Prince Street Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
NoLita, New York
"The Spicy Spring is probably the best square slice in the city!"(22 Tips)
""Soho Square" pizza slice is among the very best in the area."(15 Tips)
"Spicy pepperoni square slice all the way!"(9 Tips)
"Go for a square pizza slice, for sure one of the best in town!"(13 Tips)
358 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- spicy spring
- good for a quick meal
- soho square
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
RayMarch 23, 2016The spicy spring square aka the pepperoni square is the only thing I have gotten and will ever get here. Ask for it extra crispy, unless it's fresh from the oven, in which case get it now!!
Adam KubanFebruary 9, 2014If you're not getting the square slices here, you're doin' it wrong. The Spicy Spring (pepperoni) is my pick here, but the plain square is excellent, too. Best-in-class squares.
Upvoted 1 week ago
Mike FriedlichFebruary 15, 2017Best slice I've had in NYC. It is filled with pepperoni and everything about it, including the crust, is perfect.
Upvoted 4 weeks ago
Petros AOctober 13, 2016Amazing pizza slices! The service is not the best though (and we are talking about a takeaway place). It seems they know their pizza is popular in any case so no need to try which I guess is true...
Serious EatsJanuary 27, 2014This spot, (formerly Ray's) serves some of the finest square slices in the city, like the Spicy Spring, which comes with natural casing pepperoni that curls and crisps in the oven.
Alyssa B.November 25, 2019Sauce is rich and peppery, on a perfect pan crust. Would come back at off-peak hrs next time
Robert AccetturaApril 7, 2018Get the pepperoni slice. That’s what they are known for. It’s slightly greasy, but delicious thick slices o pepperoni that cup with a slight char. Their other pizzas are ok. This is their fame.
It's worth the wait (and well-deserved)! This place is my favorite slice of pizza in the city. You're looking for the pepperoni square, save the traditional triangle for someplace else.
The Soho Square with pepperoni is probably the best slice in the city.
Avneesh KohliApril 15, 2018Can’t go wrong with the pepperoni squares and vodka pizza slices. Probably my favorite pizza in NYC
Probably some of the best pizza in Manhattan, but the line can be downright obnoxious (both in length and the people in it), gird your loins accordingly.
J CrowleyMay 30, 2012No joke - the Vodka Sauce slice is one of the best I've ever had. Grab a side of Prosciutto balls (with ricotta) and a window seat. People watch and stuff your face like a Creepy McFatso!
Juan RestrepoMarch 4, 2019Had the Sicilian, pep, and the grandma slice. All truly top notch. Worth the 30 minute wait? Maybe this time
- Get the spicy square. Pepperoni for dayz. (Honestly, don't waste your time with anything else, the spice square is why you're here).
Simon KratzerDecember 26, 2016Go for a spicy spring, it's massive! (with extra salami on the picture :))
Get the pepperoni. It’s so good, and they are very generous with the pepperoni. Worth it for $4.50 especially after a night of drinking.
Ben K.November 23, 2015One of the best slices in NYC: the square pepperoni. Also try the vodka slice.
Their pepperoni squares are great. The dough is thicker but it's really tasty and kinda chewy. A nice alternative to your regular NY slice.
Albert TongJuly 4, 2017It's all about the spicy spring street pizza. Pan square pepperoni slice. Great crust and crispy pepperoni. Not that spicy actually.
Bee WilliamsJanuary 8, 2016The pizza here is super good! We got the pepperoni Sicilian and it was amazing!!!!
Honghui YuNovember 10, 2017Get one of their square slices. It's what they're known for and it's fucking delicious.
- square slice - loaded with crispy pepperoni - is one of the best you’ll find
Garett PressAugust 13, 2014Spicy spring and vodka and everything in between. Some of the best slices in NYC no doubt about it.
First We FeastAugust 3, 2014"No other square can compare," claims Prince Street Pizza, and who are we to argue? The Sicilian slice here—deemed the "Prince Perfection"—is crunchy, chewy, and surprisingly light and airy. Read more
Alex RichardsJuly 30, 2015This is one of NYC's best pizza joints. Grab a slice or two and look at the photos of celebs on the walls.
Boshika TaraDecember 31, 2018I can eat everything here, but for first time visit I suggest Pepperoni pizza and Margherita pizza. Also want to avoid the long lines, then go early like at 10am.
This is the best tomato sauce in town. Any slice or square is amazing. My absolute fav is the pepperoni square, not the slice. Crunchy, greasy goodness...
Jeffrey KaoJune 7, 2017A New Yorker staple. Grab a SoHo Square (the one with dem crispy pepperonis) and munch it while you crush the streets of SoHo with your Pizza Swag.
JeffreySeptember 6, 2013Vodka slice or Soho square - Prince St has the right doughy consistency, and step-up options like a vodka slice and square slices topped with spicy sopressata and fresh mozz.
Danny NathanApril 7, 2019Get the grandma slice. Less "traditionally NY" but so tasty. And go at an off time to avoid crazy lines.
If you want a whole pie you can order delivery or pickup through an app, if you visit, grab a slice or two of the spicy spring squares.
SolJanuary 2, 2019Pepperoni slice is the best Sicilian you can get, better when fresh so eat it right away.
BaturalpSeptember 10, 2018Get a slice of square pizzas. You won’t regret it however this place gets packed on the weekends.
Eric HoJanuary 5, 2017Best slice I've had in NYC 🍕. Follow me on Instagram @EricHoRaw for more food adventures.
The first time I took a bite in to their vodka slice, it tasted like I was sent to a new flavorful dimension. The cheese on that slice was great quality too!! Square pepperoni slice also great!
Valerie SecklerApril 9, 2013Prince Street's Sicilian slice is outstanding. So is a crispy pepperoni topping. Sauce stars. Still, the $3.95 price surprises. Celeb photos dot this near hole-in-the-wall. Streisand is in the house.
AmateurConciergeJune 21, 2019Very solid slice. Not the best on the island but top 3-5 downtown. The lines are annoying but whatever. Get a square slice with Pepperoni and shut up. The whole neighborhood is sceney what u expect
Julia MontiSeptember 22, 2015Best pizza I've had in New York City by a landslide. Sicilian style pepperoni. Perfection. I'll definitely take friends here when they visit.
Tabitha JohnsonDecember 20, 2016Go at an off hour, the line is not as long. The Spicy Spring is delicious!
The vodka sauce slice is great, but before you start eating, make sure to blot some of the oil off the top of it. You'll need three napkins. You'll feel less like death afterward.
Connie XiaoFebruary 9, 2017A fresh-out-the-oven square slice of pepperoni pizza at Prince Street = the pizza of my dreams 🤤🍕❤️
Paul HuangMay 16, 2018The pepperoni pizza here is what you come here for. They don't place the pepperonis on the pizza, they DUMP them on!
Louis BitskoJune 28, 2016The square pepperoni is unmatched for pizza in the area. None of the fancy stuff. Classic Great
jake furstNovember 29, 2012everything you could want in a New York slice: thin and crunchy crust, sweet and tangy sauce, fresh mozz and the whole thing's so damn hot that it burns the roof of your mouth. YES.
1,061 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Prince Street Pizza
27 Prince St (btwn Mott & Elizabeth St)
New York, NY 10012
United States
New York, NY 10012
United States
Located in the heart of SoHo and featuring a traditional exposed brick décor and seating for twelve, the restaurant will offer curb side pick up allowing customers to drive or bike up to the storefront and have their order brought out to them.
Closed until 10:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Tue, Thu–Sun
- 10:00 AM–3:00 AM
- Wed
- 10:00 AM–Midnight
(212) 966-4100
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 9.1
"This place has an old school diner vibe with draft Budweiser and solid pizza. Plus there's awesome rap music always playing. Try a slice of Sicilian."
Jamie Lonie - 9.1
"So delicious. Pepperoni, cheese, fresh mozzarella--any way you want it."
Alex Robertson - 8.8
"Kale and manchego salad is amazing"
Alex Elias
Appears on 2,785 lists
The 25 Best Pizza Places in NYC
Created by Foursquare City Guide
25 items • 397 followers
Created by Allison D.
199 items • 88 followers
Created by D
161 items • 213 followers
