Gamla / Old Iceland
Restaurant
Miðborg, Reykjavík
"The cod, shellfish soup, brownie and rhubarb cake were all amazing."(8 Tips)
"The cod and fish soup are delicious and are beautifully presented."(12 Tips)
"The cod with root veggies and the fish stew were both outstanding!"(21 Tips)
"The restaurant owner's mom bakes the rhubarb cake and the brownies!"(3 Tips)
92 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- soup
- lamb
- rhubarb cake
- healthy food
- comfortable
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
MarieJuly 1, 2018This place is so cute and rustic! Quite tiny but cozy and worth the 20 minute wait. The food is fantastic! The cod with root veggies and the fish stew were both outstanding! Great drinks & desserts!
Hanna JohanssonJanuary 13, 2017We had the lobster soup and the cod with mashed potatoes. It was the best cod I've ever had. So delicious I highly recommend it. Great service as well. And the place has a really nice vibe.
Miguel Roberto MangligotMay 10, 2022Had the traditional lamb soup, braised beef cheeks and the rhubarb cake. All really great. The beef cheeks in particular made the meal for me! Very soft, tender and flavourful!
Yakubu BayiFebruary 27, 2020Lamb is great but the cod is superb. Service and friendliness of the staff is excellent. They held our reservation for 2 hours, despite a 1 hour waiting list, as our flight was delayed.
maite aNovember 27, 2016Really good icelandic food. The soup was amazing, and the fish was really fresh and nicely cooked to keep the natural taste. Totally recommended. In the range of 50$
Thiago MaiaDecember 30, 2015Just amazing. It was all perfect. Best restaurant in Reykjavik for sure. Fish Soup WOW, Cod WOW (best I ever had) and Skyr WOW. Staff is also amazing.
Lina BodestadMay 1, 2017Don't let the name fool you - this is not a tourist trap, but rather a cosy, semi-upscale place w/ delicious food. The lamb and cod were excellent. Plus they have cool wall murals of different fish.
Tamara HissOctober 5, 2016I ve had an amazing cod, with smashed potatoes and vegetables! Really recommend it! And I also loved the butter with truffles they've brought with the bread! The staff is gentle and friendly!
Darshy NApril 11, 2016Cozy vibes, authentic eats, they don't lie when they say the lamb in Iceland is the best you'll ever have! Get a taste of both seafood and meat soup by opting for appetizer portions.
Taci O.S.December 26, 2016The creamy shellfish soup is the best I've ever tried! Start with that soup and the scallops. Do yourself a favor and order the lamb dish and try not to lick the plate afterwards.- Alexis ScherlAugust 5, 2016The lamb was perhaps the best I've ever eaten. Generous portions, beautifully composed plates with balanced flavor profiles. The restaurant owner's mom bakes the rhubarb cake and the brownies!
What's Good HereJuly 4, 2015Fillet of cod seasoned with garlic and angelica; served with potatoes, root vegetables and salad. Fresh and perfectly cooked and seasoned.
Mu-An 👾March 16, 2016Friendly staff, good food, gets packed at 6:30. They take reservations and has free wifi for some reasons. ☺️
Amy KoenigJanuary 21, 2014A lovely, low-lit, homey little oasis off the main shopping street. The owner is extremely friendly, the food is good, and they brew a mean cappuccino. Also, free wifi!
Maya 🐟March 29, 2017Can't go wrong with anything on the menu but DO NOT SLEEP on the shellfish soup! You need it.
- maite aNovember 27, 2016Authentic food in a really cozy atmosphere. Amazing local flavors. The soup and the cod is a must
Kate FurmanMay 27, 2015A cosy restaurant with Icelandic vibes. Try the fish soup, it comes with excellent dipping breads.
Ludko RuschMay 13, 2019Amazing food! Highly recommended! We have had cod, lamb, beef cheek and the great fish soup !
- What's Good HereJuly 4, 2015Get this as a starter - seafood soup with chunks of fresh fish,white wine, herbs and cream.
- Ann SinOctober 28, 2021Great food! I highly recommend it to everyone visiting Reykjavik! Shellfish soup was amazing! Super lamb and fish, too!
- Richard NMay 28, 2017Most tender lamb I've had. Better than organic Welsh even. They cook it sous vide!
Jack LiuDecember 25, 2016As good as it gets in reykjavik. Can be tough to find a table without a reservation thou. Both soups are delicious.
JustinApril 15, 2016Cozy little place w. incredibly friendly staff. The fish was cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. Highly recommended!
Klara LichtNovember 28, 2015Lovely cozy place, very friendly people and great food. Had the meat soup with lamb and the cod and that was delicious.
Elsa Said-ArmanetAugust 27, 2016This was my best restaurant experience in Reykjavik. One of the few fancy places where we didn't need to book a table in advance. At worst, wait for 5-10 min for a table to become available.- Tamara HissOctober 5, 2016The cod with smashed potatoes and vegetables is a good choice! Very tasty and one of the best I ve had in Iceland!
Cosette EliasonJune 9, 2016Shellfish soup to start, fillet of lamb for the entrée, and affogato to finish.
Ty JaquezMarch 10, 2015Phenomenal food and very friendly waiters! This is definitely a place to stop on your trip to Reykjavik!
Nate MeyerJuly 12, 2017Everything was incredible. Best lamb I've ever had, the cod was excellent and the fish soup was a must.- Lindsey ChunMay 1, 2017Cozy restaurant serving small portions at a high price. Food was good though. Lamb cooked nicely, shellfish soup good but rich, salad could use more greens
Victoria TerebrjuhovaDecember 2, 2019Small and very friendly restaurant with absolutely delicious food!
- AshleyMay 30, 2017Highly recommend! The cod, shellfish soup, brownie and rhubarb cake were all amazing.
Dimitris VergitsisNovember 28, 2021Shelfish soup, meat soup, cod with shampagne sauce and lamb ribeye were all great!!
Valentina StephanenkoJanuary 6, 2014The most wonderful cafe on the walking street. The owner is very friendly and makes you feel comfortable.
Svala Eldberg ÞorleifsdóttirNovember 28, 2013Delicious Icelandic meat soup and nice coffee at a reasonable price. Good service and friendly atmosphere.
Annie ChangMay 12, 2013Friendly service, great vegetables in the lamb stew. Cream and fruit cocktail cake on Sundays! Delicious ^_^
Tuomo LindqvistJanuary 11, 2014The fish soup is absolutely delicious! Great place to have lunch. Warm and welcoming atmosphere.- What's Good HereJuly 8, 2015Be sure to call for a reservation. This is a small venue, but worth the visit.
Bogdan AioaneiMarch 25, 2016Really good sea food and deserts. Staff was incredibly nice. Definitely check it out.
Lubos JantoJune 30, 2015Fish on lunch menu was excellent , soups ( we had both) were not disappoitment but we had better , cozy and nice staff
Lauren ChristopherJuly 17, 2018Amazing fish dishes! Very original taste and presentation. Great date spot!
168 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Traditional Icelandic diner
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–11:00 PM
+354 551 6131
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Music
No
Dining Options
Table Service
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Tasting Menu
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Flatbread with hummus and paprika spread, roasted cauliflower and lamb ribs are my fave. All the cocktails are amazing."
Arnór Hreiðarsson - 8.9
"We went to the Reykjavik for a lunch. They offer a nice lunch menu for reasonable prices, from which we chose the fish of the day - it was absolutely amazing!"
Hannah - 9.0
"Cosy interior, delicious food, perfect place for a lovely dinner in Reykjavik."
line andermark
Places people like to go after Gamla / Old Iceland
Appears on 546 lists
Created by Thomas Dori
31 items • 2 followers
Created by Yelnur Sultanbekov
8 items • 2 followers