- This pizzeria is famous for their pizza. It's one of the most popular in the city!
- pizza
- burgers
- good for dates
- casual
- trendy
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Perri SilverJuly 14, 2016The menu says they won't make modifications to the burger, but they will if you just ask nicely.
- Menu stars include: The Colony, the Q, and the kale salad.
- Phil KatzDecember 26, 2014Oh mama. The colony is insane, but for that matter, so is everything else.
- Mahesh Paolini-SubramanyaSeptember 28, 2015Best Roman-style pizza in NYC (thin, almost cracker-like crust)
- ElizabethMay 23, 2015Definitely go for the Emily pizza (or the Colony if you can handle some kick!).
- Meghan PaulJune 14, 2015Stupid good. Kale salad, Emily pizza, and the burger. If you only get one - burger.
- Rob PrattApril 29, 2019Good food but not worth the hype / line. Burger is way to greasy / oily. I do NOT recommend doing the “vindaloo bacon” your fries.
- M MDecember 22, 2015The dessert canzone is enough four 4 people. I don't recommend it if you have a beard, unless you like cleaning sticky marshmallow out of yours.
- Alberto MannApril 14, 2017Wildly overrated pizza. Not saying it's bad but doesn't live up to hype/FSq rating. Excessive toppings/sauce created soggy, greasy and chewy crust. Plain pizza was better than Colony for this reason.
- Bitches Who BrunchDecember 16, 2016The Bitches say: A. For one of the best lunch-brunches in the boroughs and one of the best new burgers in the city, head to Emily ASAP. Everything, besides the lack of caffeine, was amazing. Read more
- LukeNovember 6, 2016Come early, if you want the burger. It's that simple. If you miss it, the pizza is chill
- Colony pizza = best pizza. Pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey.
- So into their green pizzas. How did it take so long for the world to think of tomatillo sauce on a pizza?
- Split the Spinach Salad, burger, and Emily pizza #perfectmeal
- Kahina BeMarch 8, 2017It's rated really good and I had high hopes to find a good pizza place here but this place is super disappointing and the pizza is average and not worth the price at all.
- Get the Grave Blanc AOC (white Bordeaux blend) with any white pizza.