Phoenicia Diner
Diner, Breakfast Spot, and Sandwich Spot$$$$
Phoenicia
"Great representation of the best of the Catskills."(7 Tips)
"Serves typical diner fare with a locally sourced lean."(5 Tips)
"bloody marys are delicious-- any of the skillets are great too."(28 Tips)
"One of the best diners!!! Good quality food."(2 Tips)
119 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- breakfast food
- catskills
- healthy food
- pancakes
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
DensApril 2, 2014Best breakfast we've found within 20mi of anywhere. The Bloody Marys are top notch and the skillets are epic. ProTip: start with the breakfast tacos as an appetizer!
Tim HettlerFebruary 23, 2016You could say this place is specifically catering to Brooklyn hipsters on holiday, but - damnit - hipsters know how to brunch. Serves typical diner fare with a locally sourced lean. Not to be missed.Upvoted 2 weeks ago
Gregory FisherFebruary 1, 2014This is potentially the best diner I've ever been to. Definitely get fries and if chicken chili is on the menu, combine them...the kitchen won't do it in the back, but best chili cheese fries ever
Victor JungSeptember 27, 2021A favorite with locals and visitors to Hunter mountain. Phoenicia has friendly service with classic diner menu filled with seasonal and local ingredients. The pan fried trout is one of my favorites.
Barry BloomAugust 3, 2015A real keeper. On Route 28 just south of Phoenicia, NY. Another stop on the two lane to Cooperstown. Everything is very fresh. Hardly a dinner menu. Meatloaf lunch is plentiful and delish!
Justin BretonJuly 3, 2014The Bloody Mary is fantastic! It's made with a local vodka, which makes it taste better just because...
Marie La RueNovember 22, 2018Quintessential brunch spot in the Catskills. Excellent Bloody Mary. Gets crowded but service is fast. Great for people watching.
Paige CJuly 26, 2017They are weird about letting you take food to go. Only can be done w/ certain items. Apparently their hot food will "melt" the container? Anyway, food is good. Try the sandwiches or watermelon salad.
Arlo Devlin-BrownDecember 13, 2015It is all good here, but you can't beat the wild hive polenta skillet, topped with two perfect poached eggs. A homemade Bloody Mary with local vodka doesn't hurt either.
Elizabeth MitchellMay 26, 2016Everything is delicious. Kid friendly, bourbon shakes, and incredible food. Reuben was excellent, pancakes were a dream, and the kale salad was fabulous.- DensApril 2, 2014No Bloody Marys served 'till noon, but when the clock strikes, hoo-doggy they are good. Miglorelli Farm Tomato Juice + Catskills Peace Vodka + some weird root thing = $8!
Kevin GrantNovember 16, 2016The bloody Mary is amazing. The biscuits and gravy are amazing. The cell service on t-mobile is nonexistent and I'm pretty sure the free WiFi is a farse, but that's OK, pay attention to your friends
Swen GrahamNovember 28, 2015The breakfast tacos were everything I've dreamed of and more. Best Mexican breakfast fusion outside of California.
Kathryn DAugust 26, 2016Usually a wait but the bar scene compensates. For food, all of the skillets are great, especially the one with duck. Order a side of mac n cheese.
Jackie GApril 16, 2017If you want to avoid major crowds, go early in the morning or later in the afternoon. Avoid Sunday all together if possible - however, the food is well worth the wait. I love the omelets and skillets!
Willem Van LanckerAugust 18, 2015The best (and only) diner for miles around. The skillets are great. Expect a wait.- Best Mexican breakfast in the Catskills. Great pancakes and local ingredients. Wonderful people. Great representation of the best of the Catskills.
Dan AcostaOctober 19, 2019Best diner to stop by during a camping trip. Everything is great here. Choose from a special or try a local brew!
AshleyAugust 2, 2017Everything on the menu is delicious. Their bread is really good and baked in-house.
Colleen SheaFebruary 20, 2020The food comes out quick like a typical diner but the quality and taste is way better weather you’re having breakfast or lunch! The crispy chix sammie is delicious but way too big for 1 person..share!
CarolineDecember 8, 2016This diner is a jewel of the restaurants. Breakfast served all day. Vegetarian alternatives. Delicious food, a real american atmosphere and a friendly service.
Jenny LinAugust 7, 2014Get a skillet - you won't regret it. While you're at it, their Bloody Mary is made with locally sourced tomato juice & vodka 👌
PierreMay 30, 2016Amazing! I hear there's always a crowd but ended up not having to wait too long for a counter seat. Chicken and waffles was some of the best I've tasted.
KateSeptember 2, 2021The best pancakes I've ever had at a restaurant are here. Fluffy on the inside, crisp on the outside, and delicious local maple syrup!
Pauline B.August 18, 2013Biscuit sandwich is lovely .. Great bacon biscuit had maybe a pepper and rosemary hint .. Himself lived the Chorizo omelet .. Service great ! These people work hard! .. Easy choice- Cheryl HuangJune 14, 2014One of the best diners!!! Good quality food. Portion is a bit too big but very testy. Loved my Veggie Quesadilla.
Alex HunterNovember 1, 2021My coffee was never empty and for me, that is a good diner. Plus fluffy pancakes and a tasty breakfast burrito.
Andy MeehanAugust 28, 2017Staff that gives a damn and food made with the good local stuff. Many reasons to go back. Corned beef sandwich and trout skillet are two.
Emily IsleJune 11, 2016Skillets are legit. Locally sourced food. It's a calculated cast of diner grunge and hipster appeal.
Cooper SmithOctober 19, 2014Tortilla soup is the perfect way to warm up after a brisk fall day of hiking.
LilySeptember 2, 2022A perfect diner experience. Don’t miss the fresh squeezed juices. I recommend trying the local smoked trout🤌
Vincent RaymondFebruary 16, 2015Farmers skillet is awesome!! This is an awesome diner, awesome restaurant in general!
CharlottesJune 1, 2016Delicious food in charming old school diner, en route to or from Catskills. Word to the wise, check your bill on the way out.
Sean SalmonAugust 4, 2014Pancakes - Buckwheat are crazy good or Buttermilk which are impossibly light and airy. Pour on the local maple syrup and enjoy
Chelsea FowlerFebruary 3, 2017The food is good, but a bit pricey since they focus on quality ingredients. The bourbon milkshake was a great treat! I was a little disappointed with the service level. I felt ignored at times.
This place has never let me down. Consistent and delicious food, sweet and knowledgable servers... A seriously beautiful establishment.
Daniel PowellNovember 11, 2017Worth the trip - cool setup. Higher quality breakfast fare. Duck dish had limited meat and was a little dry but great flavors.
Amanda VinciAugust 29, 2015Awesome old diner turned hipster hang out. Polenta and eggs was delicious.
Roniel TesslerNovember 8, 2017One of the best diners EVER. The skillets are divine. The pancakes are perfect. The ambiance can't be beat.
Giacomo MazziniJanuary 5, 2015Omg! Generous portions, good food, friendly staff. A little wait but expected when the food is so good!- Justin BretonJuly 1, 2014Free WiFi! Connect to "Phoenicia" network (not "Phoenicia Diner"). Use the phone number as the password (8456889957). As of 7/1/14.
The corned beef is house-cured, and comes as hash, a Reuben, or snuck into the gravy in their amazing biscuits and gravy.
Grant Ryan LAugust 13, 2014Skillets are great, and they make a great Bloody Mary. The menu is really well designed too!
535 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
American diner on NY Route 28 serves local seasonal Catskills/Hudson Valley food. Thurs-Tues 8a-6p, closed Wed; breakfast all day
None listed (See when people check in)
People tend to check in during these times:
- Today
- 9:00 AM–4:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 8:00 AM–5:00 PM
- Mon
- 9:00 AM–3:00 PM
- Tue
- 11:00 AM–Noon
- Wed
- None
- Thu
- 11:00 AM–2:00 PM
(845) 688-9957
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.0
"The menu is seasonal and changes daily based on fresh ingredients. One things for sure -- the Parsnips Gratin was delicious! A must-have side!!"
Rusty Harding - 8.2
"The pancakes are great. The breakfast burrito and bacon are quite good. I really like their coffee, it is very smooth"
Kathrine Mitchell - 7.0
"Good food, friendly prices. Get prime rib if they are running it as a daily special."
Tom L.
Places people like to go after Phoenicia Diner
Appears on 454 lists
Created by Foursquare City Guide
45 items • 248 followers
Travel Guide to the Hudson Valley
Created by Foursquare City Guide
38 items • 24 followers
Created by Dens
17 items • 29 followers