Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.John's of Bleecker Street
Pizzeria$$$$
West Village, New York
The folks at Eater and New York Post like this place. Would you agree?
"BEST PIZZA IN NYC - Always get the roasted tomatoes, best topping"(12 Tips)
"Tie between this and Grimaldis for best pizza in NYC"(6 Tips)
"A dreamy classic coal oven pie"(4 Tips)
"Awesome!! Worth the wait for sure...iconic NY pizza spot!"(3 Tips)
218 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- grimaldi
- casual
- whole pies
- good for groups
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Honghui YuDecember 18, 2018The pizza here is delicious. I recommend coming here with a small group and sharing a few different pies to try the most toppings, although their ricotta is my favorite.
Upvoted Oct 10- Mike SingletonApril 25, 2014Authentic, original pizza. If you see a line outside don't be scared away, it's about 15 minutes for every 10 people. Also look out for the signed Pete Rose jersey!
dara lynneJanuary 25, 2014I'm a native New Yorker & incredibly snobby about pizza. BELIEVE THE HYPE, this place is great!You won't need it, but don't be afraid to ask for some Parm (not on the table). Only fail? Nast bathrooms
SolDecember 31, 2018Classic pies in a grungy setting. Great for a casual night with friends. Try to avoid the tourists by going on a weeknight.
John's gets their meat toppings fresh from Faicco's, the Italian butcher down the block. Get sausage pizza here, trust me.
Absolutely my favorite pizza place in NYC. Great service and the quality of their food is consistent and great. I like this better than Grimaldi's.
Celena ChanAugust 3, 2015Absolutely delicious thin crust pizza. We ordered a salad and one pie for two people and had the pie split in half w/ two different combos. Everyone gets what they want!
JP ObandoJanuary 6, 2019Great service! Simple menu! Just get the pizza, no matter what. Pitchers of beer for $22. And worth the wait if there’s a line. Best pie pizza in town!
Jonathan FaccentoAugust 11, 2017Cheese slice 8.8, meatball 9.0. Tastes like Joe's but with better sauce. They don't serve slices, which meant I almost ate the entire pie. Was in and out before the dinner rush, great pizza.
Francis AlvarezJanuary 7, 2023The traditional and the boom, both lacks on flavor (roasted tomatoes are very good), the meat lovers pie has the flavor but’s nothing extraordinary Will recommend if u hungry, close n there’s no line.
Louis MattaAugust 2, 2015Classic pizza place. If you're a one-slicer type of person this is not your jam. No slices all pies, but one bite and you won't regret it.
Cole KennedyOctober 22, 2018It has a reputation for being the best for a reason. (Note that I'm not saying it's the best, because choosing the best pizza in New York is a fool's errand.)
Simple cheese pizza + Caesar salad + carafe of red wine = perfection!
Marc MayerFebruary 21, 2015Real solid pizza. Sometimes it takes a bit for your pie to come out, but it's a million times better than any instant gratification dollar slice joint. Patience is a virtue. Especially with pizza.
Destination: Anywhere & EverywhereAugust 22, 2013While I love all the toppings keeping it simple is the way to go you get to taste the flavors on a crispy slice (sometimes the everything pizza turns soggy)
Patrick LawsonSeptember 30, 2019Definitely worth a visit. Watch them make your pizza in front of you and fire it off. Delicious.
Stephen GatesSeptember 8, 2013If you look up NYC pizza in the dictionary there is a picture of John's Pizza. Be sure to try the coal fired pizza and the sausage sandwich.- DorouliniMay 19, 2018Freshly baked pizza! We ordered the large pepperoni and it was amazing! Old classic decoration.
Meela DudleyJuly 5, 2012First time trying the "best pizza in NYC," apparently going at 10 pm on the fourth of July is the best way to beat the "crazy" lines. No AC, sit at a table with a fan. Seriously is the best pizza.
Carlos RussoOctober 30, 2017Seriously can't miss John's of Bleecker. Amazing and authentic NY pizza. One of our favorite spots in the city.
Katy VerhoevenSeptember 11, 2014Pizza made in stone brick oven, was one of the best I ever had, good music, greate ambiance, cool pictures of famous people who come there
Nabil BazzariAugust 8, 2019Woooow....amaaaazing pizza... yummy pepperoni pizza + get the meatballs with tomato sauce. Must try if in NY
ElizabethAugust 21, 2015There is a reason it is always named as one of the best pizza places. It's crowded though so come early or expect to wait. They only take cash.
FoodtoEatJuly 27, 2012Some of the best pizza in the Big Apple! Stick with the classic cheese pie, with heavenly margarita sauce! Cash only though, but that's how they keep their prices down!
Renee TMay 6, 2015Our favorite spot for a slice. Coal-fired-brick-oven-cheese-&-sausage-light-sauce. Yum!! Line out the door moves quickly, so get in it.
New York PostMay 13, 2015Lou Reed's partner Laurie Anderson tells us he liked the Margherita here. "When you use the right mozzarella, it’s amazing." Read more
Buford BarnesMay 24, 2012Established 1929 and continuously operated. One of the only coal pizza ovens in NYC. As a friend who grew up nearby says, "they have a talent for making burnt pizza and flat cola taste magical."
Tim VetterFebruary 17, 2012One of the few remaining NYC coal oven pizzerias (along with Patsy's & Totonno), where the burn, at 200 Fahrenheit higher than a wood oven, contributes a very special character to the crust. Read more
Joseph StahlDecember 27, 2013Absolutely great pizza. Crust is fantastic and ingredients are high quality. Try to sit in the side room to watch your pizza being made.
CarolApril 4Always a line, but it’s overhyped. If you wanna try it, make sure you know which way the line goes. Someone randomly followed our group to the side and the poor guy lost his spot in the real line
New York HabitatOctober 26, 2011Brick oven cheesiness. Another one of NYC's best spots to get a pizza. They don't do slices so either come here with some friends or be prepared to eat an entire pie by yourself!
Harish HoonJanuary 29, 2015Simple and fresh. I know people come from all over the world to try pizza in New York City. They often go to Lombardi's but should really come here instead!
Jarel HillAugust 1, 2018So good! Classic ny slice. Ricotta with basil was my favorite. Meatball was second then pepperoni- Jarel HillAugust 1, 2018So good! Classic my slice. Ricotta with basil was my favorite. Meatball was second then pepperoni
- Jarel HillAugust 1, 2018So good! Classic my slice. Ricotta with basil was my favorite. Meatball was second then pepperoni
- ElisaFebruary 10, 2019Lineup is worth it, waited about 20-30m during peak time. You can also order to go. Margherita so good. Meatballs are decent but nothing special.
GabiotaSkMay 23, 2018Best pizza in NYC!! I’ve been here a long time ago and came back today. Pizza still tastes as good as I remember!
Village VoiceFebruary 17, 2011Get the black olive and sausage pie-The loamy fennel sausage is freshly made, the tomatoes bright tasting, the canned olives saline, and all the flavors come together deliciously!
AntonellaFebruary 25Might be the best pizza in NYC. Going with original classic pizza. Skip the toppings.
Mathieu VinceletteMay 4, 2015Best pie on Bleeker! Try it with any topping you like. The also have yuengling.
- BEST PIZZA IN NYC - Always get the roasted tomatoes, best topping
FoodSherpas.comAugust 21, 2011Considered by many to be the best pizza in New York, making it's case to be one of the best on the planet! TIP: No slices available at John's, so bring your appetite.
One of the best pizza joints in NYC. They don't take reservations, but worth the wait.
seanFebruary 15, 2015You can watch tourists wait in line for this place across the street from Keste which actually has pretty great pizzas and salads.
883 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:30 AM–11:30 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–Midnight
- Sun
- Noon–11:30 PM
(212) 243-1680
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after John's of Bleecker Street
- 8.8
"Excellent and constantly changing craft beer list. The wings are great too. Can get crowded, but there is no shame sharing tables with strangers."
ben m - 8.3
"Cannoli. They fill them fresh. Nuff said. The tiramisu is also amazing."
Erica Sklar - 9.5
"Beautiful, European style park. Occasional live music and outdoor chess makes it a hit."
Gajtana Simonovska
Appears on 1,700 lists
Created by New York Habitat
44 items • 316 followers
New York's Most Iconic Pizzerias
Created by Eater
25 items • 233 followers
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers
