See all
110 photos

Noodle Pudding

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

Save

Noodle Pudding

8.4^/10

333

ratings

Ranked #6 for gnocchi in Brooklyn
"Amazing gnocchi and squash blossoms when in bloom"(6 Tips)
"The gnocchi is heaven, as is the lasagna."(19 Tips)
"Try the Risotto With Rock Shrimp And Corn"(2 Tips)
"When they are running the risotto with rock shrimp and corn, GET IT."(2 Tips)

89 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
risotto
daily specials
pork belly
good for groups
casual
Chicken Milanese
braised short ribs
liver
polenta
great value
eggplant parmigiana
salads
meats
dinner
asparagus
cash only
crowded
good for special occasions
mushrooms
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

KESeptember 7, 2016
Warm, romantic lighting and a homey, vintage Italian vibe. Clearly a loved spot by locals. Good for dates - I saw a few families during dinner too. The spaghetti bolognese was just right.
Abbie StevensonMarch 30, 2018
Get the pasta limon if it’s in season. It’s friggin fantastic!!! Otherwise get the cacio e pepe with asparagus and ask for them to add pork belly on top. Holy smokes. It’ll change your life
Katie ReavesNovember 28, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Get here as early as you can - they have great specials but often run out early in the night. Don't fret though if this happens to you - everything on the regular menu is also very good.
Upvoted 14 hours ago
Sheetal JiwaniMay 21, 2022
Nice ambiance! The spicy garlic bread was INCREDIBLE. If you like spicy foods, it’s a must get. I got the cacio e Pepe and lasagna, both were okay.
Chophel NamgyalAugust 6, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Everything is simply amazing! Cash only! Orechiatte pasta w the garlicky cauliflower for the win with a side of Maine Black Bass clams, mussels and shrimps!
Phil TorontoMay 31, 2015
This is one fine plate of fried calamari - light & airy
Asli SJune 21, 2017
Good for dates. Try the pappardelle with mushroom + duck ragu- so delicious. Came around 8 on a Tuesday night and only waited ~5-10 min to be seated.
Korye LoganDecember 31, 2010
Been here 10+ times
My home away from home in Brooklyn Heights. I enjoy sitting at the bar and being served by Marcello or Aldo. The clams and oysters are so fresh! All the food and service is splendid. Cash is king here
WhiskeySeptember 7, 2012
Been here 50+ times
Solid neighborhood standard bearer. Soulful and straightforward Italian fare. Wait times can be a bear on the weekend, so better off going midweek (fyi-closed Mondays) or planning for an early dinner.
BasakApril 1, 2015
Been here 5+ times
My go to place for great Italian in BKHeights. Solid seafood and pasta options. Heads up - Closed on Mondays and cash only.
Claudia FilthAugust 21, 2016
Amazing old school Italian. Food is great but the servings are HUGE so be warned!
Donelle BApril 3, 2013
The service was excellent - the calamari for starters was superb - from what I saw in the dining room u could not go wrong with anything on the menu!
Argelys OriachMarch 14, 2017
Unassuming Italian restaurant with an impressive (and affordable) wine list.
Elizabeth LutzJanuary 7, 2012
Calamari was Amazing, Should have ordered the fett w/seafood, tiramisu was like tufts of creamy sweetness, service was endearing - totally recommend visiting if you're in the 'hood.
AlexisDecember 7, 2014
Been here 5+ times
The gnocchi is heaven, as is the lasagna. Super cozy, cash only, strong bread pudding game.
Peter ShumJanuary 15, 2016
The lasagna is phenomenal, the portions are really generous and the olive oil and bread is great.
monydfnyApril 23, 2017
Delicious fresh seafood, loved my seafood pasta and service is super friendly.
Debra SchultzOctober 29, 2023
Chicken Milanese with salad and Giardina, eggplant parm and swordfish all were great.
Perry SchafferNovember 23, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Our local fave. It's all good. But no reservations or credit cards. But local checks ok.
Robby AbayaJune 4, 2016
Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna. Lasagna.
CompassApril 21, 2014
Handmade pastas and inexpensive house wine pours keep this cash-only comfort food packed on a wait come most weekends.
Public Art FundJanuary 4, 2013
#StaffPick close to our exhibition at Brooklyn Bridge Park. AMAZING italian food! A neighborhood-feeling place.
Julia MontiMarch 29, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Get the eggplant. You won't regret it!
raf pSeptember 30, 2016
the food was great, but talk about awful service! legit had to flag down several waiters to order and get each part of our meal. such a letdown.
Mark CrozerMarch 28, 2021
Mushroom risotto excellent. Service excellent. Nice atmosphere.
eric bornemannOctober 19, 2017
Amazing gnocchi and squash blossoms when in bloom
Natalia QuinteroJune 15, 2012
Once you get over the weird name, you'll find that this spot has fantastic Italian food! (but really, whats up with the name?)
Trisha VanderbeckAugust 8, 2014
AMAZING food. The gnocchi was wonderful. The bread and oil were awesome.
Tiffany SFebruary 24, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Tagliatelle bolognese. You can even get it gluten free.
Kenji TakabayashiOctober 21, 2011
When they are running the risotto with rock shrimp and corn, GET IT. Also, the braised short ribs and polenta is amazing.
Stephanie KimberlyNovember 28, 2011
The food is absolutely delicious! The only issue I had was our waitress. Everyone else was super nice and accommodating.
WEI WEIAugust 23, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Go for their seasonal specials. Had several wonderful surprises
Josh CohenJuly 19, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Classic, old school, Italian restaurant. Cash only.
CarlosApril 30, 2018
Everything is good! Strongly recommended.
Andres MenaSeptember 4, 2011
I come always, I always tip generously, always a battle to get a table. Today, they didn't even try. I am taking it personally today.
Dean BealsMarch 23, 2015
Great place. Been going for years. All is good!
Kerry EusticeMarch 18, 2018
Great appetizers. Pasta cooked perfectly - but ragu and sauces were bland.
bradleyMay 20, 2010
Been here 50+ times
The bar is the best places to hang and get food. Amazing staff and such great food made any way you want. If I lived here, I'd be here a lot. A bit loud. But ok.
Margarita KrupOctober 29, 2015
Lasagna, pasta dish with seafood and octopus!
Alyssa BereznakJanuary 25, 2016
get the fresh gnocchi. it's super pillowy and fresh.
hugo liuJanuary 4, 2015
Best pappardelle bolognese I've had in NYC
DPOctober 23, 2013
If you're not wrapping up with the tiramisu, you're doing it wrong. Cash only!
Rahul GandhiAugust 4, 2010
order the lasagna if you want a quick meal. you'll be in and out in less than 30 minutes. also, the house wine is $14 a bottle and it's good.
Nicola Carbone Jr.August 26, 2013
Love the freshly made fettucine; however, everything else was fair to average. No need to go out of your way to eat there. Also, they are a cash only business.
BrianAugust 31, 2010
Date #5, Tyla: Charming and well-priced; great date material. Make sure you have cash on you, though—nothing says "lame date" more than taking half an hour to run to the closest ATM 5 blocks away. Read more
David JosephsonAugust 18, 2014
Salmon dinner excellent! Caesar salad very good.
Red FabbriAugust 9, 2014
Suburban Italian-American fare in the heights. cash only!
Mark LeeMay 22, 2011
Look down your nose at the Comic Sans font choice on the menu. Then order something tasty from said menu. Great good.
Madam AnnlaSeptember 23, 2016
The restaurant is lovely and nice but staffs and services are not good as it should be. Slow and not very welcome.
Kaja KrólikowskaOctober 13, 2017
Overpriced, not high quality food. No receipts provided - only piece of paper like on attached photo. While paying and leaving the tip - the waiter did complain that the tip is not enough. Dissaponted

1 2

110 Photos

Noodle Pudding

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Noodle Pudding

Appears on 386 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.