See all
418 photos

Patsy's Pizzeria

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

East Harlem, New York

Save

Patsy's Pizzeria

8.8^/10

532

ratings

Ranked #4 for NY style pizza in New York
Has a stamp of approval from Time Out New York and Eater
"Its thin and light, so a whole pie isnt as filling as you may think."(8 Tips)
"Patsy’s offers some of the best in the country."(4 Tips)
"Even Ol' Blue Eyes knew where to find the best NY pizza."(5 Tips)
"Gotta admit, one of the best thin crust I have ever had."(6 Tips)

139 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
whole pies
patsy s
casual
lively
good for groups
good for a quick meal
good for dates
great value
scenic views
sub sandwiches
cheese
vodka
city
sausage
fresh food
dinner
good for special occasions
lunch
tomato sauce
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

EaterOctober 11, 2016
Patsy’s serves the quintessential example of the New York Neapolitan style of pizza — cooked in a grandfathered coal oven. Few, if any, places provide a more lucid touchstone to old New York. Read more
Upvoted 2 days ago
Emily WilsonJuly 11, 2016
The restaurant is dark and sleepy, with that classic NY pizza joint vibe. Margherita is the way to go, but if your group or your appetite is big, get a vodka pie too.
EaterMarch 17, 2014
Opened in 1933, the original location of Patsy's is the only old school coal oven pizzeria in New York that offers pizza by the slice. The crust will make you feel as if you are in Naples. Read more
Cole KennedyApril 14
The perfect ideal of New York style pizza. Crispy, light, foldable, molten hot and massively flavorful. I could eat it every damn day.
Upvoted Sep 17
Mike Mahdavi NYC-LA-TEH-KISH * insta—> NYCPERSIANSFebruary 5, 2017
You already know best pitZa in HARLEM NYC. One of my fave pitZa spots, take out side are like the pizza nazi though. Dine In everything is good. YOU MUST TRY IT ONE TIME.
PureWowDecember 18, 2015
This is the joint created by Patsy Lancieri, Grimaldi’s uncle. Patsy’s changed owners in 1991, but the thin-crust, coal oven pie at its original East Harlem location is one of the best in the city. Read more
Serious EatsSeptember 6, 2013
Their coal-fired slices are the missing link of pizza. The clear middle ground between the old world Neapolitan pies and the modern New York slice.
Men's Health MagAugust 3, 2014
While plenty of places offer cheap slices, Patsy’s offers some of the best in the country. Plus, because it’s just a hole-in-the-wall stop you can grab a slice on the quick. Read more
Nicholas DoyleSeptember 11, 2014
The perfect slice is here: With slight layer of cheese, a touch of delicious sauce and a thin charred crust perfect for folding, you'll suddenly realize what NYC pizza is all about.
Time Out New YorkJuly 18, 2018
The Margherita slices at this 1933 East Harlem original are thiner and shorter than you’ll typically find, which means the average person—okay, fine, we—can easily wolf down five to six slices each. Read more
Malin Ali BeyApril 13, 2018
whole pie portabella mushroom pizza to of the line. A lout of places lose their luster over time not Patsy's, I've been coming here for decades and it is still amazing!
Nadia IssaBellaFebruary 28, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Everything is delicious here!! The MOZARELLA sticks, fresh pasta (the fettuccine is to die for) and the tiramisu are some of my favourites. Get spoiled here, like Sinatra did!
Buford BarnesMay 28, 2012
Established 1933, continuously operated. One of the originators of New York style pizza and one of the few coal oven pizzerias in the city. Inspiration for a key scene of The Godfather.
Stephanie ManwaringMarch 28, 2017
The best cheese pizza in NYC IMO. Grab a slice from the window (not the sit down) and join everybody else on the curb talking about how good it is. Best and freshest tomato sauce!
Almando PerezJanuary 28, 2016
Pizza is very good. I was impressed, I didn't think it would be amazing and it was. Also, the chicken parm is very good.
James Mark IIApril 8, 2017
Best Pizza in NYC. Every trip I take there, I get a whole pie to share with my gf. Its thin and light, so a whole pie isnt as filling as you may think.
CompassApril 25, 2014
Time-tested recipes, addictive red sauce, and coal brick-baked pies have been the dishes du jour since the 1930s, when the legendary local pizza chain got its start at this very spot.
Betty HuynhMarch 19
The pizza was so delicious and with so many flavor could choose that we even visited the pizza shop twice in the same day!
Upvoted Sep 17
Jose MendezApril 14, 2016
All I can say about this place.. This is the real deal.. Not can ever take this place out of business . the real oven brick pizza .. 100% real pizza.. The best in the whole five boroughs.
Elie BleierJune 9, 2014
Splendid. Enjoyed every bite. Best uptown pizza. Cheap!
Will HarahanMarch 30, 2021
The slice was so good I had to get a whole pie to go.
Frenzy HunterMarch 15, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Patsy's HARLEM is the best pizza on the island. Seasoned w/ filed unicorn horn dust & baked in a stone oven heated by dragon spit. Then they feed the unicorn-turned-horse the slices. And they love it!
Adam KubanAugust 16, 2011
Only one of two coal-oven places in NYC that sells by the slice (the other is Sac's in Astoria) -- over in the small take-out shop near the corner. I prefer the whole plain pie with regular mozzarella
P. D.October 16, 2020
Been here 10+ times
I think it's the best pizza in the whole city (and most classically "New York"). Maybe a tie w Louie and Ernie's.
Harlem AmbassadorMarch 21, 2013
The pizza is old world style. Then again, so are the portions in this supersized era, you'll craving more.The coal oven gives a smokey flavor to fresh slices. The nearby restaurant is an alternative.
Men's Health MagAugust 3, 2014
Piping-hot, paper-thin slices of crispy, coal-charred cheese pizza served at a no-frills Harlem storefront for only $1.75 each. Read more
Elizabeth BursteinNovember 22, 2020
Lovely thin melt in your mouth pizza. Got cheese and pepp.
Jon hoffmanApril 15, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Excellent pizza. Great for sitting down and sharing a whole pie or ordering a single slice from their to-go window.
Jennifer JonesFebruary 16, 2011
I like to call myself a Pizza snob. With that said I must say, Patsy’s is by far one of the best in the city. If you enjoy this then you must try Lincoln Lounge in Mount Vernon I like to call myse
Almando PerezJanuary 20, 2016
Pizza is very good. I also had chicken parm, I thought it was very good. Not. Too many restaurant have a good one.
Kelsey RichardNovember 9, 2013
Best pizza I've ever had. Got 2 peroni beers and a whole pie for only 25.20 (including tax) I'll def be going back.
Nadib Al-IslamApril 23, 2016
Tried the cheese slice. Gotta admit, one of the best thin crust I have ever had. Definitely recommend it.
Julie SosciaJanuary 27, 2019
Classic spot for an amazing slice of thin crust pizza. Worth the trip to East Harlem.
M. G. StellaJanuary 25, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Drita is always one of the most accommodating servers I've encountered in New York City. Good service paired with some of the best pizza around. Salute!
Martin RigbyJanuary 28, 2020
Open with a caprese salad. If you were thinking of going to Grimaldi’s go here instead. (Or to Juliana’s if you are near Grimaldi’s already)
Graham GnallNovember 10, 2018
Stick with the coal original, even if getting several pies. It's incredible, cheap, and not too filling.
Serious EatsAugust 19, 2011
It's awesome. Go. Regular and fresh mozzarella are both good, and you can order pies or slices. Cash only. Read more
Maurice RossOctober 1, 2022
Historically great pizza. Exceptional
New York HabitatMarch 7, 2012
Get a thin-crust pizza slice at the take-out window and walk east one block to enjoy eating pizza with a view of the East River!
FarheenSeptember 22, 2018
Get the classic slice. Also delivery from them is just as good as eating there
Rachel W.November 22, 2010
Been here 25+ times
This is the original Patsy's, unaffiliated with the rest in the city. Their coal oven pizzas are the closest to what I've had in Italy. Absolutely delicious.
Nicole ChristieMay 29, 2010
I can't even eat regular pizza anymore--Patsy's has spoiled me. The thin crust, the cheese, the sauce! So good you can eat a whole pie and not feel guilty. GO HERE! You will not regret it...
Craig PollardDecember 10, 2015
I had the margherita and it was great.
SarahgoatJune 10, 2016
Pizza is awesome, share as an appetizer, then get classic red sauce food.
Giovanni MelendezJanuary 4, 2016
Best pizza hands down, you would have to order a pie, one slice is not enough!!!!
ZkApril 7, 2015
Patsy said Daisy was working today which is why Marty & I drove here all the way from Ronnie's. Karen hasn't stopped quipping about it all night. I shoulda listened to Larry.
Tom WalshSeptember 7, 2017
The crust and the dough has great flavor the staff is great.
Kathryn DJune 5, 2017
Everything is delicious but the pizzas are the stars.
MaddieOctober 3, 2015
Good thin crust pizza. Fast service. Friendly wait staff. Clean place.
Wejdan ✨August 18, 2018
Classic New York slice. Best in the area.

1 2 3

418 Photos

Patsy's Pizzeria

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Patsy's Pizzeria

Appears on 864 lists

Top places in the area