Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Paulie Gee's
Pizzeria and Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant$$$$
Greenpoint, Brooklyn
The experts at Eater and Travel + Leisure recommend this place
"Cherry jones and the Hellboy"(22 Tips)"Agree with others, the Hellboy pizza is the best."(13 Tips)
"... enjoying the food. Hell boy and cherry jones were both amazing...oh and..."(10 Tips)
"... jones (very unique), hellified porkpie white and hellboy. The porkypineapple and..."(8 Tips)
399 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good for dates
- cherry jones
- casual
- spicy food
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Slice Pizza BlogFebruary 2, 2011The Anise and Anephew is one of our favorite pizzas EVER. But also try the Hellboy, made with Mike's Hot Honey, which is an awesome, awesome condiment. Word.
ZacharyDecember 29, 2017worth the hype and the wait. you can substitute non-dairy cheese on any pizza.
Charlotte ChanJune 4, 2017Im sure this place has great pizzas but it was an immediate turnoff that hostess was acting rude and snobby, like she was doing us a huge favor by "maybe" sitting us down. Drop the attitude Paulie
We go here fairly regularly as IWW are a couple blocks away. We've never had a bad experience here and it's baby friendly! I
The Hellboy just blew my mind and my taste buds out of my skull. Also, the space and atmosphere are absolutely perfect...
Nicklas HolmAugust 5, 2016Probably the best pizza in NYC. Get the Hellboy. Or the Ricky ricotta. Or anything really.
Great wine list. I'm in love with their rose by the glass which goes perfect with the Greenpointer pie.
- Joe DAugust 30, 2014The Monte Cristo is cheesy, bacony, and the maple syrup drizzle ain't too sweet (in a good way)
jon ferrerAugust 23, 2014The pizzas here are so damn good. Especially the spicy sopressatta with hot honey.- Erin StFebruary 23, 2015Killer pizza and a wonderful owner who usually comes out and says hello to every table.
Sarah GrimmApril 13, 2013No exaggeration, this is the best pizza in NYC. The arugula shmoogula is not to be missed.
Theresa RoldanAugust 10, 2015If you're here, might as well go all out. Do better than the Greenpointer
Emily WilsonAugust 30, 2018Paulie Gee’s is just ok. The hellboy slays but Ops, Una Pizza Napoletana, and Roberta’s blow PG’s out of the water. Skip it, peeps! (Or if you’re already here, at least skip dessert).
Eleonora ZorziSeptember 26, 2014Cherry Jones, Cherry Jones, Cherry Jones! Such a tasty mix of savory and sweet.
CasieOctober 23, 2014If you plan your next private dinner occasion here, you get to email with Mrs. Gee who is a gem!
Sandra RubinchikAugust 13, 2014Get one of the pizzas drizzled in spicy honey or face a future full of agonizing regret.
Thom FinnarnJune 29, 2015The Hellboy, with Mike's Hot Honey is always amazing. ...say Hi to Paulie for me 🙋
Anna OhareJuly 9, 2014Meet paulie himself. Order more pies than people and you may jst get a free shot!
William HubaOctober 19, 2014Super incredibly absurdly long wait. The food is fantastic, Paulie is great, and the service sucks.
Michelle AlexanderApril 12, 2015If you left any room for dessert the hot honey Sunday is really good.
Henry W. NgAugust 11, 2013Spin the heavy metal wheel on the wooden counter by the front door for good luck—it used to be part of a vintage conveyor belt system, supposedly.
Sara StatesMarch 14, 2014I can't wait to come back! This place seriously rivals Roberta's. I won't be satisfied until I've had ALL THE PIZZAS.
The Hellboy is super. Don't let the mention of Mike's hot hard honey put you off.
Katrina MauroMarch 19, 2013Try the Arugula Schmoogula - One of my favorite simple pies ever. And who doesn't like saying schmoogula?
Best Pizza in BK. Worth the wait. I recommend coming at 6pm, you won't have to wait.
Jen BergFebruary 22, 2015Get more pies than people. Try as much as possible and celebrate with leftovers.
Mike ChauSeptember 9, 2012Try the King Harry The Iv - Italian tomatoes, provolone, beef meatballs, sliced cremini mushrooms and golden raisins
Daniel ChangDecember 31, 2015Surprisingly liked some of the vegetarian options as much as the meat ones
Tara TrilopsFebruary 19, 2011Grab a bottle or two of Mike's Hot Honey (featured on the Hellboy pizza) from the bar on your way out. $6 each, and made in Brooklyn.
Best pizza ever. But the whole world know it... get there early and prepare to wait a while.
Sam CøaNovember 13, 2018The pizza was not really tasty.The dough was good but the rest was super tasteless with way too much garlic eventhough I’m afan of garlic.Don’t know why this spot gets such a high rating.Disappointed
807 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Paulie Gee's
60 Greenpoint Ave (btwn Franklin & West St)
Brooklyn, NY 11222
United States
Brooklyn, NY 11222
United States
Closed until 6:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 6:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 6:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Sat
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 5:00 PM–10:00 PM
(347) 987-3747
View menu on http://pauliegee.com/greenpoint/menu
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
No
Dining Options
Table Service
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
Appears on 3,369 lists
#100best dishes and drinks 2011
Created by Time Out New York
100 items • 5,313 followers
Created by Michelin Travel & Lifestyle
127 items • 1,863 followers
Created by Adam Kuban
67 items • 837 followers
