See all
92 photos

Pomodoro Rosso

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Lincoln Square, New York

Save

Pomodoro Rosso

7.7^/10

150

ratings

Ranked #9 for pasta in the Upper West Side
"Their fresh pastas are great"(2 Tips)
"Excellent service."(5 Tips)
"the Pasta Bolognese is out of this world :-)"(2 Tips)
"Great cozy lunch spot!!"(2 Tips)

52 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
great value
DJs
casual
chicken
brunch food
dinner
bread
friendly staff
grappa
pomodoro
ricotta cheese
good for special occasions
olive oil
well
lunch
family dining
takeout
diner food
crowded
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Kathy ZeigerJune 20, 2012
A long time diner, the food is always delicious, the atmosphere a comfort, the service impeccable, and the wine flows.. Lovely.
Vito GialloJune 24, 2012
The pasta is good. Portions are about double a normal one (at least in Italy / Europe). So, unless you are starving or a big eater, one pasta is enough for two. Especially with starters
Ernie BelloJanuary 28, 2018
Traditional Italian vibe but with excellent flair and flavor. Get any of the fresh pastas. Good martinis as well.
Susan ClaxtonJuly 31, 2012
LOVE this place. Try the chicken ruggatino. You will not regret it. The bread and infused olive oil is also delicious. And a generous pour on the wines by the glass! A long time fav.
W. Vincent ParkAugust 29, 2012
Local favorite since forever (I have been a regular since '2000), this northern Italian restaurant serves fantastic pasta dishes along with super-friendly service.
EvrenAugust 30, 2019
The house bread is excellent! It tells you that the food will be awesome as well..Try sea food pasta! Huge plates😋
Cristina RJuly 7, 2012
I order takeout from here all the time, and each time, the service has been great, and the food has been delicious! Rigatoni alla Ricotta is to die for.
Leah HelmerJune 24, 2016
their pasta bolognase is out of this world. I am going back there again next year for my birthday with my best friend.
Michelle COctober 12, 2015
Excellent service. All indoor seating required a reservation but we didn't have to wait long at the bar for outdoor seating.
BauzenJuly 8, 2011
Brought a large party and we were accommodated on short notice. Everyone enjoyed their dinner from the service to the generous portions of pasta. Instantly one of my favorite family dining places.
David MadeoMay 20, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Splitting the gnocchi pollo is great for two people - unfortunately it's not on the menu anymore = try other restaurants. PLEASE BRING IT BACK!!!!
Trae FNovember 29, 2014
Great local Italian spot. The food is excellent and the place is bustling on the weekends.
Peter WeissensteinAugust 29, 2011
Phenomenal service that is only topped by the quality of the food. The food is not only delicious but a visual pleasure as well. The staff could not be more attentive and courteous. Read more
Kaitlyn PezikMay 11, 2015
another one of my fave spots from my days working on the UWS. awesome Italian food and great service.
Dianna DiSantoOctober 7, 2012
Great service, heaping bowls of pasta, but they got a B rating which was kind of disturbing.. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Dorian LirianoJune 24, 2010
Everyone here is extremely friendly and it seems like the owner is there at times helping out as well. I would recommend this great spot to anyone.
eric bornemannApril 14, 2021
Small old school red sauce joint. Cozy and decent food.
Tom JohansmeyerOctober 19, 2010
Been here 25+ times
This the best service I've had in Manhattan: both efficient and very friendly. I come here often for a reason!
Bruce and Budge TyrrellJuly 23, 2015
Steak sandwich and chicken quinoa were excellent!
Kimilee BryantJuly 19, 2014
Stroller & Puppy friendly. Belgian waffle is yummy for brunch!
Victor HugoJune 3, 2016
PAPPARDELLE AL CROSTACEO and the RAVIOLI ALLA ARAGOSTA.
Brett HildabrandJune 27, 2017
Some of the best Italian food I've ever had...and I've been to Italy!
Nofar CohenOctober 7, 2013
Great restaurant! Affordable and good pasta.
Leah HelmerMay 5, 2014
the Pasta Bolognese is out of this world :-)
Steven NoelsJuly 27, 2015
Very very very very friendly staff!
Robert DeebJune 21, 2016
Everything is good and it won't break the bank
Leah HelmerAugust 26, 2016
their pasta bolognase is delicious
Lawrence O'TooleMarch 19, 2012
Huge bowls of pasta, very attentive service, quaint ambiance.
Ryan McMahonFebruary 28, 2015
Their fresh pastas are great
Shaina Bhumitra-UpadhyayMarch 14, 2012
Awesome food especially the free bread they give
Kevin BowersApril 17, 2010
The host is very accommodating. Great seats for 2 at the corner of the bar by the window.
Glynis KarpMarch 27, 2011
Peter is the ultimate host and the baked clams are the best around!
Toby MatejovskyJuly 14, 2013
The pappardelle is great
Aron CohenJuly 13, 2015
good selection, but some of the ingredients just didn't seem as fresh as they could have been.
Sarah MOctober 3, 2017
Not entirely satisfied with the experience. Their Veal Milanese was chewy & hard to cut. The Napoletana Pizza 🍕? I would not recommend at all.
hi hiJune 13, 2011
You can't go wrong with Penne a la Grappa!
john JohnsonOctober 20, 2018
Snapper!! Great!!
Victor PriceOctober 9, 2013
Great cozy lunch spot!!
Margaret MolloyJanuary 19, 2014
Great pasta for the kids
German MejiaOctober 10, 2012
Get the Pomodoro Fettuccini
DJ Latin Prince ✔ July 11, 2013
amazing food.. - DJ Latin Prince
Alec CohenAugust 6, 2014
Great neighborhood spot
Leah HelmerJune 18, 2016
Their pasta bolognase
DaveMarch 29, 2015
Everyone goes to Pomodoro to break up
jill Harkavy-FriedmanAugust 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Delicious as always!
GizGuzSeptember 19, 2021
Terrible place! Do not go there! The guy taking the reservations is too rude! Such a shame
Marie La RueJanuary 7, 2021
Veal was subpar.
Eric RattnerJanuary 30, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Amazing Pasta
Kelly GribbApril 17, 2010
The bolognese sauce is to die for!
Adele BlancoSeptember 26, 2011
Mediocre. But the bread sticks are good. Kinda like the olive garden

1 2

92 Photos

Pomodoro Rosso

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Pomodoro Rosso

Appears on 61 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.