Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
New York Pizza Suprema

New York Pizza Suprema

Pizzeria$$$$
Chelsea, New York
Save
Share
9.0/10
1,318
ratings
  • Stars
  • Stars
    The experts at Serious Eats and Gothamist recommend this place
    • Serious Eats
    • Gothamist
  • Tips
    Gabriel H.
    "Best place for pizza by the slice near Penn Station."(20 Tips)
    Natalia S.
    "Cosy place with amazing pizza, loved Upside down and Hawaiian."(13 Tips)
    esther
    "The upside down slice was good and cheap... good service also"(10 Tips)
    Maria A.
    "Def on of the best NY style pizzas in town."(7 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon306 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • penn station
  • upside
  • casual
  • good for a quick meal
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Jack O.heart icon on user image
    Jack OsborneSeptember 15, 2015
    There's a reason Slice Harvester rates this as his best reg slice in Manhattan. The crisp base folds perfectly, the cheese is packed full of flavour & the sauce is sweet. I went back for seconds.
  • David Z.heart icon on user image
    David ZhangJanuary 7, 2017
    Some of the best pizza in the city, legitimately. Try the upside down (sorta like a mix between grandma and Chicago style), the white, or the suprema special.
    Upvoted 4 weeks ago
  • Gothamist
    GothamistSeptember 18, 2015
    A plain slice here runs $3, and is exactly what a slice of pizza should be—cheesy, crusty, and doused with a not-too-sweet, not-too-oniony tomato sauce. Read more
    Upvoted Oct 30
  • Yelimar R.heart icon on user image
    Yelimar RodriguezOctober 3, 2015
    Best pizza in town!!! Their sauce is on pointe. Love their basil mozzarella, white slice, mushroom slice and the vegan slice (no cheese but HUGE on flavor).
  • Carl F.heart icon on user image
    Carl FigueiredoMarch 20, 2016
    As authentic as it gets. Stand in line, wait until you're spoken to, and be ready to shout out your order. All the classics, perfectly executed in a NY kind of way.
  • MAQheart icon on user image
    MAQMarch 21, 2017
    Without a doubt, one of the best Pizza place in New York ( I've tried their Margarita, Chicken Buffalo & Fresh Mushroom and all were amazing 👌🏻)
  • Al S.heart icon on user image
    Al SJune 8, 2018
    Been here 10+ times
    Some of if not the best pizza I’ve had in New York. They offer different types (thin crust, Sicilian, upside down) so you can get a few different slices and try them all. I really like the white pie.
  • Maria A.heart icon on user image
    Maria Arshad-OsmanApril 4, 2015
    Wow wht a pizza!! The crust, the toppings, everything was delicious. Def on of the best NY style pizzas in town.
  • Zsuzsanna M.heart icon on user image
    Zsuzsanna MiklósiApril 3, 2017
    Amazing pizza, just the right amount of crunchiness and cheese, great sauce, nice service and plenty of place to sit down. Don't be fooled by the dodgy looking facade!
  • David G.
    David GreenbergerFebruary 21, 2015
    Listen to 4sq! Didn't trust the rating, went with it. Didn't trust the upside down slice, got it, bc 4sq said. One of the best slices I've had in the city.
  • Mike F.heart icon on user image
    Mike FriedlichOctober 17, 2016
    The pizza here is the best yet that I have had in NYC. I had the plain slice, and the sauce on it is so good I dont know how they do it. They are so good I could eat a whole pie.
  • Elia C.heart icon on user image
    Elia ClementeOctober 26, 2015
    The specialty slices are overflowing with choices. A simple 'regular' slice is a winner every time. Whatever your pizza craving is, these guys will have it. And it will be amazing.
  • Kasey M.heart icon on user image
    Kasey MaMarch 10, 2016
    Um. The upside-down slice is the bomb. I've never had a Sicilian like that before. Sauce was sweet AND savory. Unheard of. I just died and went to heaven. I would starve all day to eat 4 slices here.
  • Zach Aarons
    Zach AaronsApril 18, 2012
    Upside down slice is really solid. The supreme slice looks very good as well. Definitely a great option after a Knicks or Rangers game. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
  • PR M.heart icon on user image
    PR MRMay 21, 2016
    This pizza lives up to the expectations. If you're looking for something different, try the white (garlic) pizza, or ask for the upside down. The latter shows what a good pizza sauce tastes like.
  • Mehan J.heart icon on user image
    Mehan JayasuriyaFebruary 28, 2015
    The platonic ideal of the New York plain slice. A well-balanced, perfectly cooked, deeply satisfying slice every time. I really doubt there's a better way to spend $3 in Manhattan.
  • Kate F.
    Kate FurmanApril 24, 2017
    Best option for food around Penn Station. They sell pizza by the slice and it's absolutely delicious, fast, and cheap.
  • John P.heart icon on user image
    John ParkesNovember 12, 2017
    Salivating just remembering how good this was. As everyone else says, upside down is incredible (that velvety tomato sauce: yum). But also recommend the buffalo chicken. Just the right amount of heat.
  • Dáša J.heart icon on user image
    Dáša JaníkováMarch 4, 2020
    Oh my good this place is like heaven for me. There are a great selection of great pizzas and everyone can choose their favourite. This place is good also for vegetarians and vegans.
  • A S.heart icon on user image
    A SJuly 4, 2015
    Every time I take the bus back to Boston, I stop here and grab a slice of pizza for the ride. The veggie medley was excellent and so was the mozzarella basil.
  • N K.heart icon on user image
    N KAugust 17, 2014
    Tons of varieties of fresh pizzas. Personal favorite was fresh mushroom pizza and the creamy white pizza with garlic. My daughter loved the marinara pizza and wants to try the upside down pizza next
  • Levant P.heart icon on user image
    Levant PandaFebruary 25, 2016
    I only had one slice late evening, but great for single slice. It's the sauce that really sets it apart from other places. Just get a couple cheese slices and you'll know how good this place is.
  • Esther C.
    Esther ChoiMay 27, 2014
    Amazing plain slice! Great cheese-free Vegan option: Vegetable medley
  • Dan S.heart icon on user image
    Dan SohaydaApril 5, 2016
    Quality pizza in a location with a good amount of booths to sit in, but one of the smallest bathrooms in NYC!
  • Jen W.
    Jen WOctober 7, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    best slice of pizza in NY! get a plain slice and let it cool down. perfect temperature to eat it at is room temp.
  • Robert A.heart icon on user image
    Robert AccetturaAugust 1, 2016
    Very good pizza, you can't really go wrong here. Sicilian is pretty hardy and surprisingly not terrible as most places that attempt it are, though slightly on the oily side.
  • Nate S.heart icon on user image
    Nate SOctober 12, 2023
    I overheard someone next to me say “I’ve had way better.” I agree. Claims to be Top 10 slices in NY. Worth a stop if you’re near Penn/MSG, for sure, but better places in the city. Try the Upside Down.
  • Vansiheart icon on user image
    VansiMay 21, 2019
    Missed your train and need a seat with AC? The pizza is great too!
  • Lenny G.heart icon on user image
    Lenny GalloAugust 25, 2022
    Been here 10+ times
    This is still the best pizza in NYC. From the sauce to the crust, everything comes out to perfection. I highly recommend their Fra Diavlo.
  • Leonardo V.heart icon on user image
    Leonardo VillaMay 31, 2016
    Amazing. The place is welcoming and warm. The pizza is nearly-perfect. Yet, very casual. Try the siciliana with sausage. The price is super fair.
  • Appropriately C.heart icon on user image
    Appropriately CriticalDecember 12, 2017
    Perfect inexpensive, served hot n fast By the slice favorite margarita Tomato was sweet mozzarella flavorful long cheesy pull basil fresh crust perfectly thin had appropriate sweetness of the dough
  • Ian S.
    Ian SpalterJanuary 11, 2013
    plain slice gives a great fold/crease and the cheese actually has flavor -sauce is on the sweet side but its a great basic NYC slice
  • Desmond
    DesmondJune 18, 2012
    Try the Mushroom Slice - If you like mushrooms on your pizza this is the place to go! Fresh mushrooms, not the white ones you get from a can. Tastier difference!
  • Marc P.heart icon on user image
    Marc PelinaNovember 16, 2011
    Been here 100+ times
    One of the best pizza places in the neighborhood! Their plain slice is awesome and all you really need! I come here for lunch all the time!
  • Robert G.heart icon on user image
    Robert GillingsJuly 20, 2017
    I tried this place the other day and I can honestly say it was amazing. Great food, great atmosphere, and excellent service. Will definitely be returning next time i'm in the area.
  • Ian C.heart icon on user image
    Ian CheeNovember 25, 2019
    Likely the best pizza place near Penn Station. Start with the classic or upside down slice; go boujie with the Burrata slice.
  • Herve L.
    Herve LarrenMarch 9, 2017
    What a spectacular place with a spectacular staff. They are a wealth of knowledge of the extensive drink menu and masters at preparing a cocktail.
  • Kodi M.
    Kodi McKinneyJune 7, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    This is the type of place I hope tourists never have on their maps. Plain slice is better than Joe's. Easily in the top 3 cheese slices I've ever found.
  • Lilly-Marie L.heart icon on user image
    Lilly-Marie LiegauFebruary 18, 2020
    I love this very NYC Style Pizza Place and their Pizzas are the best. I’d say even better than the famous Joe’s Pizza :)
  • Sol
    SolJanuary 2, 2019
    Plain slice is in the conversation for best slices in NY, the sauce is very sweet, but boy is it delicious. An Anthony Bourdain favorite.
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsMarch 21, 2013
    The best pizza near Penn Station. Order an 'upside down' slice.
  • Mike C.
    Mike ChristensenOctober 21, 2011
    Been here 5+ times
    Here's the tip: eat here. I've been coming to the city for years on business and the Fresh Mozz & Basil (Margherita) is the best there is. Train, cab, walk, skip, whatever. You can't go wrong!
  • Kimmie O.heart icon on user image
    Kimmie OhhNovember 24, 2019
    They have the best pizza around Penn Station! Get the classic plain cheese slice or an upside down slice.
  • Steven B.
    Steven BreaAugust 10, 2017
    One of the greatest New York style pizzas I've tried!! Will come back!!
  • Chris S.heart icon on user image
    Chris SsentongoJune 16, 2018
    Highly recommended for a more than decent slice when on this side of town.
  • Dan H.heart icon on user image
    Dan HoodAugust 8, 2013
    Great regular slice, upside down is also highly recommended. It's not only good for the area (midtown pizza is generally pretty mediocre), it's good for the city.
  • Dennise M.heart icon on user image
    Dennise MarieJune 1, 2016
    Loved The Suprema Special Pizza. Really great Sauce And big slices.
  • Cole K.heart icon on user image
    Cole KennedyAugust 24, 2015
    Sure, the slices are good (I liked the Margherita; the Sicilian had too much bread) but it feels criminal to pay $4 for a pizza slice.
  • Paolo B.heart icon on user image
    Paolo BaroneApril 26, 2019
    A very good pizza indeed, just steps from Penn Station and a better option than most of the food joints in the station itself
  • P. D.heart icon on user image
    P. D.March 4, 2019
    Been here 5+ times
    A pleasant surprise behind Penn Station. I was skeptical it could be as good as some have said. But it really is a classic NY slice of the old school variety. Sauce a bit sweet but not unappealing.
Photos729 Photos

Related Searches

  • new york pizza suprema new york •
  • new york pizza suprema new york photos •
  • new york pizza suprema new york location •
  • new york pizza suprema new york address •
  • new york pizza suprema new york •
  • new york pizza suprema new york •
  • ny pizza suprema new york •
  • ny pizza supreme new york •
  • pizza suprema new york •
  • pizza supreme new york •
  • suprema pizza new york •
  • new york pizza suprema chelsea new york

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA