    Get the garlic steak fries. Amazing!!
  • Weldon D.
    Weldon DunstonJuly 13, 2013
    Get the WINGS!!! Best wings I've ever had!!!!!
  • Dane K.
    Dane KantnerNovember 27, 2010
    great option for local, sustainable food... great food, great drinks. (the only option I think...)
  • Michael H.heart icon on user image
    Michael HaganAugust 10, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Fresh garden menu!
  • Aaron A.
    Aaron AaronJune 12, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Love the risotto. Everything on the menu is solid
  • Kevin D.
    Kevin DMay 9, 2012
    Great pizza, even better atmosphere.
  • John D.
    John DamoreAugust 20, 2011
    The onion rings appetizer is HUGE and delicious!
  • Mel W.
    Mel W.March 11, 2012
    Menu shows where food comes from -- locavore friendly
  • Jay A.
    Jay AllenAugust 4, 2013
    Chicken and Waffles 'nuff said!
  • Aaron A.
    Aaron AaronJune 25, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    The price of burgers have went up. Some say the salads are where it's at.
  • John P.
    John PaffApril 14, 2014
    Tasty, but slow. Plan to linger.
  • sami l.
    sami latourNovember 4, 2011
    Nick the manager is Amesome! Place is great!
  • Elizabeth B.
    Elizabeth BuntonOctober 2, 2011
    They have the best bartender in town!
  • Chris B.
    Effingham's best kept secret.
  • Eric S.heart icon on user image
    Eric SplechterDecember 8, 2012
    Delicious!!!!
  • Michael T.heart icon on user image
    Michael TribbleJuly 20, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Jesse rocks! Great suggestions.
  • Bryant L.heart icon on user image
    Bryant LevinMarch 22, 2010
    Try the Iceberg Wedge and the Montana Mignon. Read more
  • Gheart icon on user image
    GJuly 27, 2017
    very slow service
  • Andy W.
    Andy WynnJuly 19, 2010
    A gem in a small town.
  • Bryant L.heart icon on user image
    Bryant LevinFebruary 6, 2010
    A must stop in Effingham
Photos137 Photos

Related Searches

  • firefly grill effingham •
  • firefly grill effingham photos •
  • firefly grill effingham location •
  • firefly grill effingham address •
  • firefly grill effingham •
  • firefly grill effingham •
  • stadium grill effingham •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA