See all
40 photos

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

(Now Closed)

Seafood Restaurant and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$

Key West

Save

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

26 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Michelle RJune 2, 2017
Had a trio with lobster thermador, Thai curry with shrimp, and mahi mahi over mashed potatoes. Everything was great! Came with a spicy cornbread with broccoli in it. Yum!!! Mahi was my fave!
Jacqueline FlemingDecember 31, 2013
We loved this place so much, we visited twice on a recent trip. Lobster Mac, yes. The Chicken & Waffles also amazing.
Andy RiesenbergJanuary 27, 2013
great place, great service. Not your cookie cutter tourist restaurant. Sit outside. The appetizer trio (shrimp, ceviche, and lobster Mac n cheese) was my fav.
Ann ZuccardyDecember 25, 2010
Off the beaten path, thank goodness! Tuna watermelon ceviche was delicate and light. Hogfish with banana salsa just right. Everything was perfect down to broccoli filled muffins. 5 stars, a new fave!
KathyApril 21, 2014
Light pan-seared fish with banana salsa is the best. Light fare. There's a story behind the massive exhaust fan in the middle of the restaurant.
GulfscapesOctober 4, 2011
Tonight pan-seared hogfish w/ banana salsa, grilled black grouper w/ lime butter sauce, seafood marinara in a gremolatta tossed penne pasta, black bean soup, lobster mac & cheese
CamillaMarch 29, 2012
Great place, friendly serving, lovely food(especially surf'n'turf and lobster macaroni and cheese)- not a touriattrap as many places on Key West
Kate FurmanFebruary 8, 2016
Start your meal with the app sampler. The restaurant is often full, but usually there's seating outside.
Stephanie MSeptember 15, 2013
Fred is awesome. Great service and creative dishes served with a passion. Loved it!
Jeff PainterJuly 3, 2013
Great food, great service, everything we ate was fantastic... you MUST get the lobster mac & cheese.....
Marsha NaifyJanuary 30, 2015
Wonderful fish dishes. Nice heat to some of the food. Highly recommend.
Don VancoJanuary 31, 2015
Great local business - cozy with awesome daily specials
Mythai GatoMarch 10, 2012
Been here 5+ times
...it is off beaten path, but worth finding...food is fresh and tasty...reservations recommended...yum!
Mythai GatoMarch 10, 2012
Been here 5+ times
...excellent food and service...a must go to!...make a reservation...totally worth finding!
MSZWNY MikeAugust 25, 2015
Everything!!!
Eddie GahrmannJuly 19, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Ditto on the Mac and Cheese with Lobster! Also, the chocolate quesadilla for dessert is excellent too!
JenKuduMarch 15, 2011
Lobster mac and cheese I love you!!!!! Just get it as an entree... I nearly licked the bowl :)
Sarah LeCroyJune 26, 2011
The special marinara with swordfish and shrimp is unbelievable!!
NikkiJuly 8, 2010
The bacon wrapped scallops are a must...they melt in your mouth & all menu items are the owners personal recipies
Mike BehringerFebruary 15, 2012
The lobster mac & cheese is to die for!
Sylvia MayáAugust 21, 2013
Don't believe the hype about this place. Fish is fresh, yes; but the dishes are incredibly mediocre & bland (including the infamous lobster mac), and not cheap.
Dominik StreicherJune 21, 2011
Very good lobster with macaroni cheese!!!:)
Andy StevensJanuary 15, 2012
"Near to perfect, far from normal"
ChrisJune 11, 2013
Wonderful food!!!
R. Scot ForsteFebruary 21, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Ask Alberto about his pants.
Kate MatulayAugust 23, 2011
Kid robot toys & funky decor.

40 Photos

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

Appears on 59 lists