Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza

Pizzeria$$$$
NoLita, New York
Save
Share
9.1/10
1,931
ratings
  • Stars
  • Tips
    jon f.
    "The Spicy Spring is probably the best square slice in the city!"(22 Tips)
    The Bowery House
    ""Soho Square" pizza slice is among the very best in the area."(15 Tips)
    Brian S.
    "Spicy pepperoni square slice all the way!"(9 Tips)
    Daniele P.
    "Go for a square pizza slice, for sure one of the best in town!"(12 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon354 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • spicy spring
  • good for a quick meal
  • soho square
  • casual
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Rayheart icon on user image
    RayMarch 23, 2016
    The spicy spring square aka the pepperoni square is the only thing I have gotten and will ever get here. Ask for it extra crispy, unless it's fresh from the oven, in which case get it now!!
    Upvoted 2 days ago
  • Adam K.heart icon on user image
    Adam KubanFebruary 9, 2014
    If you're not getting the square slices here, you're doin' it wrong. The Spicy Spring (pepperoni) is my pick here, but the plain square is excellent, too. Best-in-class squares.
    Upvoted Oct 11
  • Mike F.heart icon on user image
    Mike FriedlichFebruary 15, 2017
    Best slice I've had in NYC. It is filled with pepperoni and everything about it, including the crust, is perfect.
    Upvoted Oct 6
  • Petros A.heart icon on user image
    Petros AOctober 13, 2016
    Amazing pizza slices! The service is not the best though (and we are talking about a takeaway place). It seems they know their pizza is popular in any case so no need to try which I guess is true...
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsJanuary 27, 2014
    This spot, (formerly Ray's) serves some of the finest square slices in the city, like the Spicy Spring, which comes with natural casing pepperoni that curls and crisps in the oven.
  • Alyssa B.heart icon on user image
    Alyssa B.November 25, 2019
    Sauce is rich and peppery, on a perfect pan crust. Would come back at off-peak hrs next time
  • Robert A.heart icon on user image
    Robert AccetturaApril 7, 2018
    Get the pepperoni slice. That’s what they are known for. It’s slightly greasy, but delicious thick slices o pepperoni that cup with a slight char. Their other pizzas are ok. This is their fame.
  • Jon C.
    Jon ChanOctober 25, 2017
    Been here 10+ times
    It's worth the wait (and well-deserved)! This place is my favorite slice of pizza in the city. You're looking for the pepperoni square, save the traditional triangle for someplace else.
  • Noah W.heart icon on user image
    Noah WeissSeptember 3, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    The Soho Square with pepperoni is probably the best slice in the city.
  • J Crowley
    J CrowleyMay 30, 2012
    No joke - the Vodka Sauce slice is one of the best I've ever had. Grab a side of Prosciutto balls (with ricotta) and a window seat. People watch and stuff your face like a Creepy McFatso!
  • Avneesh K.heart icon on user image
    Avneesh KohliApril 15, 2018
    Can’t go wrong with the pepperoni squares and vodka pizza slices. Probably my favorite pizza in NYC
  • Amberheart icon on user image
    AmberOctober 27, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    Get the spicy square. Pepperoni for dayz. (Honestly, don't waste your time with anything else, the spice square is why you're here).
  • Alex R.heart icon on user image
    Alex RichardsJuly 30, 2015
    This is one of NYC's best pizza joints. Grab a slice or two and look at the photos of celebs on the walls.
  • Simon K.heart icon on user image
    Simon KratzerDecember 26, 2016
    Go for a spicy spring, it's massive! (with extra salami on the picture :))
  • Tim S.
    Tim SheaAugust 2, 2018
    Been here 5+ times
    Probably some of the best pizza in Manhattan, but the line can be downright obnoxious (both in length and the people in it), gird your loins accordingly.
  • Juan R.heart icon on user image
    Juan RestrepoMarch 4, 2019
    Had the Sicilian, pep, and the grandma slice. All truly top notch. Worth the 30 minute wait? Maybe this time
  • Ben K.heart icon on user image
    Ben K.November 23, 2015
    One of the best slices in NYC: the square pepperoni. Also try the vodka slice.
  • Michael G.heart icon on user image
    Michael G.September 4, 2018
    Been here 5+ times
    Get the pepperoni. It’s so good, and they are very generous with the pepperoni. Worth it for $4.50 especially after a night of drinking.
  • Albert T.heart icon on user image
    Albert TongJuly 4, 2017
    It's all about the spicy spring street pizza. Pan square pepperoni slice. Great crust and crispy pepperoni. Not that spicy actually.
  • Barton S.heart icon on user image
    Barton SmithAugust 1, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    Their pepperoni squares are great. The dough is thicker but it's really tasty and kinda chewy. A nice alternative to your regular NY slice.
  • Alyssa B.heart icon on user image
    Alyssa B.August 15, 2021
    Ok so I lined up during prime time (sunday 6pm) the line was 25 min. 5 square roni slices is $30. Worth it imo
  • Bee W.heart icon on user image
    Bee WilliamsJanuary 8, 2016
    The pizza here is super good! We got the pepperoni Sicilian and it was amazing!!!!
  • jake f.
    jake furstNovember 29, 2012
    everything you could want in a New York slice: thin and crunchy crust, sweet and tangy sauce, fresh mozz and the whole thing's so damn hot that it burns the roof of your mouth. YES.
  • Honghui Y.heart icon on user image
    Honghui YuNovember 10, 2017
    Get one of their square slices. It's what they're known for and it's fucking delicious.
  • Garett P.
    Garett PressAugust 13, 2014
    Spicy spring and vodka and everything in between. Some of the best slices in NYC no doubt about it.
  • Chris C.heart icon on user image
    Chris CooksonJanuary 9, 2015
    Been here 10+ times
    The first time I took a bite in to their vodka slice, it tasted like I was sent to a new flavorful dimension. The cheese on that slice was great quality too!! Square pepperoni slice also great!
  • Rafa T.heart icon on user image
    Rafa TJanuary 20, 2016
    Been here 5+ times
    This is the best tomato sauce in town. Any slice or square is amazing. My absolute fav is the pepperoni square, not the slice. Crunchy, greasy goodness...
  • Khashyheart icon on user image
    KhashyFebruary 15, 2021
    (9/10) GET THE PEPPERONI ONLY! It’s so good!
  • Chad H.heart icon on user image
    Chad HornerJanuary 21, 2018
    Been here 5+ times
    square slice - loaded with crispy pepperoni - is one of the best you’ll find
  • Theart icon on user image
    TSeptember 14, 2017
    Get the pepperoni! You won't regret
  • Eric H.heart icon on user image
    Eric HoJanuary 5, 2017
    Best slice I've had in NYC 🍕. Follow me on Instagram @EricHoRaw for more food adventures.
  • Boshika T.heart icon on user image
    Boshika TaraDecember 31, 2018
    I can eat everything here, but for first time visit I suggest Pepperoni pizza and Margherita pizza. Also want to avoid the long lines, then go early like at 10am.
  • Jeffrey K.heart icon on user image
    Jeffrey KaoJune 7, 2017
    A New Yorker staple. Grab a SoHo Square (the one with dem crispy pepperonis) and munch it while you crush the streets of SoHo with your Pizza Swag.
  • KovuTheHuskyheart icon on user image
    KovuTheHuskyNovember 15, 2018
    The spicy spring slice is the best pepperoni pizza in NYC.
  • Eric N.
    Eric NingJanuary 7, 2017
    Pop in here for a grandma slice that's a bit more involved than your normal pizza place. Delicious food with a line that moves very fast.
  • Michael H.heart icon on user image
    Michael HaaralaMarch 26, 2017
    The greasy, fresh square slices are hands-down some of the best in the city. Get a classic pepperoni square (and plenty of napkins)!
  • Ben L.heart icon on user image
    Ben LairdMarch 29, 2018
    Spicy spring was amazing. Maybe the best slice I've ever had
  • Valerie S.
    Valerie SecklerApril 9, 2013
    Prince Street's Sicilian slice is outstanding. So is a crispy pepperoni topping. Sauce stars. Still, the $3.95 price surprises. Celeb photos dot this near hole-in-the-wall. Streisand is in the house.
  • Danny N.heart icon on user image
    Danny NathanApril 7, 2019
    Get the grandma slice. Less "traditionally NY" but so tasty. And go at an off time to avoid crazy lines.
  • jon f.heart icon on user image
    jon ferrerJuly 7, 2017
    The Spicy Spring is probably the best square slice in the city!
  • Keith K.heart icon on user image
    Keith KerrJanuary 7, 2018
    The “Soho Square” is what you want to order. Grab two, crispy. Then enjoy those little pepperoni cups.
  • Lindsey K.heart icon on user image
    Lindsey KimDecember 13, 2017
    Go here for the pepperoni pizza ONLY. Ask to make your slices extra crispy!
  • First We Feast
    First We FeastAugust 3, 2014
    "No other square can compare," claims Prince Street Pizza, and who are we to argue? The Sicilian slice here—deemed the "Prince Perfection"—is crunchy, chewy, and surprisingly light and airy. Read more
  • Jeffrey
    JeffreySeptember 6, 2013
    Vodka slice or Soho square - Prince St has the right doughy consistency, and step-up options like a vodka slice and square slices topped with spicy sopressata and fresh mozz.
  • Faraz K.heart icon on user image
    Faraz KhanAugust 5, 2017
    Fantastic Pizza, the chef of Alinea, from Chicago (#1 restaurant in North America) highly recommended it. Was so good I didn't take pics!
  • Tom M.
    Tom M.March 1, 2016
    The best square pizza in NYC--so fresh and tasty
  • Baturalpheart icon on user image
    BaturalpSeptember 10, 2018
    Get a slice of square pizzas. You won’t regret it however this place gets packed on the weekends.
  • Taniaheart icon on user image
    TaniaJune 18, 2017
    Delicious pepperoni pizza)))
  • Julia M.heart icon on user image
    Julia MontiSeptember 22, 2015
    Best pizza I've had in New York City by a landslide. Sicilian style pepperoni. Perfection. I'll definitely take friends here when they visit.
  • Connie X.heart icon on user image
    Connie XiaoFebruary 9, 2017
    A fresh-out-the-oven square slice of pepperoni pizza at Prince Street = the pizza of my dreams 🤤🍕❤️
Photos1,104 Photos

Related Searches

  • prince street pizza new york •
  • prince street pizza new york photos •
  • prince street pizza new york location •
  • prince street pizza new york address •
  • prince street pizza new york •
  • prince st. pizza new york •
  • prince street new york •
  • prince street pizza new york •
  • prince street pizza nolita new york

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA