Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Pizza Party
Pitch Coal-Fire Pizzeria is one of Pizza Party.

1. Pitch Coal-Fire Pizzeria

8.9
5021 Underwood Ave, Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Central Omaha · 67 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: Hands down, Pitch offers some of the best gourmet pizza in the city. Try the Brussels sprouts appetizer.

Mama's Pizza is one of Pizza Party.

2. Mama's Pizza

7.1
715 N Saddle Creek Rd (Saddle Creek & Cuming), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Midtown · 18 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: It'll put you in a food coma, but the Mama's Special is indeed special. (Warning: square slices. Yes, we're in the Midwest.)

Frank's Pizzeria is one of Pizza Party.

3. Frank's Pizzeria

711 N 132nd St (at California St), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · West Omaha · 20 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: Pretty darn authentic NYC-style pizza. Simple, fresh and good.

Sgt Peffer's Italian Cafe is one of Pizza Party.

4. Sgt Peffer's Italian Cafe

7.8
1501 N Saddle Creek Rd, Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · 22 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: Try the five-chease pie with added blackened chicken and roasted peppers. Whoa, it's good and heavy.

La Casa Pizzaria is one of Pizza Party.

5. La Casa Pizzaria

8.1
4432 Leavenworth St, Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Nebraska Medical Center · 32 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: It's got that classic family-owned feel. Pizza is Sicilian style and pretty unique for these here parts.

Night Flight Pizza is one of Pizza Party.

6. Night Flight Pizza

6.1
4636 Dodge St (48th St & Dodge St), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Central Omaha · 11 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: This place may get a bad rap, but its specialty pies can be quite tasty. All bets are off after midnight though.

Zio's Pizzeria is one of Pizza Party.

7. Zio's Pizzeria

7.5
7834 Dodge St (btw 78th & 80th), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Central Omaha · 43 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: Basically an Omaha staple. Homy and affordable, complete with greasy laminated menus.

Pizza Shoppe Collective is one of Pizza Party.

8. Pizza Shoppe Collective

6056 Maple St (btw 60th & 61st), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Maple Street Corridor · 25 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: A Benson favorite. Thin crust and fresh ingredients. Nothing too crazy, but just right.

Baxter's is one of Pizza Party.

9. Baxter's

6113 Maple St, Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · Maple Street Corridor · 19 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: New to Benson, Baxter's is a small, by-the-slice joint boasting fresh-fresh-fresh ingredients. Seems like a perfect fit for the neighborhood.

Goodnights Pizza Bar + Patio is one of Pizza Party.

10. Goodnights Pizza Bar + Patio

1302 Mike Fahey St (btw 12th & 13th St), Omaha, NE
Pizzeria · North Downtown · 43 tips and reviews

OmahypeOmahype: We've never had a bad experience here. All around solid food. Plenty of specialty slices and reasonable prices. The place feels like a lonely cave when it's empty though.