See all
261 photos

Mayfield

American Restaurant$$$$

Crown Heights, Brooklyn

Save

Mayfield

9.0^/10

829

ratings

Ranked #6 for seafood in Brooklyn
The experts at The New Yorker and Serious Eats recommend this place
"Kale Salad👌 Oysters 👌 Pinot Noir 👌 this place is on point!"(18 Tips)
"Plus $1 oysters and draft beers for happy hour...the best!"(8 Tips)
"Great brunch, get the spoon bread."(4 Tips)
"Nothing beats the happy hour oysters!"(4 Tips)

170 Tips and reviews

Filter:

kale salad
good for dates
trendy
happy hour
brunch food
spoon bread
buttermilk fried quail
casual
chicken liver mousse
pork chops
desserts
sandwiches
grits
bar
French toast
ice cream
bread pudding
meats
eggs
outdoor seating
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Nick BurdMay 1, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Love this place! The oysters are great, the burger is maybe the best in NYC, and the apps and drinks are always on point. The best neighborhood joint you could hope for.
Zoe CareyApril 9, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Love this place but prices are going up and portion sizes/quality is going down with its popularity. I get the omelette with smoked salmon, sautéed onions and mushrooms with fries on the side.
Steve SpillmanNovember 17, 2012
Hell. Yes. What a pleasant surprise. This place is the real deal. Everything is great, but if you can't decide, get the fried quail. You'll love it. Oh man.
winJanuary 6, 2015
Came here for desserts and prosecco, a chocolate mousse pot (my friend loved it more than me) and an apple turnover cake with Mexican ice cream (I loved it) great ambience, and will be back for dinner
Jemima DouyonApril 21, 2017
This is probably the best meal I've ever had. The watermelon tuna was absolutely amazing, the steak tartar was also great! I'm still drooling over the palenta!!! Great place! Highly recommended!
Damian BayonaApril 25, 2016
Great burger. High quality meat and cheese, cooked perfectly (medium rare) and served with a delicious spicy mayo. Wash it down with a cold Bikini Blonde Lager to complete the experience.
Stephen PetreyApril 9, 2018
The Atlantic Benedict is to die for! Items are a little pricey but sooooooo delicious 🤤
Angela WenAugust 19, 2018
Beautiful and cozy space with a cute small backyard. Food is delicious. Clam linguine was fantastic as was the BLT. Great cocktails and drinks. Lots of seating.
AlexMarch 13, 2014
Been here 10+ times
I know every joint does a kale salad these days, but Mayfield's is done really well. also, both the pork chop on ribs and the octopus on pork belly are truly amazing and melt in your mouth.
Kappie FarringtonAugust 30, 2015
Went here for brunch and the food was excellent (omg the home fries), but the vibe was unexpectedly bro-y. The outdoor garden is lovely but small. There was a TV at the bar with soccer on.
KateNovember 5, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Where to begin?Kale salad, roasted brussels sprouts, blackfish ceviche, fish and chips. Succinct menu, sensible wine list, & amazing touch with sauces/dressings. So happy to have mayfield in the hood!
Marcela ErazoFebruary 21, 2016
Great brunch, get the spoon bread. The kale salad is perfect, and the cauliflower custard thing is out of this world
Nick RovisaAugust 22, 2015
Been here 5+ times
$1 oyster happy hour 5-6:30 every day. Pair them with $3 Labatt Blues.
LeslieDecember 31, 2012
Been here 5+ times
in love with this new addition to the neighborhood. warm atmosphere, wonderful staff, delicious food and drink. the pastas, butternut squash salad, and ny old fashioned are standouts.
Rebecca KamelNovember 4, 2012
Been here 5+ times
They did a really great job with this place, awesome addition to the neighborhood! Everything we tried was great and the decor/atmosphere was really nice too. Would highly recommend the pork chop!
Thomas ReintjesSeptember 1, 2019
Trout is good and surprisingly comes without bones. Wish it came with a side veg in addition to the potatoes.
Mike NickersonNovember 15, 2016
Fantastic menu items on the new American-Italian spectrum. Elegantly prepared and just delicious. I loved the cacio e pepe and the brussels
Sandro LipariJanuary 24, 2016
If you're walking distance, driving distance or even plane distance, that's where you wanna be for brunch. Absolutely the best French toast ever and super tasty bloody mary's.
Erin AlderetteJanuary 26, 2013
One of my new Heights favorites. Kale salad is light, refreshing, delicious. Octopus w/pork belly also amazing. But brussels sprouts were soggy and the mustard was overpowering.
Argelys OriachJune 10, 2016
Been here 5+ times
The burgers are ridiculous. So good! And the fries are too die for. Oh and be sure to check this place out during happy hour for $4 drafts!
Dan DoronJuly 2, 2013
Kale salad is flavorful and a texture delight. Excellent press coffee. Sea scallops rock, best fish and chips I've had, pappardelle and trout are solid choices.
Raphael LangenscheidtOctober 3, 2015
Good brunch. The French toast is insane, but the poached eggs weren't quite as delicious as a 9.3 rating promises. Still - I'd come back. Come before noon on weekends to avoid the worst of the rush.
Scy DVNovember 11, 2020
Been here 10+ times
Great place for $1 oysters! Highly recommend the sandwiches - po’boy, fried chicken, and burger. Also the brussel sprouts and fries!
The CommanderJune 22, 2015
The fried egg on the dandelion salad is absolute perfection! Plus $1 oysters and draft beers for happy hour...the best!
David ZhangSeptember 3, 2022
Been here 5+ times
Get the oyster po boy with Tasso ham and fries
Bryan YeagerApril 30, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Been here about 10 times now and continues to exceed expectations. Food, drinks, service, and decor are all top-notch. Get here by 6 or you're gonna wait!
J StandeferFebruary 29, 2016
Burger is super legit, as is generous-portioned, not-too- sweet, brownie sundae
ChaimOctober 9, 2013
Been here 5+ times
As good as (or better than) a meal you'd pay twice as much for in Manhattan, and without the fuss and attitude that often goes along with such meals. Do not skip the steak tartare.
MbaliOctober 25, 2014
Brunch is scrumptious! Their grits are very well seasoned (hold the scary bug-eyed shrimp next time) and the french toast is delish
Gabriel HayesAugust 8, 2014
Spoon bread is delicious. Loved the ricotta gnocchi, buttermilk fried quail, hand rolled tagliatelle and the lamb chili.
Alison Brock McGillJanuary 25, 2014
Been here 5+ times
I had the shrimp & grits with scrambled eggs, collard greens and mint tea for Saturday brunch. Absolutely delicious. I will be back!
Natalie Cotto CastroAugust 31, 2014
Shrimp ceviche, scallops and amazing pork chops. Affordable wine list, friendly staff and nice atmosphere. Probably best in crown.
Paul FilippettiOctober 20, 2019
Great find! The beef tartare was the best I have ever had. Kale salad a good choice as well.
Sam GilAugust 6, 2017
Awesome chill vibe out the back. Fried quail and cavatelli both very good but need to come back.
Joe DMay 12, 2016
Been here 5+ times
The fried clam bellies and spoon bread are out of the world 🛰
LaurenMay 26, 2014
I dream about the chicken liver mousse. And while I would typically never order a sandwich for dinner, the Cubano is a must eat!
Serious EatsApril 3, 2013
A friendly, American-inspired spot that's the best all-around restaurant and bar in Crown Heights.
Leigh Anne ZinsmeisterAugust 9, 2014
The corned beef hash is delicious and reasonably priced for a weekend brunch!
💋Shoshi💋November 13, 2016
Been here 10+ times
If you're looking for great ambience and delicious American food go to Mayfield.
Zoe CareyDecember 31, 2019
Been here 10+ times
It says on here it doesn’t take reservations but it does. Parties under 6 people you can book via Resy, over 6 you have to email with credit card info.
EllieMarch 14, 2014
Excellent! Food was great, nice atmosphere, good service! Had the Whole Roasted Eden Brook Trout and it was amazing!
Navneet AlangAugust 12, 2016
Steak tartare is amazing. Ideal, small patio in the back.
Patrick KochJune 23, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Great burgers. But really all the things are great. Just go. They have outdoor seating too.
Jarel HillFebruary 27, 2022
Burger is so solid, fried chicken sandwich is also no joke.
Makina CelestineFebruary 15, 2016
Kale salad + broiled lobster + gnocchi + draft beer for happy hour = definitely worth checking out!
WEI WEIMay 23, 2016
Really like the smoke ribs, cornbread and buttermilk here
Kelsey✨November 21, 2018
Basic brunch fare in a cozy space. It gets packed so arrive early if you want to snag a table
Tanya RojasDecember 25, 2014
Fish and chips are by far the best I've had in NYC. Kale salad was also excellent.
Freda MoonOctober 9, 2013
Really fresh $1 oysters at happy hour, and not the usual Blue Points for once. House wine ($6 at HH) was tasty too.
The New YorkerJanuary 30, 2013
"The food, creative yet controlled, is unusually delicious. Seafood fares particularly well..." -Hannah Goldfield, in the 2/4/2013 issue. Read more

1 2 3 4

261 Photos

Mayfield

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Mayfield

Appears on 858 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.