Scotty's Diner
(Now Closed)Diner$$$$
Murray Hill, New York
109 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Gabrielle BrunnerMarch 27, 2013Great food, great prices, great staff. Loved it. It was our go-to place when everything else was closed, or when we wanted a nice and quick breakfast.
AlysonJanuary 14, 2013Super quick service from friendly, attentive staff. Great if you're in a rush. Breakfast 24 hours, and you can't go wrong with bacon, eggs, and potatoes.
Cool retro diner with a very friendly staff. Big choice on the menu and delicious coffee that keeps coming. This will be our breakfast-spot for the week!
Delicious food and excellent staff. Go for the omelette with American cheese and order Some bacon on the side. Great place to have breakfast, lunch, brunch or dinner!
EdSeptember 8, 2017Service is amazing and food is tasty, but the general display of the place and the kitchen undermines the experience of an otherwise great dinner
Erika DeMartiniOctober 2, 2016One of the places I will surely check out when I'm in the area! Food is served quick and they are tasty! Their waffles are to die for!
SV Ah MaNovember 21, 2015Jetlag made us have breakfast there at 4 in the morning,just the fact that you can makes it awesome
Lina BodestadJuly 17, 2013When you get tired of Starbucks, gcome here for an authentic, movie-style, all-American diner breakfast. Staff is very friendly and you're guaranteed not to leave hungry.
Boris NovikovDecember 9, 2013Great place with good food and friendly waiters. I recommend to have Chef Salad, it's really good and filling.
MidgeMadge DFebruary 1, 2018Kinda love this no frills old school diner. Service is amazing and the omelettes are perfect and diner-y
I come here pretty often got lunch and the staff couldn't be nicer! I've only had something I didn't like once, and they were all too happy to get me something else free of charge.
Suzie HunterOctober 20, 2013Delicious! Absolutely love this place. Killer omelets. Epic turkey bacon. Visa and MasterCard accepted. What more could a girl want? Beam me up, Scotty!
bellatrix beginsJuly 20, 2015It's what you expect from a diner: Delicious food for good value (even side dishes come in huge portions) and local beer available.
JustinOctober 12, 2015Go for breakfast you will not regret it! Absolutely delicious, huge portions & friendly, incredibly efficient staff!
Christian SkovenNovember 29, 2017Great coffee, pancakes, sausages and bacon. Surprisingly attentive and friendly service. Egg whites were however quite runny.
Fernanda SilvaJanuary 2, 2015Try the Vermicelli Primavera. It's probably the best pasta I've ever had! Wonderful service, attentive and funny people.
Dillon ForrestMay 20, 2012Three eggs any style with either bacon, sausage, or ham -- great deal! Overeasy eggs cooked perfectly. Bacon was dry, crisp, thick, and awesome. 24-hr breakfast!
Karin RendelmanSeptember 21, 2011Around the corner from the bf so we found it accidentally & so glad we did...the service is amazing...the food is solid...diners like this absolutely rock<3
Ollie MartinAugust 7, 2018The French Toast is great, but putting butter on it is totally unnecessary
Dave IlagMarch 12, 2013Awesome place to eat. They def have the best sausage I've had with a breakfast meal. Portions are pretty good too!
Larissa BSeptember 17, 2014Great late night plate! A must to settle the stomach after bars that don't serve food!
Stephanie LittlerDecember 11, 2018Corned beef hash, French toast and bacon... perfect! Really great service too!- Very Nice staff, and really good eggs. Try three eggs, sunny Side up. And ask for a muffin: delicious and BIG!
One of my favorite mid town diner breakfast spots, great corn beef hash and eggs!
Tanya JaryczewskiAugust 24, 2017Corned beef hash with eggs over-easy - yum. Great service and good coffee.
NancerellaMarch 7, 2015One of few oldie but goodie type of place in Manhattan... Great breakfast spot
James LApril 28, 2014Great cheap middle of the night food. Had the Mexican chicken sandwich which was very good.
Alien InvaderApril 21, 2013What an awesome place. Great Eggs Benedict, lots of coffee refils and nice, attentive staff.
Srinivas VasudevanFebruary 4, 2015A nice place, tried their Belgian Waffle. Nothing out of the world. The staff were really nice and the coffee served was not bad.
Katie S.October 12, 2011Very courteous and attentive wait staff; If you request it, they will complimentarily provide you with the day's NY Post to read while you wait for & eat your meal!
Morgan DillardMarch 13, 2015If you leave hungry, you did something wrong. The omelettes are amazing!
Jeff BrittainSeptember 30, 2017Great authentic New York deli. Super friendly. Super fast. Super good!
Arvind DasJune 25, 2013Quick service, nice staff large helpings. The cottage cheese with Turkey was great.
Chris WrightMarch 21, 2011Awesome place, staff were super friendly! Try out the milkshakes, the waiter added fresh strawberries when I ordered a second!
Carlos LepesqueurOctober 15, 2017The experience there was awful. The service is being done mostly with written orders and waiters yelling the request to the chef. Orders arriving at the table in incompleteness are the usual.
Geoffrey RichardMarch 27, 2013The staff is really friendly and portions are very nice. Try the sausages!
170 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Scotty's Diner
336 Lexington Ave (btwn 39th St & 40th St)
New York, NY 10016
United States
New York, NY 10016
United States
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 24 Hours
(212) 986-1520
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Music
No
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch
Drinks
Full Bar
See More
You might also like
- 7.9
"Lovely place in downtown! Great the pancakes and the granola is pretty sweet and not very healthy."
Eleonora Carisi - 7.6
"Great breKfast try the western omelette sandwich :-) Delish"
Kathy O'Shea - 8.8
"Tuna melt, breakfast sandwich, and pancakes all insanely inventive and tasty. Momofuku alum elevating the diner."
Noah Weiss
Places people like to go after Scotty's Diner
- 9.5
"This place never fails to impress me. Probably my best park in the big apple. Yoga classes, live music, nice surroundings, books and great waffle place, could you ask for more?"
Joury Al - 9.7
"Great park to walk and bike. Enjoyable. Always something going on. Kayak, merry go round, zoo, concerts, playground"
Angi W - 9.0
"Great way to take in the whole city. We went on a Friday at 1pm and there was no line. Staff are very helpful and courteous."
Chad Curry
Appears on 233 lists
Created by Femke van Wel - Brouwer
82 items • 9 followers
Greasy Spoon - New York Venues
Created by badgeunlock.com
70 items • 377 followersCreated by John
30 items • 142 followers