Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Favorite St Augustine restaurants

Favorite St Augustine restaurants

Creator Avatar
Created by Randy Sisto • Updated On: November 18, 2016
Cap's on the Water is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

1. Cap's on the Water

9.1
4325 Myrtle St, St. Augustine, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 107 tips and reviews
Casa Maya is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

2. Casa Maya

17 Hypolita St (Charlotte St.), St. Augustine, FL
Mexican Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews
Mango Mangos is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

3. Mango Mangos

8.9
700 A1a Beach Blvd (A St), St. Augustine, FL
Caribbean Restaurant · 77 tips and reviews

4. Cold Cow

St. Augustine, FL
Ice Cream Parlor · 2 tips and reviews
Tedi's Old Tyme Ice Cream is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

5. Tedi's Old Tyme Ice Cream

8.1
65 Saint George St, St. Augustine, FL
Ice Cream Parlor · 13 tips and reviews
Columbia Restaurant is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

6. Columbia Restaurant

8.6
98 Saint George St (at Hypolita St), St. Augustine, FL
Spanish Restaurant · 165 tips and reviews
Michael's Tasting Room is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

7. Michael's Tasting Room

8.3
25 Cuna St, St. Augustine, FL
Tapas Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews
A1A Burrito Works Taco Shop is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

8. A1A Burrito Works Taco Shop

8.8
671 A1a Beach Blvd, St. Augustine, FL
Mexican Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews
Yard Bird is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

9. Yard Bird

117 King St, St. Augustine, FL
American Restaurant · Lincolnville · 13 tips and reviews
Cone Heads Ice Cream is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

10. Cone Heads Ice Cream

8.9
570 A1A Beach Blvd, St. Augustine, FL
Ice Cream Parlor · 15 tips and reviews
Turtle Shack Cafe is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

11. Turtle Shack Cafe

8.8
2123 N Ocean Shore Blvd (btw N. 22nd & N. 21st Street), Flagler Beach, FL
American Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews
Playa Chac Mool is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

12. Playa Chac Mool

8.4
105 D St, St. Augustine, FL
Mexican Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews
Blackfly The Restaurant is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

13. Blackfly The Restaurant

8.7
108 Anastasia Blvd, St. Augustine, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews
Ned's Southside Kitchen is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

14. Ned's Southside Kitchen

8.0
2450 US Highway 1 S (near Lewis Point Rd), St. Augustine, FL
American Restaurant · 27 tips and reviews
Mojo Old City BBQ is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

15. Mojo Old City BBQ

8.8
5 Cordova St (at Tolomato Ln), St. Augustine, FL
BBQ Joint · 81 tips and reviews
Beachcomber is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

16. Beachcomber

8.3
2 A St, Saint Augustine Beach, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 37 tips and reviews
Barley Republic is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

17. Barley Republic

8.9
Spanish St (btw Hypolita & Cuna), St. Augustine, FL
Pub · 42 tips and reviews
Salt Life Food Shack is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

18. Salt Life Food Shack

8.4
321 A1a Beach Blvd, Saint Augustine Beach, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 61 tips and reviews
World Famous Oasis Restaurant is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

19. World Famous Oasis Restaurant

8.1
4000 A1a S (at Ocean Trace Rd.), St. Augustine, FL
American Restaurant · 66 tips and reviews
Old City Farmers Market is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

20. Old City Farmers Market

8.6
1340 A1a South at the Ampitheater parking area, St. Augustine, FL
Farmers Market · 7 tips and reviews
The Ice Plant is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

21. The Ice Plant

9.0
110 Riberia St, St. Augustine, FL
Cocktail Bar · 72 tips and reviews
Al's Pizza is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

22. Al's Pizza

7.2
1 Saint George St, St. Augustine, FL
Pizzeria · 26 tips and reviews
Captain's BBQ, Bait & Tackle is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

23. Captain's BBQ, Bait & Tackle

8.8
5842 N. Oceanshore Blvd, Palm Coast, FL
BBQ Joint · 28 tips and reviews
High Tides at Snack Jack is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

24. High Tides at Snack Jack

7.9
2805 S Ocean Shore Blvd, Flagler Beach, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 51 tips and reviews
Golden Lion Cafe is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

25. Golden Lion Cafe

8.0
501 N Oceanshore Blvd (5th Street N.), Flagler Beach, FL
Restaurant · 57 tips and reviews
Mi Carnal Taqueria is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

26. Mi Carnal Taqueria

8.4
2602 US Highway 1 S, St. Augustine, FL
Mexican Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews
Fisherman’s Dock is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

27. Fisherman’s Dock

7.7
2125 A1a S, St. Augustine, FL
Seafood Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews
Culinary Outfitters is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

28. Culinary Outfitters

7.3
9 S Dixie Hwy, St. Augustine, FL
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews
Portugal Wine Bar & Grill is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

29. Portugal Wine Bar & Grill

7.6
15 Palm Harbor Village Way, Palm Coast, FL
Portuguese Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews
4 Rivers Smokehouse is one of Favorite St Augustine restaurants.

30. 4 Rivers Smokehouse

9220 Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville, FL
BBQ Joint · Southeast Jacksonville · 81 tips and reviews