Schmackary's

Schmackary's

Bakery$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
Save
Share
8.8/10
1,275
ratings
  • Stars
  • Stars
    Go here. Experience the cookies. It's worth it.
  • Tips
    Ketellyn M.
    "never thought I would say this but: try the maple bacon cookie!"(14 Tips)
    Mike F.
    "Cookies and Cream cookie and Chocolate Explosion cookie are amazing."(12 Tips)
    Kevin
    "In love with their ice cream sandwich with the funfetti cookies"(8 Tips)
    Nancy C.
    "I love the red velvet cookie complete with a cream cheese frosting."(8 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon272 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • cookies
  • maple bacon
  • trendy
  • casual
  • coffee
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Nate S.heart icon on user image
    Nate SJune 5, 2018
    Been here 100+ times
    A bakery that does one thing really well: cookies! Try the funfetti or chocolate chip if it's your first time. Trust me, it won't be your last time... you'll keep coming back to try more!
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Olivier M.heart icon on user image
    Olivier MDecember 14, 2017
    Great place for coffee and cookie and warm atmosphere! Xmas spirit is at is best here; enjoying delicious home made cookies and latte and staring at the falling snow.
  • Shai B.heart icon on user image
    Shai Ben SadonSeptember 3, 2017
    Everything is marked for allergens! Selection varies daily, with some really great options. Also, day-old cookies are 1 dollar each. Best place for sweets for gluten/egg/nut/whatever free folks
  • Lenny G.heart icon on user image
    Lenny GalloJanuary 2, 2017
    Been here 5+ times
    One of the best Chocolate chip cookies I've ever had. Most of their cookies have a little sea-salt which brings out the flavor. Something so simple adds so much. Worth the wait in line.
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Jonathan L.heart icon on user image
    Jonathan LovitzMay 12, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    Never have I ever had a better cookie in my life!!!!!! Try the red velvet, peanut butter, and maple-bacon-- you won't regret it! The best staff and an owner of any bakery in New York City!
  • Harumi U.
    Harumi UAugust 17, 2014
    Here you remember that not all cookies are created equal. The more you buy, the cheaper per cookie becomes. If you feel like ice cream, try their ice cream sandwich. You can pick any 2 cookies.
  • Melanie M.heart icon on user image
    Melanie MaddoxOctober 4, 2016
    Just stepping in the door brings a smile to your face. Love their seasonal cookies - especially for fall: sweet corn with cranberries and pecans, and maple bacon! Yes, bacon! Mmm mmm.
  • Tingheart icon on user image
    TingFebruary 20, 2016
    The cookies here are crusty and chewy at the same time. If only it is less sweet, then it will be perfect! Great flavours too.
  • Brittany G.heart icon on user image
    Brittany GoodwynSeptember 7, 2014
    They give you a generous serving of ice cream with the ice cream sandwiches. The cookies were well worth the trek from the other side of town. A+++
  • Devontaheart icon on user image
    DevontaOctober 19, 2018
    Chocolate Chip Cookies made with love and sugar. You won’t regret stoping by this place.
  • Karman D.heart icon on user image
    Karman DheelApril 3, 2018
    The Funfeti cookie is out of this world good. Also try the vegan cookie with coconut & pineapple, it’s surprisingly delicious!
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • BuzzFeed
    BuzzFeedAugust 16, 2016
    Schmackary’s Cookies are by far the best in the city! Especially their funfetti flavor. Read more
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • honeywhatscooking.comheart icon on user image
    Red Velvet Cookie topped w/cream cheese frosting is disturbingly good. Not too sweet either.
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Patricia L.heart icon on user image
    Patricia LazzarottoSeptember 8, 2015
    Best best cookie in town and of the world! I absolutly love this place, and the service is awesome just like these cookies!
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Luna J.heart icon on user image
    Luna JayAugust 20, 2014
    I've never really liked cookies because they're either too sickly sweet, gooey, or too hard. But Schmackary's Key Lime with pistachios, red velvet, yogi bear were fantastic! Fav was yogibear mmmmmmm
  • Tessa D.heart icon on user image
    Tessa DomzalskiNovember 24, 2015
    Everything is AMAZING!!! I love the maple bacon cookie. Go for the 6 for $14 deal, trust me, you'll want that many.
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Gia F.
    Gia FarruggiaJuly 27, 2013
    Try the red velvet cookie. It's literally the best cookie I've ever had in my entire life. On top of that, the staff is always super nice and the place itself is soooo cute. Love love love.
  • Jonathan P.
    Jonathan PevarnekMay 27, 2016
    Fantastic place to go for some delicious cookies, they always have new tasty and interesting flavours
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Adrienne C.heart icon on user image
    Adrienne CFebruary 24, 2013
    Maple bacon is pretty solid but I think the real winner was Red Velvet. We tried the two aforementioned as well as Blueberry, Choc PB, Ginger, Cookies n Cream, and lemon poppy shmackentash.
  • Lloyd G.heart icon on user image
    Lloyd GJuly 28, 2015
    Absolutely amazing cookies. Not too small, not too big with a great selection. Small amount of seating.
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • emily m.heart icon on user image
    emily mcgillJuly 22, 2015
    get in line for some of the best cookies in the city, made fresh daily on site. you never know who you'll spot when grabbing a coffee to start your day.
  • Caroline L.heart icon on user image
    Caroline LeSeptember 15, 2014
    Big and deliciously balanced cookies! Try the maple bacon when it's in season, it was absolutely perfect
  • Ivan Z.heart icon on user image
    Ivan ZimnukhovApril 14, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Best latte in Hell's Kitchen hands down, stands up to the best in all of Manhattan. Cookies are good, too, but they don't blow my mind all that much, I come here for coffee.
  • Tasting Table
    Tasting TableJuly 12, 2012
    Dunk sugar-bomb cookies (such as the Cookies & Cream made with dark cocoa powder, white chocolate, Oreo pieces and vanilla buttercream frosting) in chilled milk or hot coffee until midnight here: Read more
  • Liz C.heart icon on user image
    Liz ChoyFebruary 25, 2014
    The Maple Bacon cookie was pretty awesome, a perfect balance of sweet and salty. The Red Velvet cookie was a little too sweet for my liking, with frosting and chocolate chips.
  • Daniel R.heart icon on user image
    Daniel RayJune 8, 2013
    Now that Coffee Pot is closed this is my favorite HK coffee place. Cookies are great and coffee is better than that burnt and acidic Starbucks swill. Nice friendly vibe.
  • Nina S.heart icon on user image
    Nina SNovember 5, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    Smores cookie awesome as was the Chocolate chip came in on a whim from searching four square excellent find!
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Rachel W.heart icon on user image
    Rachel WangOctober 11, 2014
    Been here 10+ times
    Maple bacon cookies make for the perfect breakfast item! The staff is always super friendly and this sweet spot is also open late too
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Adela M.
    Adela MouJanuary 6, 2013
    The key lime cookie was delicious. Sweet and tart with pistachio pieces that gave it some nice texture. The apple crisp cookie was like a revved up oatmeal cookie - amazing.
  • Andrew C.heart icon on user image
    Andrew CSeptember 23, 2016
    OMG... it's like insomnia cookies but much more unique - such a bigger selection and variety of amazingly delicious cookies, brownies, cupcakes, and more!!!
  • Katie W.heart icon on user image
    Katie WillardJune 29, 2015
    GREAT cookies. Cozy atmosphere. Not afraid to experiment with the salty-sweet cookie combo in the form of the chocolate pretzel cookie.
  • Kate F.
    Kate FurmanOctober 25, 2016
    $2.75 each or 2 for $5 for a large freshly baked cookie. Maple bacon is really good!
  • Benjamin V.heart icon on user image
    Benjamin ValdezOctober 30, 2015
    This place has awesome cookies! Try the maple bacon! Sooo good! If you dislike salty stuff, stay away from the cookies with sea salt. Very salty.
  • Sophia L.heart icon on user image
    Sophia LevdanskiNovember 25, 2015
    Their cookies are the best, huge and very filling. Their shakes are great too. Try the maple bacon, red velvet or smores
  • Jonathan L.heart icon on user image
    Jonathan LovitzSeptember 8, 2012
    Been here 25+ times
    The most delicious cookies, nicest staff, and exactly the kind of local, neighborhood hang out HK needed! Yum! The Peanut butter cup cookie is amazing!
  • Ana Q.
    Ana QuillinanAugust 14, 2013
    The key is to trust the bakers, what a fantastic and eclectic selection and oh my, the calorie count is not something I'd want to know so don't ever tell me
  • Kamaria M.heart icon on user image
    Kamaria MionDecember 5, 2016
    Smells amazing- you can't walk by without treating your self. Maple bacon is a good way to go
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Ashley H.heart icon on user image
    Ashley HornJanuary 18, 2016
    Go for the red velvet for something a bit different. Cookies without frosting tend to be a bit drier and crumbling (in my experience).
  • Vivek P.
    Vivek PradhanJune 28, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Every cookie is phenomenal. Favorites include key lime, red velvet, blueberry cobbler, sea-salt/chocolate. The coffee is also really good.
  • Bryan B.heart icon on user image
    Bryan ButlerNovember 16, 2018
    Fresh cookies, coffee, and hot chocolate are great after work or a show. Even better with the frosty air.
  • Elizabeth B.
    Elizabeth BursteinMarch 26, 2017
    This place is amazing!! The lucky charm and peanut butter cookies were incredible
  • Cameron G.heart icon on user image
    Cameron GidariOctober 2, 2016
    Best cookies in the city. Love the maple bacon and s'mores.
    Upvoted Feb 4
  • Amy
    AmyAugust 1, 2015
    Super friendly staff behind the counter. Good chill music. Share a brownie. Very chocolatey. Coffee is good, too.
  • Melody E.
    Melody EwingMay 20, 2017
    Celiacs beware. Tested a couple of the Yogi Bare cookies with my Nima Sensor; came back positive for gluten. High risk of cross-contamination here, sadly.
  • Katherine M.heart icon on user image
    Katherine MullisJuly 8, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    The staff know me and always make me feel welcome. The shakes take a while to make, but otherwise it's very efficient service, and it's always worth it.
  • Mike F.heart icon on user image
    Mike FriedlichMay 13, 2017
    Some of the best cookies in NYC. Cookies and Cream cookie and Chocolate Explosion cookie are amazing.
  • Theresa R.heart icon on user image
    Theresa RoldanMarch 7, 2016
    Cookie heaven. I can vouch for the monster, the s'more, and the chocolate chip cookies. Spot on!
  • Nate T.heart icon on user image
    Nate TinnerMarch 25, 2015
    Huge cookies at a price you might expect in NYC, but they're so good (w/ very generous icing). Cinnamon bun was excellent as well.
  • Jinnie L.
    Jinnie LOctober 13, 2014
    my friend dragged me here to try their cookies even though I didn't want any. *however* I'm glad she did! >_<// maple bacon and cookies & scream!!! Yum♥
  • Alvaro S.heart icon on user image
    Alvaro Sanchez DiazMarch 8, 2020
    I gave it a second chance with the Lemon and Poppy seeds cookie and now I kinda get why everyone recommends this place
Photos964 Photos

Related Searches

  • schmackary's new york •
  • schmackary's new york photos •
  • schmackary's new york location •
  • schmackary's new york address •
  • schmackary's new york •
  • schmackary's new york •
  • schmackarys new york •
  • schmackery's new york •
  • schmackerys new york •
  • shmackary's new york •
  • shmackarys new york •
  • shmackery's new york •
  • shmackerys new york •
  • schmackary's hell's kitchen new york

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA