Marie Eiffel Market

Restaurant

Shelter Island

Save

Marie Eiffel Market

8.4^/10

ratings

Ranked #4 for restaurants in Shelter Island
"fresh veggies and salad in the case plus a lobster roll"(2 Tips)
"Best breakfast sandwiches on the Island."(2 Tips)
"Coffee gooooood"(2 Tips)
"Your go-to lunch spot during off peak times."(2 Tips)

11 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

Elysia MannJune 23, 2016
Get a by-weight platter of the fresh veggies and salad in the case plus a lobster roll and sit out back
Steve MarcheseJuly 4, 2019
Grab a can of beer from the great selection of local options, a shrimp cocktail, and head to the back with a nice view of the marina.
naveenAugust 27, 2018
for your first lunch after you arrive at Shelter Island: a lobster roll, a Narragansett and a seat out back in the deck. (you can actually boat in as well, because why not?)
Doug WSeptember 17, 2015
pizza missing arugula, maybe they ran out? who knows, good anyway- not the friendliest girl "helping" us, great albeit pricey market
Tom WolfsteinJuly 21, 2017
The omelets and the croissant were great. We also had a breakfast burrito which was good, but it's not big.
Kathryn DMay 28, 2018
Great for picnic supplies.
Willem Van LanckerSeptember 6, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Best breakfast sandwiches on the Island.
Greg DoughertyNovember 11, 2015
Your go-to lunch spot during off peak times.
Cathy WeschlerMay 24, 2016
Order the duck before noon to pick up later in the day.
Izzy HumairAugust 12, 2015
Coffee cake and gelato
Maria PerezDecember 31, 2017
Coffee gooooood

51 Photos