- Popular
- Recent
- Nicole FormicaJuly 2, 2015Great selection of custom and classic cocktails! Be sure to come early to avoid the crowd
- Peter WuJune 28, 2015Love their menu! All drinks are graphed on two axes: adventurousness v. comforting and spirit-filled v. refreshing.
- Jenny FanJuly 25, 2017Low-key speakeasy without obnoxiously long lines, friendly bouncer, excellent drinks. Good for Sunday nights
- GlennApril 15, 2016Fancy cocktails and a charming atmosphere. Good for dates or a relaxed night out with friends.
- Far more seating than most other notable East Village cocktail bars, such as Angel Share and Death & Co.
- Alejandro HoyoJuly 12, 2016Incredible/ cool-as-heck menu of drinks graphed by flavor/personality + wicked selection of Chartreuse featuring cocktails.
- Grant ShellenSeptember 23, 2017Incredibly well-designed cocktails, served by friendly folks in an unpretentious and lovely space.
- Marc SchneebergerMarch 5, 2017Amazing cocktails, nothing else to add. Just let the waiter recomend you!!! Great spot!
- Nora MooreAugust 20, 2014Amazing cocktails!! Best manhattan and old fashioned. Sazarac was even better than in New Orleans.
- Serious EatsMarch 6, 2013A cocktail-lover's cocktail bar, its inventive drinks ranked by how spirit-forward and how experimental they are.
- AlexNovember 14, 2012Unique tall glass ice cubes and friendly bartenders, but this place isn't intimate enough for a first date. Better for drinks with a friend.
- Chris SteeleDecember 31, 2014Exile on Main Street and The General Lee are both boozy knockouts. The maple bacon brittle isn't half bad either.
- Leigh FerreiraJune 23, 2013Get the Eye to Eye. Eagle Rare bourbon, lemon, macadamia falernum, strawberry & angostura bitters. Sooo good.
- Amazing spot for a classy drink, with an extensive mix of quality house cocktails.
- Suri RApril 22, 2013One of the bartenders made a heavenly mezcal Sazerac (off the menu). Only worth going if you have a bar seat.
- Time Out New YorkOctober 5, 2018Claim a barstool to watch a pro expertly stir your drink in a beaker-like glass, or settle your crew into one of the cozy dark-gray banquettes. Read more
- Paul KardousApril 4, 2015Always a very friendly, chill vibe. It's likely because the staff are great and the cocktails excellent.
- CassidyJanuary 12, 2013Playlist could use an update (Uncle Kracker? Really???), but drinks are delicious and ambiance is hard to beat.
- Yoni ZloczewskiSeptember 23, 2015Low key laid back atmosphere - the drinks are not stellar but the staff is very friendly and helpful.
- Sarah NelsonFebruary 16, 2013Outstanding drinks, mid-level atmosphere, BS door policy (bouncer & queue when empty inside). Get the Ragin Glory.
- Great bartenders, good vibe, amazing drinks. Make sure to check this place out
- Brooklyn UnitedJune 19, 2013A nice, quiet, low key environment, great place to go with a small group of friends.
- Natalie VDecember 3, 2017The cocktails were good but the hostess was rude. We came to celebrate a bday & even emailed ahead to see if we needed a reservation. They said no, but the hostess started turning away friends anyways
- Liz ChenMarch 2, 2013the haberdasher is suprisingly strong, be prepared for something that is almost chocolately but still very good.
- Adam Van DusenJuly 12, 2015Where inventive mixology is paired with intelligent, kind bartenders. The best cocktail in New York.
- Pratheeksha KSApril 25, 2018Lots of chartreuse cocktails on the menu. It's pretty spacious for an East Village bar.
- Andrew D.May 7, 2014Superior cocktails. Inferior decor. The bare walls are institutional looking, dim the lights and hang some pictures.
- Talia FisherOctober 20, 2012So far I've had the spirit of diplomacy and death and taxes and LOVE them! Can't go wrong with either.
- Very good cocktails, very blah small food menu. The space is large but not cozy. Better for a group than a date.
- I love it whenever their menu changes. so many awesome drinks to try!
- Kimmie OhhDecember 8, 2019The drink menu allows customers to know whether drinks are familiar or adventurous or whether they’re refreshing or spiritous.
- Anastasia EnotAugust 25, 2015Cocktails are good without being exceptional. Great servers. Nice atmosphere but nothing original
- Rachel DunlapDecember 9, 2012They'll make off menu cocktails for you too. Just tell the waitress what you like!
- Can RoySeptember 16, 2012Cocktails are AMAZING. Highly recommend the Dark + Stormy and Spirit of Diplomacy
- Cocktail MagicMarch 21, 2016Sazerac was the signature cocktail featured at Cocktail Magic. Read more
- Cowrie ShellApril 9, 2013Brighter and more weirdly spartan than one would expect. Quite echoey and loud when more than half full. Great drinks, though.
- pkqk …August 18, 2014Drink everything but definitely choose something on the adventurous scale especially when it doesn't sound adventurous.