Petee's Cafe

Pie Shop, Bakery, and Café

Clinton Hill, Brooklyn

Save

Petee's Cafe

9.0^/10

ratings

Ranked #7 for pie shops in Brooklyn
"Try the strawberry rhubarb pie!"(2 Tips)
"I recommend the NY Sour Cherry pie!"(2 Tips)
"Get the peach pie and be sure to add whipped cream."(2 Tips)
"The coffee and apple strudel."(2 Tips)

15 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Sort:

sMarch 13, 2019
Been here 5+ times
lovely little cafe with a good variety of pies that will make you consider saying screw my diet just get everything they have. I recommend the NY Sour Cherry pie!
Adam KDecember 8, 2018
Been here 10+ times
The answer to Clinton Hill's dessert prayers! Literally everything is delicious, but I'm partial to the black bottom chess, the sour cherry, and the blackcurrant streusel when it's in season.
John ClineJanuary 26, 2020
The cinnamon roll is incredible! A cream cheese frosting with a hint of orange really makes it pop!
Valentin GuerinJune 3, 2018
Try the strawberry rhubarb pie!
Andrew BezekAugust 17, 2019
Get the peach pie and be sure to add whipped cream.
Holly BrittonJune 21, 2019
I was completely unaware of my affinity for pie until I encountered Petee’s. Insane crust!
Melissa PerezOctober 12, 2019
The coffee and apple strudel. But I had milk that was kinda curdled.
Amy SheridanOctober 28, 2018
Omg... all the pies are delicious!
Gideon OlshanskyMarch 4, 2019
Make sure to add make whipped cream to everything you order.
lino brescia™March 8, 2019
kids love the pie
Md NisharJune 9, 2018
good place and so beautifull
Kelsey✨November 29, 2018
Gluten-free pumpkin pie!
stephen friasOctober 16, 2018
great pies
Inna GJune 3, 2018
Strawberry rhubarb pie is great, skip the pecan
Daniel MaliaMarch 21, 2019
Decent apple pie, crust was not flaky and crisp but more damp and soft. Portion too small to be even worth the $6 they charge.

48 Photos