Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Heidi's House By The Side Of The Road
Comfort Food Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$
Upper East Side, New York
The mac & cheese at Heidi's House By The Side Of The Road is a can't miss
"chocolate souffle or date pudding..."(4 Tips)
"Lobster Mac and cheese and tuna tartar are amazing"(7 Tips)
"Heidi is amazing and the tuna tartare is out of this world!"(5 Tips)
"had the lamb gnocchi special and it was amazing!"(10 Tips)
81 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- mac & cheese
- good for dates
- date pudding
- cute
- gluten-free food
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
AlAnoud A AlGhunaimFebruary 20, 2022The coziest place I’ve been to in a while, really crowded. Brisket and lobster mac and cheese, paella, and their gnocchi👌🏻 the vibe itself is worth the visit guys.
Kristina RudicJanuary 25, 2015One of the best meals I've had in NYC. Lobster mac & cheese is everything they've said it is and for dessert, don't miss the date pudding! It's absolutely amazing.
KinoApril 9, 2017The Mac & Cheese here is my favorite in all of NYC. I'm not sure what cheese blend they use, but it's an excellent combination. No beer taps & no reservations. Bottled beer. Wine bar feeling.
Best lobster Mac & cheese I ever had! The burger was good too! Small place and a little hot inside 4 me, next time I'll be sure to wear a tank top! I'm def going back for try the rest of the menu.
Tom DiMaggioMay 29, 2017One of my favorite local spots in the UES, make reservations early because there is limited seating. I could recommend everything, the food is consistently good.
WendyJuly 23, 2014The paella is a amazing! Not too salty or greasy and the right amount of seafood chorizo! A great selection of wine. Call ahead to reserve a spot or risk waiting a while!
Rachel MartinAugust 19, 2018Tuna Tartar was amazing! Definitely a must have. We had the short ribs special that was so delicious and the Mac and cheese with mushrooms and truffle oil. Best comfort food in NYC.
The mac and cheese is incredible, but I’d also recommend any of their specials. Had a gnocchi tonight and it was the pillow-iest gnocchi I’d ever tasted
Andie SleemanDecember 14, 2016Our go to comfort food spot in the neighborhood. Get the Mac & Cheese and the Artichoke Salad. Their beer selection is great (always a few options on "special" for $5).
Michelle KramerNovember 2, 2012Heidi is super sweet! Make sure to call ahead and put your name on the list or you'll wait for over an hour. The shrimp tacos and Mac 'n Cheese are both amazing!
- Randi CharlesNovember 22, 2013One of the coziest and best meals I've ever had in NYC. Heidi is amazing and the tuna tartare is out of this world! Definitely call ahead- she'll hold a table for you.
Marines MendezMarch 19, 2016Artichoke dip is to die for, as is the Osso Bucco. Will keep going back until I try their entire menu! Always packed so don't go when in a hurry
Leisha MagsisiJanuary 13, 2015Perfect date spot! Cute and cozy with amazing food! I've always ordered the special and have never been disappointed. Save room for dessert!!
If the daily special pasta is gnocchi - get it! Heidi's has the best gnocchi I've ever had! 🙌
Bonnie CarpenterSeptember 9, 2014Their guacamole is so good. These girls know their wine and love how it's hidden between the avenues. Small but it's part of its charm
Menu changes frequently, but can't go wrong with any of the dishes. Great wine and bottle beer list. This place is tiny, though, so get here early!
NadiaMarch 15, 2014Mac and cheese was a huge portion and too rich for my taste but their shrimp tacos and pasta of the day was delicious. Cozy and friendly atmosphere.
Matt BorstFebruary 28, 2012Loving this Rioja. Adorable place with incredible food across the board. I love that they get their bread from Orwashers around the corner (also highly recommended).
Brandon F.July 20, 2014Exceptional service despite its small setting. Good selection of wines and IPA's. Their pan seared steamed vegetables are exquisite.
HangryHeidiMarch 2, 2015Great atmosphere, great food and a great selection of wine and beer. What a find!
Ani ZApril 1, 2014The lobster Mac and cheese and the braised short ribs #hallelujah. Get the Tempranillo with it. Orgasm in your mouth #won'tDisappoint
stephanieDecember 24, 2012they don't take reservations, but you can call ahead and put your name on the list, and they'll call you to come when your table is ready.- lauren sandonatoJanuary 11, 2016had the lamb gnocchi special and it was amazing! great little spot if you live in UES.
Dana MarkiewiczMarch 11, 2013GREAT hidden wine bar. Tell Heidi what you like and let her choose your wine...never a bad pick, plus EXCELLENT food!
Roy EthanAugust 18, 2018Tuna tartar, Mac & Cheese w/ Bacon and Jalapeño, Paella or Pasta of the day.
C. Sha•Doe McIntoshJanuary 23, 2014Small. Good doe two or three. No more. Eat at the bar. Mary is (singaongy) awes-some. Finally...Eat. Steak! (Trekked from LIC for it.)
Devan PlylerDecember 30, 2017Everything, Mac & the Pork Chop, love the Date Pudding I get it every time
Andrew MichaeloffFebruary 28, 2013Delicious specials and such a cute space ... Make sure you have no more than 6 people in your group or you wont fit ;)
Get anything on this menu. You can't go wrong. Heidi will take care of you, I promise. Chase every meal with Malbec to the dome.
Katie NeufeldAugust 2, 2011Gnocchi is the best I've ever had. Personally I think the mac and cheese is a bit too rich, but basically everything is delicious.
Sebastian NilssonAugust 9, 2014Very allergy-unfriendly. Gluten in almost everything, even the scallops. Gave up after asking about it in 5-6 different dishes.
Nikki MApril 21, 2013Absolutely loved! And Heidi is a doll (thanks for lending the glasses) a must try on the ues!
jamieMarch 12, 2012Since Heidi's is tiny the wait can be long, but it's definitely worth it! Be sure to order the mac and cheese.
Frank KimJuly 1, 2011Very impressive assortment/selection of beers! Had a milk stout and a dark lager here, both of which had never had before.
120 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 5:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 5:00 PM–2:00 AM
(212) 249-0069
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.8
"The Chocolate Milkshake and Truffle Brownie are my favorites."
Alissa - 6.7
"Tried just the Nutella crepe- it was mouth melting, delicious and they were quite generous with the nutella! My new favourite late night dessert spot."
Simrita Chopra - 7.6
"Great breKfast try the western omelette sandwich :-) Delish"
Kathy O'Shea
Places people like to go after Heidi's House By The Side Of The Road
- 8.6
"This place is awesome if you like Craft Beer. Have a Third Rail beer if they have them! Field 2 or Bodega, you can't go wrong!"
Craig K - 8.4
"Try Black bottom pie or blueberry flavors or the sorbets, perfect respite for hot summers"
Maryam
- 8.7
"Everything is great, food and drinks! Sometimes they have live music and it's even better. Great casual date spot."
Stephanie Cesear
Appears on 496 lists
Created by Lindsey M
200 items • 150 followers
Created by Matthew
188 items • 51 followersCreated by Matt Borst
90 items • 34 followers
