Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Lucy's Whey

Lucy's Whey

(Now Closed)
Cheese Store
Chelsea, New York
Save
Share
Lucy's Whey
Photos35 Photos
MenuMenu
Menu 5
Cheese‏
Across the Pond
12.00 per Piece
Rich, fruity, and pungent.Made by keeley's cheese company, king ferry, ny. Made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb.
Bonne bouche
11.00 per Wheel
Creamy, floral, and goaty.Vermont butter and cheese creamery, websterville, vt, made with pasteurized goat's milk.Sold by the 4 oz. Wheel
Coupole
16.00 per Wheel
Bright, savory, and dense.Made by vermont butter and cheese creamery, websterville, vt, made with pasteurized goat's milk.Sold by the 6.5 oz. Wheel
Dante
15.00 per Piece
Rich, nutty, and toasty.Made by wisconsin sheep dairy cooperative, river falls, wi, made with pasteurized sheep's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Dunbarton blue
14.50 per Piece
Tangy, fruity, and savory.Made by roelli cheese haus, shullsburg, wi, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Flora nelle
13.00 per Piece
Earthy, savory, and creamy.Made by rogue creamery, central point, or, made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Green hill
18.00 per Wheel
Sweet, buttery, and smooth.Made by sweet grass dairy, thomasville, ga, made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 8 oz. Wheel
Kunik
16.00 per Wheel
Creamy, tangy, and decadent.Made by nettle meadow farm, thurman, ny, made with pasteurized goat's milk and cow's cream.Sold by the 8 oz. Wheel
Manchester
14.00 per Piece
Woodsy, herbaceous, and subtle.Made by consider bardwell farm, west pawlet, vt, made with raw goat's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Mt. Tam
24.00 per Wheel
Rich, milky, and mushroomy.Made by cowgirl creamery, point reyes station, ca, made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 9 oz. Wheel
Pawlet
12.00 per Piece
Tangy, sweet, and grassy.Made by consider bardwell farm, west pawlet, vt, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Prairie breeze cheddar
8.00 per Piece
Sweet, tangy, and creamy.Made by milton creamery, milton, ia.Made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Spring brook farm tarentaise
14.00 per Piece
Nutty, fruity,‏ and savory.Made by spring brook farm, reading, vt, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Bayley Hazen Blue
14.00 per Piece
Crumbly, barnyard-y, and anise-y.Made by jasper hill farm, greens boro, vt, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Cabot clothbound cheddar
10.00 per Piece
Sweet, savory, tangy, and grassy.Aged by the cellars at jasper hill, made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Cremont
12.00 per Wheel
Creamy, buttery, and tangy.Made by vermont butter and cheese creamery, websterville, vt, made with pasteurized goat's milk and cow's cream.Sold by the 5 oz. Wheel
Dorset
13.00 per Piece
Vegetal and loamy.Made by consider bardwell farm, west pawlet, vt, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Ewe's blue
17.00 per Piece
Creamy, fruity, and peppery.Made by old chatham sheepherding company, old chatham, ny, made with pasteurized sheep's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Grayson
12.00 per Piece
Beefy, grassy,‏ and pungent.Made by meadow creek dairy, galax, va, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Harbison
18.00 per Wheel
Luscious, woodsy, sweet.Made by jasper hill farm, greensboro, vt, made with pasteurized cow's milk.Sold by the 2/3 lb. Wheel
Landaff
11.50 per Piece
Bright, tangy, and grassy.Made by landaff creamery, landaff, nh, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Marieke smoked gouda
12.00 per Piece
Smokey, sweet, and creamy.Made by holland's family farm, thorp, wi, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Parmigiano reggiano
12.00 per Piece
Sweet, salty,‏ and rich.Made by latteria sociale rubbianino, reggio emilia, italy, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Point reyes original blue
10.00 per Piece
Lemony, tart, and creamy.Made by point reyes farmstead cheese company, point reyes station, ca, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the 1/2 lb. per Piece
Rush creek reserve
30.00 per Wheel
Woodsy, vegetal, and spoon-able.Made by uplands cheese company, dodgeville, wi, made with raw cow's milk.Sold by the .80 lb wheel
Crackers
Per package
Castleton Rutland Rye Crackers
7.00
Handmade and hand-cracked in castleton, vermont, these rustic crackers break into beautiful pieces for a dashing cheese plate display. These hearty whole grain crackers are topped with caraway, sesame, and poppy seeds, and excellently accompany most cheeses.6 oz. package
Castleton Middlebury Maple Crackers
7.00
Handmade and hand-cracked in castleton, vermont, these rustic crackers break into beautiful pieces for a dashing cheese plate display. The slightly sweet maple flavor makes a nice accompaniment to creamy goat’s milk cheeses or tangy cheddars.6 oz. package
Jams, Chutneys, Confections‏
Per jar
Bonnie's Jams Red Pepper Jelly
12.00
A classic!‏ This jam is delicious with almost any cheese, but especially with a soft goat cheese. It also makes a great addition to a cheddar cheese sandwich.8 oz. jar
June Taylor's Meyer Lemon Marmalade
15.00
This tart and refreshing marmalade is made by june taylor in berkeley, california, who makes preserves with sustainably grown fruit that are fashioned after traditional flavor combinations. Her preserves make great accompaniments for cheese, as well as perfect toppings for grilled meat and fish.8 oz. jar
Oysterponds Farm Red Raspberry Jam
14.00
This red raspberry jam is the best we’ve ever tasted! It’s great on toast, stirred into yogurt or over ice cream. Produced on the north fork of long island by oysterponds farm in orient, new york.8 oz. jar
Bees' Needs Honey
15.00
From the hives of a small-scale beekeeping operation in sag harbor, new york, comes this luscious jar of raw, unheated, unfiltered honey. Enjoy as an accompaniment to your favorite blue cheese, drizzled atop your morning toast with fresh chevre, or stirred into your tea.8 oz. jar
Fat Toad Farm Caramel
12.00
This confection is rich, creamy, and elegant. Made from the milk of fat toad farm’s goats in brookfield, vermont, this caramel is modeled after the mexican confection cajeta. Drizzle over ice cream and other desserts, spread on toast, pair with fresh ricotta or yogurt, and stir into your tea or coffee.8 oz. jar
Miss Amy's Jalapeno Peach Jam
12.00
Both spicy and sweet, this jam is a superb addition to any cheese plate, as well as a great spread for a grilled cheese sandwich. Made in southampton not far from lucy’s whey east hampton shop, this jam is a local favorite throughout the east end of long island.8 oz. jar
Savory Cheese Accompaniments
Creminelli Barolo Salami
18.00 per Piece
Made by creminelli fine meats, this italian-style hard salami made from pork is one of our favorites. The addition of piemontese barolo wine during the curing process lends a richness to the salami that perfectly accompanies any cheese board.Creminelli fine meats, salt lake city, ut, 1/2 lb. per Piece
Mcclure's Garlic Dill Spears
12.00 per Jar
These pickles have a strong sour taste with notes of garlic and dill. Closest in resemblance to your grandmother’s dill pickles.32 oz. jar
Freddy Guys Hazelnuts
9.00 per Package
Sourced from a family-owned hazelnut orchard in the willamette valley of oregon, these hazelnuts are freshly roasted and shipped within three days of roasting.8 oz. package

Problem with this menu?

Related Searches

  • lucy's whey new york •
  • lucy's whey new york photos •
  • lucy's whey new york location •
  • lucy's whey new york address •
  • lucy's whey new york •
  • lucy whey new york •
  • lucy's whey new york •
  • lucys whey new york •
  • lucy's whey chelsea new york

Foursquare © 2025  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Lucy's Whey
425 W 15th St (at 9th Ave)
New York, NY 10011
United States
At: Chelsea Market
Get directions
Information icon
This Lucy’s Whey outpost offers a curated selection of American artisanal cheeses, in the convenience of the bustling Chelsea Market.
Clock icon
Permanently closed (Show more)
  • Mon–Sat
    • 10:00 AM–8:00 PM
  • Sun
    • 10:00 AM–7:00 PM
Phone icon
(212) 463-9500
World Wide Web icon
Twitter icon
@lucyswhey
Instagram icon
@lucyswhey
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
See More

Other places inside Chelsea Market

You might also like

Places people like to go after Lucy's Whey

Appears on 48 lists

See all
United States » New York » New York » Chelsea

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.