See all
267 photos

Gari of Columbus

Sushi Restaurant and Japanese Restaurant$$$$

Upper West Side, New York

Save

Gari of Columbus

8.6^/10

256

ratings

Ranked #2 for sushi restaurants in the Upper West Side
"The omakase tasting menu sushi and shashimi is a must."(36 Tips)
"Salmon Tomato sushi"(3 Tips)
"sweet tuna with pinenut and spicy scallop handroll"(3 Tips)
"Try the chef's tasting menu... it's amazing."(4 Tips)

83 Tips and reviews

Filter:

omakase
sushi
tasting menu
good for dates
healthy food
hand rolls
roses
salads
desserts
tomatoes
brunch food
bar
good for special occasions
dinner
chef special
eel
crowded
Spanish mackerel
avocado
mushrooms
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

HanzAugust 20, 2012
Perhaps one of New York's most unique & exciting sushi experiences. For veterans, lovers, and those who are new to the art, this is a must do and the Omakase special is a great place to start!
CBDecember 13, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Quality of sushi is outstanding- would rank Gari at the top of the places in Manhattan. There are no bargains here. Get salmon sushi with roasted tomato and spicy scallop hand roll.
The Corcoran GroupNovember 4, 2011
Like it’s sister restaurants, they’re serving some of the freshest and tastiest Sushi in all of Manhattan – it’s like you’re in Tokyo. Splurge on the chef’s omakase.
Nic CopeDecember 26, 2011
They do vegetarian omakase upon request! Get the omakase at the bar. 14 veggie pieces for ~$50 or 14 seafood pieces for ~$90. Friendly service and the best sushi I've had make it worth every cent.
Adrian LDecember 23, 2015
Only come here if you can budget about $100 for omakase. You will not be disappointed. My favorite was the double uni - one from Japan, one from Cali, stacked on top of one another. Supreme.
Halstead PropertyJuly 25, 2011
Freshness is the name of the game when it comes to sushi. The lobster tempura was outstanding, and for those who aren’t fish-lovers, the breast of duckling was extremely tender and perfectly flavored.
Andrea Weiss WeissJuly 10, 2013
Would eat here every day if I could! The fish is extremely fresh and you can taste the difference. cute/cozy atmosphere too. Hajiki seaweed salad is great.
Jane ChuMay 7, 2012
The tuna here is really good and overall the fish are all fresh. However, I go mainly for the tuna. This location is the best imo of all the Gari restaurants in NYC.
Jason H.March 25, 2017
It's very good but IF you're going to do the omakase go to the East Side location. Much more wow factor there. At this location - just order off the menu.
Alana FrankfortMarch 29, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Salmon Tomato sushi is a must... and if you really want to splurge, it's worth getting the omakase... an unforgettable experience!
JennaSeptember 13, 2011
Sensational! The. Best. Sushi. Ever. And do not fail to try an utterly amazing seaweed salad either. End your meal here with mochi and smile all the way home.
Raymond MannJuly 9, 2013
Get the omakase. But also ask them to surprise you if your still hungry. Easily one of the most inventive sushi houses in NYC.
BenMay 6, 2015
Best sushi in the upper west side, hands down. Great selection of sake - expect to pay for it though.
JLSeptember 14, 2015
Delicious, Cousy, service is excellent. They will charge your phone if needed.
NathanFebruary 9, 2015
If you couldn't manage to snag a seat at the sushi bar, the sushi deluxe does the trick.
Christopher CocchiaraleyFebruary 4, 2012
Tender and tasty sushi niigiri await you at this energetic, yet overpriced, neighborhood favorite. Bring your appetite and a credit card. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
ChubbyChineseGirlFebruary 17, 2013
Best salmon skin roll in the city. Super crunchy. Yum. Gari's sushi are creative and yummy too.
Alina Alya GruzdevaJuly 10, 2012
Highly recommend: chapped eel with avocado and salmon with hot tomato!!
Roman TyrsinSeptember 6, 2012
Omakase! Omakase! Omakase! It is so scrumptious!!! If you come here you have to try Omakase!
Jennifer NypFebruary 12, 2013
must order: fried oysters, salmon with hot tomato, squid, yellowtail and they have a pretty good rose.
Alex KeslingAugust 10, 2014
Try the chef's tasting menu... it's amazing.
BrandonOctober 6, 2017
Freshness is amazing but $150 for a 12, single piece, omakase is just crazy.
Yasser MasoodMarch 4, 2014
Free hot green tea after your meal to help the digestion. Water refilled are free and unlimited.
Damian CorbettFebruary 17, 2012
The omakase tasting menu sushi and shashimi is a must. My first time here surely won't be the last.....
SuleeMarch 21, 2013
Salmon skin, squid/shiso, spicy tuna all delish!
Benjy WeinbergerMarch 15, 2012
The omakase is very pricy but more than worth it. By far my best sushi experience outside Japan.
Lucy H.February 27, 2017
"Fusion" omakase meant one piece of sushi had a warm tomato topping. Good pieces didn't make up for the bad ones IMO.
Nadim JaberMarch 12, 2013
Amazing! Order the omakase! No questions asked!
Pat NakajimaJuly 16, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Sit at the sushi bar, by yourself. Order a bottle of nigori. Get the omakase.
EviJuly 29, 2019
Amazing sushi. Pricey but worth it!
Serena TMarch 4, 2016
Been here 5+ times
i liked all the gari style sushi except the tomato/salmon
LindsJune 6, 2012
The wait staff are literally depressed if you sit at the sushi bar and try to ask for anything other than sushi. Don't make them sad, it's DEF worth it to just go with whatever they recommend.
NY WaterwayAugust 23, 2012
The seabass here was one of the best dishes we have ever had! Delicious!
Chiara PedroniMay 26, 2014
One word: omakase! it's divine
Kristina KorhonenJanuary 8, 2019
The omakasse is to die for!
MargotAugust 15, 2011
Salmon with tomato, sweet tuna with pinenut and spicy scallop handroll are my faves!
VernaMarch 31, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Faves: salmon tomato, snapper with salad, tuna with tofu sauce and spicy scallop roll
BalyNovember 13, 2013
Don't be fooled by the disposable chopsticks and paper napkins. This is good stuff.
The Fun Consultant!April 9, 2017
Omakase is a must👌🏼
Sandra DavisFebruary 20, 2013
Sushi is outstanding !!! It's insatiable, can't get enough.
LaurenAugust 15, 2010
Read in a guidebook it was top 5 sushi in nyc, the book wasn't lying! Some of the best sushi I have ever had!!!
Emil MoshkovichJune 30, 2013
Save yourself time. Just sit at the bar and tell them when to stop.
Melody AngelesJuly 22, 2013
I haven't had ordered anything bad from Gari so come try it out
Blair PeckaFebruary 1, 2014
Go to the bathroom. You're welcome.
Matt BrittonApril 13, 2011
Been here 5+ times
The salmon pieces with tomatoe on top is original and a must have!!
DaveFebruary 1, 2015
Omakase is an incredible experience.
Marissa SolomonJune 24, 2012
Best sushi. Try the spicy tuna roll. Wow!
Restaurant FairyMay 5, 2013
Try the @gari - Spanish Mackerel with mushroom
Youn jung KimJune 26, 2015
The best sushi in my life.
DAVID DANESHDecember 20, 2011
Been here 5+ times
ive been here over 200 times... salmon tomato is still the best piece

1 2

267 Photos

Gari of Columbus

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Gari of Columbus

Appears on 258 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.