See all
68 photos

Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe

Seafood Restaurant and American Restaurant$$$$

Lawrenceville

Save

8.7^/10

ratings

"Conch fritters"(4 Tips)
"best fried oysters in the Southeast and don't forget the garlic"(13 Tips)
"island crab cakes"(4 Tips)
"Shrimp and lobster bisque, off the chain!"(2 Tips)

33 Tips and reviews

Filter:

conch fritters
casual
great value
key lime pie
good for dates
bacon
grouper
bar
garlic
dinner
parking
island
red potatoes
lunch
alcohol
good for special occasions
(11 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

AJCAugust 1, 2014
Does an excellent job of filling bellies with platters of crab legs, grouper, shrimp and other beachy fare in a casual setting that balances the bar crowd with an otherwise family atmosphere. Read more
Kaitlyn RoneyFebruary 6, 2017
This place is amazing if you're looking for seafood! I'd recommend the monster basket, island crab cakes and key lime pie for desert! Also, great beer prices.
Claudia LazoNovember 12, 2020
Raw oysters, baked oysters, fried calamari, u peel shrimp are our favorites! Ariel is the best and will remember your face and preferences every time! I recommend this place 🥰
Stephanie WigginsOctober 5, 2013
The oysters and crab legs were wonderful. The raw oysters were huge and it was like getting 24 oysters instead of 12. I would highly recommend eating here!
Nikki GroteMay 4, 2014
Amazing Bar service & food was top-notch. Accidentally ended up here, will definitely come back again or recommend it.
Greg SchulzOctober 13, 2014
Oysters are good and very reasonable. Also had the gumbo and a shrimp salad. No complaints.
Edward deGruyMay 27, 2020
All the apps are great. The staff is very friendly and helpful.
Sherri ThomasonDecember 6, 2015
The Cajun Bimini tilapia w/ the mango sauce is mad good fam!
Melanie WaltonMay 26, 2013
Great fish tacos.., peel and eat shrimp:)
April McKayJuly 31, 2013
Tuesday is Oyster Day! 60 cent oysters all day, any way you want them!
Chester HaleAugust 11, 2012
The best fried oysters in the Southeast and don't forget the garlic red potatos...
Damon ToureSeptember 7, 2013
Great food and service love the Wednesday 25 cent Shrimp nite
Vicki ChristianJuly 2, 2013
Tues night $0.50 oysters are the way to go!
Eldridge ScottSeptember 14, 2014
The ribs were good and falling off the bones
Tina HildebrandAugust 10, 2012
Service is awesome! Buffalo grouper bites are amazing!!!
Larry BurtonSeptember 9, 2016
Been here 5+ times
We love the lobster ravioli.
Trip AndrewsJune 7, 2014
Add a crab cake sometime. Deelish!!
Mary HoneaSeptember 11, 2011
This place is great! As a good or better than seafood on the coast!
Patrick LabrieDecember 30, 2014
All that fried food is delicious but heavy!
Jeff AllenAugust 24, 2018
Great fish and chips
Jennifer PopovichOctober 7, 2012
oysters baked with Parmesan garlic and bacon!
Trip AndrewsJune 7, 2014
Great smoked fish dip
Hannah DayNovember 22, 2011
Shrimp and lobster bisque, off the chain!
Joni Fontaine-McColleyFebruary 23, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Keith is the best server.
Chris ShepherdMay 12, 2012
Try the stuffed grouper
KraziOver HeelzBoutiqueJuly 2, 2013
I Love Oysters!
Linda JoJune 30, 2015
Conch fritters
Prinston RoseMarch 6, 2016
Conch fritters
Alec MillerJuly 11, 2011
Try the conch fritters!
Michael BuckelewFebruary 28, 2012
Been here 5+ times
60 cent oysters on Tuesdays
Jesse LyonApril 13, 2012
Two words... Ship Po'boy
Larry BurtonMay 24, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Get the Conch Fritters.
Rowena Oliva-BrownFebruary 3, 2012
Great food

68 Photos

Planning a trip to Atlanta?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe

Appears on 20 lists