See all
128 photos

Hill And Bay

American Restaurant$$$$

Rose Hill, New York

Save

Hill And Bay

6.3^/10

283

ratings

"not large beer selection."(3 Tips)
"Mac and cheese was amazing, along with their fries!"(6 Tips)
"Classic burger cooked exactly to order was delicious and juicy."(9 Tips)
"Strong cocktails, friendly staff and a great burger."(6 Tips)

61 Tips and reviews

Filter:

burgers
happy hour
healthy food
good for groups
casual
coffee
trendy
biscuits
Kale Caesar
Caesar salad
good for dates
muffins
wifi
breakfast food
pot pies
spicy food
good for a quick meal
sandwiches
restaurants
spinach
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Andrew COctober 17, 2017
Tiny physical space and had 30+ min wait, but it was absolutely worthwhile... cocktails had perfect balance of liquor and other flavours + french fries were perfect + burger was on point!!
Karen LMay 28, 2016
Stop by their coffee window regularly and I love their lattes. The foam is creamy and ace and double thumbs up for the service! I love when great businesses like hill and bay come to my neighborhood.
Jenny LeeDecember 10, 2018
Classic burger cooked exactly to order was delicious and juicy. No romaine lettuce due to ecoli outbreak (very thoughtful). Recommend the sautéed kale. Nicely cooked, good portion. Relaxed ambiance.
Upvoted Feb 23
Jason YoungOctober 2, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Super friendly and awesome staff! Great draft selection! Food was all pretty decent! All in all great new addition to the neighbor, looking forward to how it is once it's fully settled in! :)
Khalid ElachiAugust 7, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Pat LaFrieda hamburger done medium well is simply delicious and will satisfy any burger craving. Start off with the deliciously gooey baked Mac and cheese OE the bought make Cesar salad.
Jackie LeeDecember 12, 2014
Perfect for being right across the street from the movie theater! Perfect dinner/movie night. Try the specials for sure... And the "full metal shaker" cocktail for liquid dessert. :)
Leia PFebruary 19, 2016
Strong cocktails, friendly staff and a great burger. Sometimes the spacious back room is empty making it a good place to use the free wifi for a work lunch.
Rosamaria P.January 26, 2014
Great food. Both the fried chicken and the vegetarian pot pie were delicious. Drinks were well executed and staff was super attentive and friendly. Nice date spot as well.
harryhNovember 4, 2014
A fine choice for a place to eat when you're looking for somewhere close to the movie theatre. Their straightforward american fare won't blow you away, but it's totally solid.
Elnara KozlitinaSeptember 25, 2019
Great food! Especially Mac and cheese and split pea soup were sooo yummy 😋 decent but not large beer selection. Great happy hour deals!
John ESeptember 4, 2014
The pulled pork sliders come on a biscuit with the perfect amount of spice...absolutely delicious! Will be back for these for sure!
Jackie SiegelSeptember 28, 2013
Ratatouille and Hanger steak were great. Our party cleaned their plates (flaw: small portions). Great Martinis and a great add to the neighborhood!
James G.November 17, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Bay Benedict: poached eggs, lox, cream cheese on a warm fluffy biscuit. You should probably get it.
Fedor KorotkovSeptember 25, 2019
Great Wings deal on Wednesday from 4pm till midnight. 50% off plus decent selection of beers! 🍺😻
AnnaJanuary 4, 2019
Maybe because it was new years day but we waited 1 hour for food. It was pancakes and fish tacos. Usually they are good. Offer something else or just say you are short staffed.
Khalid ElachiOctober 27, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Burger medium rare is the best! Sit towards the front if you enjoy people watching - full windows are great.
Ali KraftOctober 9, 2013
A little pricey for the neighborhood and service is good if you're looking for a slow relaxing night, but food (fish & chips and steak) was delish!!
Elisa AAugust 20, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Hangover helper during brunch and salmon burger during dinner. Friendliest staff and bomb cocktails.
Caitlin PikeNovember 23, 2013
Solid bloody Mary, great bunch choices. Get the bisket basset. There's more seating in the back too!!
Jason KorenthalApril 4, 2014
Great music with a very classy vibe. Fantastic happy hour until 8pm and a hell of an old fashioned!
Amanda KellyFebruary 18, 2015
Great brunch spot! Check out the ambiance with their virtual tour before you go! Read more
Roxy NederpelAugust 10, 2014
The Mac and cheese is delicious and you can't get enough of the shoestring fries 🙈
Ardit BejkoJanuary 12, 2014
The spicy spinach meatballs are great to share. The prosciutto and the raclete are memorable
ColinDecember 5, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Love the kale Caesar salad. The drinks are also amaze.
Brad BensonOctober 3, 2013
Great food! Everything we ordered was delicious! The fish & chips, especially!
Rose RooneyMarch 31, 2014
Mac and cheese was amazing, along with their fries! Service was great.
CC M.January 22, 2016
Sweet potato fries are delicious. I didn't like the clam chowder soup, it was bland with too many onions.
Jonathan MeasorJune 29, 2023
I like some saucy wings, they have saucy wings.
Kelli SolomonOctober 5, 2013
I came here expecting great things, and nothing was up to par. The service was lacking and the food was so-so. They even ran out of their signature biscuits. The options jon the area are limited so...
Lori K. http://www.lkpheartsfood.netOctober 5, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Love the walk up window for morning coffee & a muffin!
Shrutika SachdevJuly 12, 2014
It's called Hill and Bay because it is between Murray Hill and Kips Bay :)
Neil DuttaDecember 8, 2013
The decor is nice, but we came here on a day when they literally did not have most of the items on their menu in stock. What's up with that!? Sarabeth's is nearby. Just go there instead
Garett PressOctober 20, 2013
Been here twice and had service issues both times (cold food, preparation instructions not followed, etc.) - food is decent for the neighborhood though. Points for effort.
Rajesh MidhaMarch 28, 2015
Great place for a burger pre or post the movies.
Nazli OguzFebruary 19, 2017
It was good, nothing fancy but scrambled eggs and nutty professor was good
Hannah TempleAugust 1, 2014
The fries are delicious!! Worth every calorie!
Francis UdlerJuly 30, 2015
Good addition to the area. Brunch is okay.
Steph DNovember 23, 2013
Worst restaurant ever. 1 hr wait for food, food was terrible, sat us at a table with a wine bottle display as the back of the booth (not really a place for a table). Will never ever come back!!
Corey LevineMarch 11, 2018
The Tater Tots are unreal
YousDecember 8, 2013
Great food but staff is very inexperienced.
Jackie LeeJanuary 12, 2015
Sweet potato fries and happy hour beer flights
JasonOctober 7, 2014
Fun trivia night on Mondays
courtney schielaApril 9, 2016
Incredible food and service
Isabel ZhongOctober 22, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Thin cut beacon and "old fashion"!
Alison CJuly 22, 2017
My grilled cheese was kind of burnt. Underwhelming as a whole.
Emma CramerJune 13, 2015
There's a coffee/smoothie window on 32nd!
Nicolette RomeroJuly 31, 2014
$20 for a carafe of sangria? Yes, please!
Brian McGNovember 22, 2014
Flights of beer available
Erkan AtrekSeptember 23, 2018
All brunch items
Caitlyn FowlesAugust 27, 2014
The cheese plate leaves something to be desired

1 2

128 Photos

Hill And Bay

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Hill And Bay

Appears on 70 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.